nice recovery in dataflow. which had been growing anyway. and this time, happening right now, we have the data in the area actually outperforming the u.s.n q1. but i might not be linked to the the effect of currency depreciation. we also have the reaction of consumer spending to the drop in inflation. but where the ecb has been absolutely crucial, two things. making this net fiscal loosening financially doable. if you reduce interest rates, you can create those conditions. and second, it is on the banks. the ecb has come under a lot of criticism for the negative rate. and i agree, but at the same time, everything they have been both from the14, delivery and policy side, on the messagehort against the of the banking industry prices. anna: gilles stays with is longer on the program. volkswagen supervisory board meets today to talk about the emissions cheating scandal. he comes a day after the company agreed to buy back cars and compensate u.s. customers in a deal that will cost at least $10 billion. ryan chilcote is at volkswagen headquarters in germany. good to see you. to what extent this morning, draw a line under the scandal, perhaps