and we are back with tyson slocum director of public citizen's energy program tyson let me ask you about this oil rigging scandal that seems to be emerging here it's kind of reminiscent reminiscent of something that happened ten years ago what's this all about yes the last month the e.u. announced that they were investigating three major oil companies shell b.p. and stadol oil for price fixing key european oil benchmarks that end up affecting oil prices and chemical prices and hundreds of other products on u.s. markets as well of course and what they say is that these oil companies who voluntarily report their trades to a for profit news publication called mcgraw hill and they have an energy division called plaid shirt so they were conspiring with each other to mislead plats to set prices that were financially beneficial for the oil companies but financially disastrous for consumers now as you said this sounds a lot like what happened a decade ago in the united states right around the time of the enron scandal in california federal regulators in the u.s. discovered that natural gas compa