with the commissioner turman. and i am allowed to say that we put him back on there. and good commissioner be made better. >> and the better commission will be made the best. >> we can't lose with this man. with ferguson, staten island, cleveland, north, charleston, south carolina, and in the news, san francisco cannot look the other way. and says that it is not here too. >> we do have challenges in the city. but with a man like mr. turman and the other commissioners who are doing a great job, we will be able to meet the challenge, and bring about the kind of police community relations and in which police will be held accountable and the community will be held accountable and we will see ourselves as just human beings working together to make a safer, saner, and stellar community, thank you very much. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please? >> and if you intend to speak, if you would not mind to come up along the walk where the doors are that would be great thank you. >> goods morning. supervisors and members. and thank you for having us here today. i am here to speak

. >> okay commissioner turman. >> my question is probably more to the chief chief i keep seeing inover and over the need not of the duty for the traffic status i understand we're not seeing repeat of those one the first time and the astonishment and retrain i'm not taking issue what was the last time we sent out the quarter in saying how important this data is it is done. >> so every bulletin is put out every two years i'm happy if you want me to put a bulletin out. >> i think because the keeps seeing themselves reoccur on the broader i think a adjourn reminder and i have to put it in prospective we wrote hundred and 29 thousand tickets last year so you've heard the tickets where we didn't do the 5 data it was not hundred and 29 astonishment you probably i mean the exception rather than the rule director hicks will agree we've gone through thirty this progressive mode the data is far less than it used to be that's correct i applauded u applaud the department but it is it is the one you need it didn't report on just to see we've done the things to do to everyone i'm going saying i'll fa

it clarified. >> and commissioner turman if i might i mean at ms.ranco it is the interpretation of the employer what the city attorney has o pined an employer is each department of the city and so what it labor code prohibit is one employer providing another employer affirmative. >> i know the section now. >> okay it is interesting interpretation of the labor code but okay. thank you very much >> okay. do i have a motion to file the quarterly report. >> second. >> all in favor, say i. opposed? motion passes unanimously >> line item 3 public comment the public comment can address the commission not with the agenda for today is the people shall address the commission as a whole no commissioners are to respond to the public but may i provide a comment, however they shall rerefrain from the conversations with the public limit your conversations to 3 minutes. >> unbelievable. >> welcome. >> i see the commander maddox he's no traffic and i brought it up i heard last night a interview with the director of salt lake city on traffic they have a great program

. >> commissioner turman. >> i'd like to calendar for the next available meeting a discussion and action item to consider ca a change to the commissions monthly schedule. >> okay. we can take that up in june great anything further commissioner and we're going to have a report back on the department of appendixes on the departments sort of performance or compliance with the 21st century leasing report. >> yes. that's on the docket only a matter of scheduling. >> okay hearing nothing further let's get to public comment. well. >> hello sf i sit here and here hear you talk about the crip and this is a mthd by sometimes i don't don't know if you're black or gay why people hate you there's no help for us because one over rules to leave you out but i was 54 and martin luther king and malcolm x died and 39 we've enjoyed on the i want to say last year, he fell and broke at 4 and howard street but it made it better i can carry many pie pocket the bold head i understand this year there's a republican president candidates between 5th and 6th and howard that's a good thing on howard but mainly as i a

. >> good evening director hicks and good evening commissioner president loftus and commissioner turman members of the commission. >> i'm just taking our time now. >> (laughter). >> chief suhr and members of the public. >> mayor brown asked me. >> are you going to remind the chief of last week. >> recent developments at the appendixes on monday we had a building where appendixes is housed on van ness experienced a two hour power outage and that power outage blew up our phenomenon system it crashed and damaged the hard drive so the occ was without phone number stiffer from monday to noon to today to noon and anyone call would only get a busy signal no voicemail it was, of course terribly indevelop for people calling and officers that had scheduled intrifz and the like so our reception desk was not able to receive phone calls of the rest of our staff and the voicemail messages were missed on the phones in the morning exist, however as of noon today they became operational so if anyone attempted to call during the time our phones were down we encourage you to please call us back and we wil

. >> thank you, captain i should have recognized you other questions sorry commissioner turman. >> just a couple of quick questions thank you by the way, commander it was very thorough i'd like to hear about the block the box to highlight people listening at home could you talk about how it operation works and what is the effectiveness. >> it was rocketed the traffic was not flowing in the downtown quarters up to the bay bridge in december we got together and came up with a plan that our parks and beaches unit will take the area around city hall and block the box and make sure the directions r are clear and the traffic officers company k will take the area around brilliant street along supplementing with the dp t parking tithe on the end and parking tickets on the upper end all the higher intersections and second and it is no shortage of violations the idea to keep the intersection clear you can't pull into the intersection without a clear view. >> the parking street supervisor yee has embraced it seems like an excellent idea to have the awareness on traffic rules with younger people ge

in these vast communities and commissioner turman approached me and other pry minority union groups and asked us to join together in order for us to start diversifying this police department further. and commissioner turman has been responsive when requested to respond to the community on issues, he is someone that we can always count on even in the last minute requests and of course, because of the situation that we find ourselves in right now, san francisco has the nation watching, 60 minutes, called me on friday. and they told me sergeant williams and i am telling you right now, as san francisco can't get this right, no one else is going to. we are depending on you supervisors to do the right thing, and to put commissioner turman back in that seat. thank you. >> thank you very much. >> next >> the city of san francisco sfgtv meeting of the san francisco finance committee occurring may 12, 2015, will begin shortly. >> the city of san francisco sfgtv meeting of the san francisco finance committee occurring may 12, 2015, will begin shortly. >> the city of san francisco sfgtv meeting of

in why don't we invite, commissioner turman up? first of all i want to thank you for your service and if you want to, give us maybe a couple of minutes, and introduction, of you know, your work on the commission, and what you want to be able to accomplish and moving forward as well. >> thank you very much, good morning, chair, avalos and good morning, supervisor cohen and tang, and i want to thank the rules committee for not only holding this special meeting but also i want to thank each of you for the attention that you gave to this matter, and especially during this time in which there are so many issues to consider. and national conversation going on about police community relations, and no one has a right to expect an appointment or a reappointment and i am glad that each of you has taken the careful time to not only hold this special meeting but to meet with me individually to talk about what we see policing like, over the next four years, should i be reappointed. over the last, four years, and i have worked with a dynamic and

justice for all may want i'd like to take roll to call roll commissioner president loftus commissioner turmanhat excused commissioner marshall commissioner dejesus excused excuse me. commissioner mazzucco commissioner hwang and commissioner melar

turman you have 7 minutes to present your case when you're ready. >> thank you, ma'am executive director i want to reserve 3 minutes. >> you wanted to reserve 3 minutes and 3 minutes for rebuttal later would you mind using the other microphone. >> this is acquit all right. thank you. >> go ahead. >> good evening, commissioners sf america taxi appeals it's recognition of the permit to dispatch taxi services transportation code section 1107 which requires at the time that the recognition revocation was issued have 50 medallion holders as well as a visual 2 hundred and 50 service calls for services the problem with the section 1107 is that the stated purpose for the to increase economic activity and utilities of the counterpart transit and other services the problem with section 1107 not a measure that is geared towards increasing or murray's economic activity it is a measure towards protecting larger taxi service dispatch services the problem is sf american taxi is is a small business serving san francisco for thirty years and switching from an original model to one which it must now repor

justice for all may want i'd like to take roll to call roll commissioner president loftus commissioner turman that excused commissioner marshall commissioner dejesus excused excuse me. commissioner mazzucco commissioner hwang and commissioner melara madam president i have quorum and with us the chour areas director of the office of complaints sfgovtv.org good afternoon. welcome to the wednesday, may 6, 2015 police commission meeting inspectors the first line item calendar received and filed the inquires first quarter sfpd status reporting report on the proposals first quarter 2014. >> colleagues you have to items the schufr from the action and the ocii policy matter my discussion. >> chief anyone you want to add. >> director hicks so do i have a motion. > all in favor, say i. > opposed? motion passes inspector the next line item any public comment? line item general public comment judge. to the public that are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the commission except agenda items. with respect to agenda items, your opportunity to address the commission will be afforded when reached in t

turman 3 minutes of rebuttal. >> and in rebuttal i'd like to make a few comments first of all, mr. murray stated that he aspects in terms of dispatches not being reliable okay. he also speaks in terms of it not working or not being a successful dispatch what he didn't say is that sf american dispatch taxi services has failed to meet the dispatch needs that they've been called on to provide dispatch- when individuals called for services no indication and could be no indication simply by a count of numbers we're failing to meet the dispatch needs of persons needing service he further made clear that their - one thing he further didn't clarify there is a clear this is clearly favors disproportionately larger organization larger dispatch services and when the president of the commission asked about the number of dispatch services you know have there been others placed on probation no hard numbers of data war provided which of the first is american the first of a series of which you'll be seeing no one that that information it is within - not being fairly being provided american dispatc