46
46
Jul 26, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 46
favorite 0
quote 0
they might be underemployed, they might not have the passion for the job they're in and so forth.ght have a lot of debt on top of that. so what we're trying to do here with our bill, congressman thompson and i are basically, what we're trying to do is trying to get people as many -- give people as many choices as possible. we're not here to dictate what, you know, what line of profess you're going into or whether you should go to four-year college or go to career and technical education. however this should be made more available to more people so they have the option. there's one point i wanted to just mention as well which is that this bill, it modestly increases some funding to get more people to participate. but what it's really going to do as well is unleash billions of dollars in private investment into our career and technical education system. ow, private companies -- ♪ ♪ i won't forget the men who died who gave that right to me i gladly stand up next to you and defend her still today because there ain'to
they might be underemployed, they might not have the passion for the job they're in and so forth.ght have a lot of debt on top of that. so what we're trying to do here with our bill, congressman thompson and i are basically, what we're trying to do is trying to get people as many -- give people as many choices as possible. we're not here to dictate what, you know, what line of profess you're going into or whether you should go to four-year college or go to career and technical education....
27
27
tv
eye 27
favorite 0
quote 0
economy you know the economy has many problems as a lot of high jobless rate danny people are underemployed. prices are rising inflation is high the banks are a mess important to remember that the sanctions never really fully went away the u.s. despite signing up to the new could do kept many of its sanctions in place and not stopped a lot of money coming into the into iran because the international banks are simply terrified of u.s. penalties and never really opened up the iraq iranian economy in the way that iran had hoped so although these sanctions will have a significant impact it's important to remember that iran was never really brought back and that community of nations in the way that they promised that the time of the new eric randolph putting it into perspective for us corresponded to the french news agency a.f.p. reporting from tech ron thank you. when americans feel good about the current state of their economy the index of u.s. consumer confidence apprising the rose in july despite analysts expecting a decline the positive trend is partly due to very fast job gains and rising
economy you know the economy has many problems as a lot of high jobless rate danny people are underemployed. prices are rising inflation is high the banks are a mess important to remember that the sanctions never really fully went away the u.s. despite signing up to the new could do kept many of its sanctions in place and not stopped a lot of money coming into the into iran because the international banks are simply terrified of u.s. penalties and never really opened up the iraq iranian economy...
80
80
Jul 15, 2018
07/18
by
BLOOMBERG
tv
eye 80
favorite 0
quote 0
kaplan: underemployed america.t's a low-end service economy with people who hate their jobs working only 20 or 30 hours a week and that's what the statistics often hide. tom: i mean, to finish up here in this section, this is a huge issue in the elites on "bloomberg surveillance" are saying it is a fully employed america. 100% of my audience says they are nuts. that's all there is to it. dr. bremmer: look, if people felt good, we wouldn't have had trump and sanders doing what they are. people are actually having, some have two jobs, some have three jobs. but if you look at a person who is driving for amazon flex ups driverto the that they replaced, who is making $35 an hour. now they're making $14. they used to have the infrastructure and benefits. now they don't. their quality of life for the last 40, 50 years of the average american has deteriorated at full employment levels, has deteriorated. completely unacceptable. tom: and then that article in "the atlantic" recently, the woman did amazon flex, that was jaw d
kaplan: underemployed america.t's a low-end service economy with people who hate their jobs working only 20 or 30 hours a week and that's what the statistics often hide. tom: i mean, to finish up here in this section, this is a huge issue in the elites on "bloomberg surveillance" are saying it is a fully employed america. 100% of my audience says they are nuts. that's all there is to it. dr. bremmer: look, if people felt good, we wouldn't have had trump and sanders doing what they...
36
36
Jul 24, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 36
favorite 0
quote 0
talk to workers and employers, to innovators and entrepreneurs, it is clear that many people are underemployed and that our economy continues to face serious long-term challenges. that is why i launched the "make it in america listening tour" last august. in peoria, toledo, and wisconsin. we heard from margaret and other business owners, educators, , about the challenges of preparing a 21st-century workforce. in kansas city, pittsburgh, and toison, we listened innovators talk about the difficulties of launching and sustaining businesses that hire locally. in las vegas and indianapolis, local leaders talk about tilting the infrastructure necessary to access national and global markets and attract investment. withsiting chicago representative bukowski, we how undermining workers rights are disadvantaging those workers and their families. we ought to be making it easier, not harder, for workers to organize and bargain collectively. the middle class in america was built on such organizations. unions and their abilities to bargain collected we -- bargain crucial in thee fight for equal pay for wome
talk to workers and employers, to innovators and entrepreneurs, it is clear that many people are underemployed and that our economy continues to face serious long-term challenges. that is why i launched the "make it in america listening tour" last august. in peoria, toledo, and wisconsin. we heard from margaret and other business owners, educators, , about the challenges of preparing a 21st-century workforce. in kansas city, pittsburgh, and toison, we listened innovators talk about...
44
44
Jul 23, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 44
favorite 0
quote 0
talk to employers and workers, innovators and entrepreneurs, it is clear that many people are underemployed and our economy continues to face serious long-term challenges. that is why i launched the make it in america listening tour last august. from business owners, educators, students, about the challenges preparing a 21st-century workforce. in kansas city, pittsburgh and medicine, we listened to entrepreneurs and innovators talk about the difficulties of launching and sustaining businesses that hire locally. indianapolis,nd local leaders talked about building the infrastructure necessary to access national and global markets and attract investment. , we heardng chicago from labor about efforts to undermine workers rights, as a managing -- disadvantaging those workers and their families as well. we ought to be making it easier, not harder, for workers to organize. the middle class in america was built on such organizations. unions and their ability to bargain collectively are critical in my opinion, in the fight for equal pay for women, affordable health care and child care, paid family l
talk to employers and workers, innovators and entrepreneurs, it is clear that many people are underemployed and our economy continues to face serious long-term challenges. that is why i launched the make it in america listening tour last august. from business owners, educators, students, about the challenges preparing a 21st-century workforce. in kansas city, pittsburgh and medicine, we listened to entrepreneurs and innovators talk about the difficulties of launching and sustaining businesses...
59
59
Jul 15, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 59
favorite 0
quote 0
poor grammar in the rowdy one who misbehaves at the bar on saturday night he might smoke meth underemployedbe next con or a product of the lower class he has few friends in the media world because it is populated by the upper-class white people decidedly liberal and then to discuss the notion of white privilege and they are the embodiment of it and at least they were in their mind they convince themselves they have overcome this paradox through education and intellectual magazine articles world travel and psychotherapy the way the liberal feels they are no longer privileged but self-aware and self-made and they are woke. in the hierarchy of american life blacks on the bottom and whites are on the top but that only comes around when there is a catastrophe like katrina or flint or a police shooting. but again what about the poor white man? believe that they have scrubbed themselves clean of it but how could they know? they spent no time in his living room in the corner bar so to them he is a louse and a bore into racist to dig any deeper is an exercise of inconvenience and toothache he reside
poor grammar in the rowdy one who misbehaves at the bar on saturday night he might smoke meth underemployedbe next con or a product of the lower class he has few friends in the media world because it is populated by the upper-class white people decidedly liberal and then to discuss the notion of white privilege and they are the embodiment of it and at least they were in their mind they convince themselves they have overcome this paradox through education and intellectual magazine articles world...
112
112
Jul 26, 2018
07/18
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 112
favorite 0
quote 0
will join him talking about receiving a certificate in the heating and cooling, a person who is underemployed, unemployed, and another with a vocational program that they entered and how those things are making a difference in their daily lives, we have, as you know, as viewers of fox news, a tremendous opportunity in our economy for people seeking jobs. we have more jobs than people who are currently seeking them, so what the president is talking about doing is closing the loop on the training that the people will need to get into those jobs, and this visit to iowa is one step in that process, as this continues to make news, we will bring you back to this live events, but there is a lot going on that we want to tell you about on "outnumbered overtime" today, a group of house republicans, impeachment is not off the table for deputy attorney rod rosenstein, the battle over his future is far from over, this is "outnumbered overtime," i am harris faulkner, 11 house republicans introduced a resolution to impeach rod rosenstein, claiming that he has a conflicted interest in overseeing the mueller
will join him talking about receiving a certificate in the heating and cooling, a person who is underemployed, unemployed, and another with a vocational program that they entered and how those things are making a difference in their daily lives, we have, as you know, as viewers of fox news, a tremendous opportunity in our economy for people seeking jobs. we have more jobs than people who are currently seeking them, so what the president is talking about doing is closing the loop on the training...
75
75
Jul 29, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 75
favorite 0
quote 1
the kind you might smoke meth is underemployed, maybe a veteran or ex-con, product of a desperate loweran has few friends in the media world because the media world is populated by upper-class white people. decidedly liberal who had their cocktail tables discuss white privilege. the media know about white privilege because they are the embodiment of it. at least they were. in their minds, they have convinced themselves that they have overcome this self paradox. through education, intellectual magazine articles, world travel and psychotherapy. the white elite liberal feels they are no longer privileged. they are self-aware. world savvy, self-made, down with the program, they are woke. [laughter] in the hierarchy of american life, blacks are on the bottom and whites on the top. and so the white media is down for the black man. which is a fine thing but it only comes around when there is a catastrophe. like katrina or flint or pay police shooting. but again, what about the poor white man? the liberal white elite who have been raised with advantage but believe they have scrubbed themselves
the kind you might smoke meth is underemployed, maybe a veteran or ex-con, product of a desperate loweran has few friends in the media world because the media world is populated by upper-class white people. decidedly liberal who had their cocktail tables discuss white privilege. the media know about white privilege because they are the embodiment of it. at least they were. in their minds, they have convinced themselves that they have overcome this self paradox. through education, intellectual...
43
43
tv
eye 43
favorite 0
quote 0
you know the economy has many problems as a lot of high jobless rate people are underemployed. prices are rising inflation is high the banks are a mess important to remember that the sanctions never really fully went away the u.s. despite signing up to the new could do kept many of its sanctions in place and not stopped a lot of money coming in into iran because the international banks are simply terrified of u.s. penalties and never really opened up the iraq iranian economy in the way that iran had hoped so although these sanctions will how significant impact it's important to remember that iran was never really brought back and that community of nations in the way that did promise that the time of the nuclear do eric randolph putting it into perspective for us correspondent at the french news agency a.f.p. reporting from tech ron thank you. well right in the middle of the summer holidays it's hot no one's going to want to walk to wherever it is they're going to go in spain's taxi driver this are on strike it's a lucrative time to turn down but they're more worried about the m
you know the economy has many problems as a lot of high jobless rate people are underemployed. prices are rising inflation is high the banks are a mess important to remember that the sanctions never really fully went away the u.s. despite signing up to the new could do kept many of its sanctions in place and not stopped a lot of money coming in into iran because the international banks are simply terrified of u.s. penalties and never really opened up the iraq iranian economy in the way that...
61
61
Jul 18, 2018
07/18
by
BLOOMBERG
tv
eye 61
favorite 0
quote 0
i see the same situation in california, where you have people that have been underemployed, working very, very hard, two and three jobs, and they continue to say that they haven't seen that wage increase yet. we have seen for sure, and i think you're correct about the unemployment go down. we haven't seen yet, certainly not in my district, any measurable way, the increases in wages. >> wages in general have been somewhat slow in moving up as the labor market has tightened. we understand that really matters to people's lives a lot. we do see them moving up in the aggregate, but i'll be theep supply -- >> you said there was an issue of productivity, because maybe this time the reason the rates haven't increased as much is because of productivity. can you talk about that for a snecked >> sure. over a long period of time, wages really can't forever go up faster than productivity. productivity is slow, but there's a reason for that, and that is, after the financial crisis, there are many reasons for it, but after the financial crisis, companies didn't invest much, because there was no need to
i see the same situation in california, where you have people that have been underemployed, working very, very hard, two and three jobs, and they continue to say that they haven't seen that wage increase yet. we have seen for sure, and i think you're correct about the unemployment go down. we haven't seen yet, certainly not in my district, any measurable way, the increases in wages. >> wages in general have been somewhat slow in moving up as the labor market has tightened. we understand...
54
54
Jul 6, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 54
favorite 0
quote 0
in some sense, every underemployed person is a failure of entrepreneurial imagination. >> are there other countries that do a better job of job training? or retraining? there is some sense in which the scandinavian countries do it better, but their educational system is so much stronger in lots of different dimensions. and the location has a lot to admire. troubleus would have with a tracking system that looks any person and says your job is you will be a tree for the rest of your life, or a job again, whatever. so doing things that allow traditional american optimism combined out with serious vocational training would be a plus. you know, i have no problem asking our kids to spend more time at school, especially on the back of what you're describing. we should have other programs that work. steve: one second, i just wanted to comment. bookville, amy goldstein's , one of the most interesting parts is the re-scaling section section and her survey of workers laid off on the gm victory -- factory. in her book, those who did not go through training were a much ander percentage employed compar
in some sense, every underemployed person is a failure of entrepreneurial imagination. >> are there other countries that do a better job of job training? or retraining? there is some sense in which the scandinavian countries do it better, but their educational system is so much stronger in lots of different dimensions. and the location has a lot to admire. troubleus would have with a tracking system that looks any person and says your job is you will be a tree for the rest of your life,...
60
60
Jul 8, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 60
favorite 0
quote 0
orething every unemployed underemployed is a failure of entrepreneurial imagination. >> are there other countries that do a better job of job training? think there isi some sense in the scandinavian countries do it better, but the education systems in those areas are so much stronger. also in terms of vocational ed, there is a lot to admire in term of germany's system. most of us would have trouble with a tracking system that looks with a 13-year-old and says going to be a tree the rest of your life or a garage mechanic or whatever. doing things that allow traditional american optimism that combines that with serious vocational training on top of that would be a plus. i have got no problem with asking our kids to spend more time doing schooling, especially on the back of what you described, in a world where families work less we should have other programs that work. >> one second. janesville, amy goldstein's book. when of the most interesting parts is the re-skilling section. these workers who had been laid off from the gm factory. and after six years, though who went through rescheduli
orething every unemployed underemployed is a failure of entrepreneurial imagination. >> are there other countries that do a better job of job training? think there isi some sense in the scandinavian countries do it better, but the education systems in those areas are so much stronger. also in terms of vocational ed, there is a lot to admire in term of germany's system. most of us would have trouble with a tracking system that looks with a 13-year-old and says going to be a tree the rest...
37
37
Jul 10, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 37
favorite 0
quote 0
in some sense, every unemployed or underemployed american of entrepreneurial imagination. >> are there other countries that do a better job of job training? and retraining? >> there is some sense that the scandinavian countries do a bit better but the educational systems in those areas are so much stronger in lots of different dimensions. also terms of vocational ed, a lot to admire in terms of germany's system. i think most of us would have trouble with a tracking system that basically looks at -- your job is to be a tree for the rest of your life, or a garage mechanic. doing things that allow the traditional american optimism about finding something that combines that with serious vocational training on top of that, would be a plus. and like i have no problem with asking our kids to spend more time doing schooling, especially in the back of what you just described. where families work less, we should have other programs that work more. >> one second, i just want -- ed. jamesville, amy goldstein's book, one of the most interesting parts is the rescaling section and her survey of these
in some sense, every unemployed or underemployed american of entrepreneurial imagination. >> are there other countries that do a better job of job training? and retraining? >> there is some sense that the scandinavian countries do a bit better but the educational systems in those areas are so much stronger in lots of different dimensions. also terms of vocational ed, a lot to admire in terms of germany's system. i think most of us would have trouble with a tracking system that...
49
49
Jul 19, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 49
favorite 0
quote 0
i would see the same situation in california where you have people that have been underemployed working very hard and they continue to say that they've seen that increase. we have seen for sure unemployment go down but we haven't seen yet certainly in my district in any measurable way. >> the wages in general have been somewhat slow in moving up the. maybe this time the reason they haven't increased as just because of productivity. can you talk about that for the second? >> over a long period of time the wages can go up faster. productivity is slow but there is a reason for that for many reasons for that. the companies didn't invest much because there was no need to. the economy was weak and so the weak investment casts a shadow on the productivity growth for a number of years. investment has now popped up and it was strong in 2017 and continues. it's important and glad to see it, but it may take time to show up in higher productivity. it isn't because people are not working harder but it's because you need the information technology and other tools to be more productive. >> i think tha
i would see the same situation in california where you have people that have been underemployed working very hard and they continue to say that they've seen that increase. we have seen for sure unemployment go down but we haven't seen yet certainly in my district in any measurable way. >> the wages in general have been somewhat slow in moving up the. maybe this time the reason they haven't increased as just because of productivity. can you talk about that for the second? >> over a...
112
112
Jul 26, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 112
favorite 0
quote 0
they might be underemployed.y might not have a passion for the job they are end, and they may have a lot of debt on top of that. what we are trying to do here with our bill, congressman thompson and i are trying to give people at many choices of possible. whate not here to dictate line of profession you are going to go into or whether you should go to four-year college or career technical education. however, this should be made more available to more people so they have the option. there's 1.i wanted to mention as well, which is this bill -- there's one point i wanted to mention as well, which is this bill will unleash billions of dollars in private investment into our career technical education system because now private companies are going to be more knowledgeable about the rules of the road going forward and know that they are going to have a seat at the table. i think this is going to leverage a lot of outside investment. that is another reason why it is so important. host: sam is in new york, democrat. quest
they might be underemployed.y might not have a passion for the job they are end, and they may have a lot of debt on top of that. what we are trying to do here with our bill, congressman thompson and i are trying to give people at many choices of possible. whate not here to dictate line of profession you are going to go into or whether you should go to four-year college or career technical education. however, this should be made more available to more people so they have the option. there's 1.i...
74
74
Jul 27, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 74
favorite 0
quote 0
i see the same situation in california where you have people underemployed working hard we haven't seen that wage increase will see the unemployment go down but we haven't seen yet any measurable way increases in wages. >> wages in general have been somewhat slower moving up. as the labor market has tightened. we understand that matters to see the moving up in the aggregate i'd be happy to supply. >> maybe the reason rates heaven increases because of productivity. >> over a long time wages cannot goal up. productivity is slow but there's a reason. after the financial crisis companies did not invest because there is no need to. there wasn't demand so we can investment casts a shadow over productivity growth over years. investment is now popped up. it was strong in 2017. that's really important. were glad to see it. it may take some time to show up. it's not because people are not working harder. it's because you need those information technology and other tools to be more productive. >> i just wanted thank you with the way that you have been open to talking to people. the confidence we h
i see the same situation in california where you have people underemployed working hard we haven't seen that wage increase will see the unemployment go down but we haven't seen yet any measurable way increases in wages. >> wages in general have been somewhat slower moving up. as the labor market has tightened. we understand that matters to see the moving up in the aggregate i'd be happy to supply. >> maybe the reason rates heaven increases because of productivity. >> over a...
90
90
Jul 21, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 90
favorite 0
quote 1
their education prepare them for a job, and more than half of recent graduates are unemployed or underemployedit's not for lack of jobs. tells us of statistics more recently we have more job openings than jobseekers in america. a number of these jobs are higher paying higher skill jobs in areas like health care, cyber security, manufacturing. unfortunately those looking for work don't have the skill sets that employers are seeking. the western governors association spent the last year studying the skills gap. we found that integrating state efforts, increasing the availability of training, expanding broadband access and areas and connecting education to careers are ways to help address that workforce gap. we need to ensure that a degree is not just a destination but a pathway to jobs. that means providing students with better information earlier with guidance of a can make -- one way we are doing this is through a pilot program called career launch. includes a number of school districts, which are pooling resources to provide more career counseling and give students a more hands-on experience.
their education prepare them for a job, and more than half of recent graduates are unemployed or underemployedit's not for lack of jobs. tells us of statistics more recently we have more job openings than jobseekers in america. a number of these jobs are higher paying higher skill jobs in areas like health care, cyber security, manufacturing. unfortunately those looking for work don't have the skill sets that employers are seeking. the western governors association spent the last year studying...
80
80
Jul 8, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 80
favorite 0
quote 0
and a lot of them are college graduates or american citizens, they are underemployed.t will be another issue. wages are low. salaries are low. people may be working two jobs. host: thank you for the call. the new york times headline is that red state democrats face the agonizing supreme court choice. reading as follows. democratic senators running for reelection in trump country face the agonizing choice over trump supreme court nominee, vote to theirm the pic and risk to moralizing democratic voters ahead of the elections or sacrifice their own seats with a in 2019. a majority remainstates, trump popular. most notably, heidi heitkamp, .oe donnelly and joe manchin a decision by one or all of them to bolster the standing with republican leaning voters in their states by backing the president's nominees would undermine democratic leaders as unity.y to sustain party but if they hold together on a no vote, they could send own thes and they could narrow path of democrats to a senate majority for years to come by seating those states to republicans. that is from the new york
and a lot of them are college graduates or american citizens, they are underemployed.t will be another issue. wages are low. salaries are low. people may be working two jobs. host: thank you for the call. the new york times headline is that red state democrats face the agonizing supreme court choice. reading as follows. democratic senators running for reelection in trump country face the agonizing choice over trump supreme court nominee, vote to theirm the pic and risk to moralizing democratic...
24
24
Jul 20, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 24
favorite 0
quote 0
the young people but the folks who were almost all employed, but they all felt like they were underemployed. they were raising a family. they had full-time jobs but they knew they could do better. to see those folks ranging in age from 25 to 60, going back and studying and taking algebra two seemed to be the big separator. them give a they knew they could do better but they needed someone to help give them a little bit of a hand. the government working with the academ ec we've got to figure out a tor c that's not just the government. working with the academic sector, the note, -- non-profit sector and certainly the academic sector. we have a great panel, and what we are going to do is we're going to go around right on the order. i think we will start with representative boyle. if you could keep your comments relatively brief because we're trying to create a conversation here. but the general topic, a positive democratic vision for jobs and prosperity. >> it is great to be here >> thank you. it's great to be here and i really appreciate the vision, that will has shown not only in this group
the young people but the folks who were almost all employed, but they all felt like they were underemployed. they were raising a family. they had full-time jobs but they knew they could do better. to see those folks ranging in age from 25 to 60, going back and studying and taking algebra two seemed to be the big separator. them give a they knew they could do better but they needed someone to help give them a little bit of a hand. the government working with the academ ec we've got to figure out...
59
59
Jul 19, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 59
favorite 0
quote 0
people who were there but the folks who were almost all employed but they felt like they were underemployed. they were raising a family, had full-time jobs but they knew they could do better and to see folks ranging in folks ranging age from 25 to 60 going back and studying and taking algebra 2, that seemed to be the big separator. they knew they could do better but they needed somebody to give them a bit of a hand. we have to figure out way. it's not just the government. the government is working with the academic sector. thank you for starting us off. we have a great panel and what we're going to do, we're going to go around. i think right on the order. i think we'll start with you representative boyle. if you could keep your comments relatively brief. we're trying to create something of a conversation here. the general topic, a positive democratic vision for jobs and prosperity. congressman, great to see you again. >> thank you. it's great to be here. appreciate the vision that will has shown and great to be here with my colleague, tim. i'm a congressman from the city of philadelphia and
people who were there but the folks who were almost all employed but they felt like they were underemployed. they were raising a family, had full-time jobs but they knew they could do better and to see folks ranging in folks ranging age from 25 to 60 going back and studying and taking algebra 2, that seemed to be the big separator. they knew they could do better but they needed somebody to give them a bit of a hand. we have to figure out way. it's not just the government. the government is...
80
80
Jul 18, 2018
07/18
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 80
favorite 0
quote 0
i see the same situation in california where you have people that have been underemployed working very, very hard, two, three jobs and they continue to say they haven't seen that wage increase yet. we haven't seen the increase in wages. >> wages in general have been somewhat slow in moving up as the labor market is tightening. we understand that matters to people's lives a lot. we do see them moving up in the aggregate but i'll be happy to supply -- >> maybe the reason the rates haven't increased as much is because of productivity. could you talk about that for a second? >> sure. over a long period of time wages really can't forever go up faster than productivity. productivity is slow and there's a reason for that. after the financial crisis -- there are many reasons for it. after the financial crisis, though, companies didn't invest much because there was no need to. there wasn't demand. the economy was weak. so weak investment casts a shadow over productivity for a number of years. investment was strong in 2017, continues in 2018. that's really important and we're glad to see is it.
i see the same situation in california where you have people that have been underemployed working very, very hard, two, three jobs and they continue to say they haven't seen that wage increase yet. we haven't seen the increase in wages. >> wages in general have been somewhat slow in moving up as the labor market is tightening. we understand that matters to people's lives a lot. we do see them moving up in the aggregate but i'll be happy to supply -- >> maybe the reason the rates...