drive in ward investors out because carbon trading by its very nature requires a common price not a unilar price and we need to spend that price and send his chancellor to the eu and negotiate a common price so that we have a level playing field for investment. >> i respect the gentleman's view. i don't agree him. i think the steps taken in the budget are right. and i think we should judge companies like tarrer by what they've making. and they are putting more investment in the u.k. and if we take obviously the case of red car which closed under the last government it's going to be re-opening in part because of the reinvestment. of course, i listen to the honorable gentleman but i think he knows a bit more about his business than he does. >> mr. speaker, my statue jeff jacobs is in parliament to remind us it is the most common cancer in men. many dying each year of this disease, does the prime minister have a dream of better outcomes for the increasing investment in nhs? >> i think the honorable gentleman is absolutely right to raise this issue. and he's right. it is both a dream you have