that dirk messner, president of the uba. which is wh in president of the uba. the last _ president of the uba. which is why in the last 15 _ president of the uba. which is why in the last 15 months - president of the uba. which is why in the last 15 months thisl why in the last 15 months this government has done more than happened in the previous 16 years. since the government has come on board, we are not there yet, we have gaps, that's why we have climate law, that's why we have climate law, that's why we are at 40% reduction already. we are aiming to be 65. we see that actually the coal that we had to bring on for the war, which was a big topic and rightfully so because we phased out russian fossil fuels. in less than a year, 55% of our imports were from us, gas, so we had to bring a bit of coal although we are phasing down —— from russia. is now been replaced by renewable energy and we are meeting our targets now earlier. it energy and we are meeting our targets now earlier.— targets now earlier. it doesn't look like you _ targets now earlier. it doesn't lo

achieved an average 2% drop "per year," says dirk messner, president of the german environment agency the ubaas done more than happened in the previous 16 years. so, since this government has come on board — we're not there yet, we have gaps. that's why we have climate... crosstalk. ..climate law. we're at 40% reduction already. we're aiming to the 65%. we see that actually, the coal that we had to bring on for the war — which was a big topic, rightfully so — to — because we phased out russian fossil fuels in less than a year. 55% of our imports were from russia — gas. so, we had to bring a bit of coal, although we're phasing down. that has now been replaced by renewable energy. we're meeting our targets actually earlier, so... it doesn't look like you are. but, look, i'm making... crosstalk. on the whole... yeah, sorry, go on. but on the whole, we have more to do. but i think the thing to understand is that we are doing this. we are having the societal debates. but not very successfully. you're setting the targets but you're not necessarily meeting them. and it's — when we're looking at the