you want to take somebody's job. >> bob: you think it's okay to call the president of the united states un-american kimberly: i didn't say it's okay to call him un-american. but i hardly think mitt romney is unhinged or out of line. >> bob: that's out of line. >> eric: to be clear, did he call president obama un-american or his policys? >> dana: policies. >> bob: it doesn't matter. >> eric: it does matter. >> bob: did he say the republicans were going to chain them? joe biden said the bank, the banks are unchained. you guys are giving romney a pass. romney has been tough or tougher and his facts have been worse in attacking obama than the other way around. >> kimberly: all the ads accusing -- >> bob: it wasn't something attacked? >> kimberly: all right. >> bob: we'll take it. >> kimberly: coming up, if you are a senior citizen will medicare be around if mitt romney wins the election? we have that answer when we come back. stay with us. ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ >> dana: all right. paul ryan budget proposal included a way to preserve medicare become a lightning rod issue in the 2012 presidential race now that he

un-american. and i work in the united states senate at that point. and we walked around on eggshells to make sure we didn't criticize bush and what he did abroad. mitt romney is bringing that up. if i were his people, i would be very careful about that. >> could that part have been edited out of that speech? if for example the point was to get to know mitt romney, that was all about president obama and mitt romney's critique of his foreign policy. but we don't get anything out of this as far as what governor romney wants. many people left thinking he wanted to go to war with iran. >> mitt romney thinks that barack obama has been a bad foreign policy president and so do a lot of other people. what he's done in iran is a perfect example. you can talk about -- he's not done anything to deter iran from building a nuclear weapon. nothing. and when israel is our greatest ally in the middle east, we need to stand with them no matter what. and i think if you talk to the israelis, they have questions whether barack obama is going to side with them. >> chip, y

it says something about the president of the united states if that is what he is reduced to doing. is he attacking warren buffett as being un-americane derives his income from investments like capital gains and dividends? if he really wants his secretary to pay a lower tax rate than he is he ought to give her a bunch of stock so she can keep driving her income from capital gains and dividends. i think one reason obama is going to lose, people are desperate for the president to offer more. goodbye to you think obama is going to lose -- >> do you think obama is going to lose? the tracks if he were to win, and i do not think he would, and he would come until prepared. davi>> what about tax reform, ey reform, this guy has not laid a predicate for anything but the volcker rule -- >> you are answering how he could lose. how could he win? geithner i have a good -- >> i have a good column. >> i am from vanity fair, and i also have a new book. >> go ahead. >> you took highly critical of sarah palin, donald trump, what are the questions here? were you doing that intentionally to help romney's chances, and did you discuss it at all? >> no, but