i don't see commissioner trasvina? >> i'm a little troubled and struggling with you seem to be -- side miss tammy saying yes the unblocked 4 windows agreed upon in 88 applies to this property. . this proposal. and at least as i understand her, miss tammy is saying that those windows are still unobstructed you are saying they are obstructed. had are they obstructed by. activity this is go on decks. there they are if you love privacy we will put up a winds screen that will block the vow of the ocean the folks still have. they were guaranteed to keep with the bargain struck by the formy zoning administrator 35 years ago. he bargained this thing. . and that's what we are looking at is the all the activity this is go on a deck. is what the obstructions will be. and you know no one can. yop where upon shill find this support for b activities are includes in kruck. these are on the roof. they are roof decks if you go become to the language of the nsr it is 2 part. on or over. and these are on. plus once you read in the settle

thank you. >> commissioner trasviÑa? >> john trasviÑa: thank you. showing some restraint and not being accused of appealing on as egregious and the harm that has already been stated. i would like to know, the basis for your recommendation regarding the attic. after somebody removes the windows, what's the basis for prohibiting storage in a window less part of the property that's otherwise an attic? >> well, we are basically reinforcing what the applicant is asking for on their permit which is the attic space will not be used for habitation or storage. we want to make sure that for the recording on the property so there is no confusion. >> are they asking for no storage or asking for no habitation? >> both no habitation and storage. >> great. the other question is what is the difference on the living room versus the office? >> you mean the dining room? >> sorry, dining room. you are recommending further restrictions on that. is it a matter of redesign or construction? >> no, it's just sort of, i'm going to put up the floor plan and maybe that will he