developments to can you turn you to the work of another group of engineers. researches here at the university of west virginia began using a different testing method. they measured emissions from cars while actually out on the road instead of in the lab. and to their surprise, the v. w engines, nitrogen oxide levels were up to 35 times higher than permitted we saw a vastly different performance between the test. so, and the on the, on the highway than, you know, then we knew that there, you know, the vehicles must be exhibiting some different behavior. while scientists and inspectors were baffled, nobody yet was thinking fraud. they informed v w. we fully anticipated the derby voluntary recall. things have been fixed and we heard nothing more about the virginia study was commissioned by the international council, unclean transportation or i. c. c, t. the developers at v w h q involved spoke new. it contained all the pieces of the puzzle to expose their machinations. an engineer remembers the increasing anxiety. we knew we were busted. we had 500000 vehicles in the u. s. and in the worst case scenario would ha

developments to can you turn you to the work of another group of engineers. researches here at the university of west virginia began using a different testing method. they measured emissions from cars while actually out on the road instead of in the lab. and to their surprise, the v. w engines, nitrogen oxide levels were up to 35 times higher than permitted we saw a vastly different performance between the test. so and the, and the on the highway than them. we knew that there, you know, the vehicles must be exhibiting some different behavior. while scientists and inspectors were baffled, nobody yet was thinking fraud. they informed v w. we fully anticipated the derby voluntary recall. things had been fixed and we heard nothing more about the virginia study was commissioned by the international council, unclean transportation or i. c. c, t. the developers at v w h q involved spoke new. it contained all the pieces of the puzzle to expose their machinations. an engineer remembers the increasing anxiety. we knew we were busted. we had 500000 vehicles in the u. s. and in the worst case scenario would have to buy t

developments to can you turn you to the work of another group of engineers. researches here at the university of west virginia began using a different testing method. they measured emissions from cars while actually out on the road instead of in the lab. and to their surprise, the v. w engines, nitrogen oxide levels were up to 35 times higher than permitted we saw a vastly different performance between the test. so and the on the on the highway then, you know, then we knew that there, the vehicles must be exhibiting some different behavior. while scientists and inspectors were baffled, nobody yet was thinking fraud. they informed v w. we fully anticipated the derby a voluntary recall. things have been fixed and we heard nothing more about the virginia study was commissioned by the international council, unclean transportation or i. c. c, t, the developers at v w h q involve spoke new. it contained all the pieces of the puzzle to expose their machinations. an engineer remembers the increasing anxiety. we knew we were busted. we had 500000 vehicles in the u. s. and in the worst case scenario would have to buy t

developments to can you turn you to the work of another group of engineers. researches here at the university of west virginia began using a different testing method. they measured emissions from cars while actually out on the road instead of in the lab. and to their surprise, the v. w engines, nitrogen oxide levels were up to 35 times higher than permitted we saw a vastly different performance between the test. so and the, and the, and the highway than you know them. we knew that there know the vehicles must be exhibiting some different behavior. while scientists and inspectors were baffled, nobody yet was thinking fraud. they informed v w. we fully anticipated that there be a voluntary recall. things have been fixed and we heard nothing more about the virginia study was commissioned by the international council, unclean transportation or i, c. c, t. the developers at v w h q involve spoke new. it contained all the pieces of the puzzle to expose their machinations. an engineer remembers the increasing anxiety. we knew we were busted. we had 500000 vehicles in the u. s. and in the worst case scenario would ha

researches here at the university of west virginia began using a different testing method. they measured emissions from cars while actually out on the road instead of in the lab. and to their surprise, the v. w engines, nitrogen oxide levels were up to 35 times higher than permitted we saw a vastly different performance between the tassel and the on the on the highway than you know, then we knew that there, the vehicles must be exhibiting some different behavior while scientists and inspectors were baffled. nobody yet was thinking fraud. they informed v w. we fully anticipated the derby a voluntary recall. things have been fixed and we heard nothing more about. the virginia study was commissioned by the international council, unclean transportation or i. c. c, t. the developers at v w h q involve spoke new. it contained all the pieces of the puzzle to expose their machinations. an engineer remembers the increasing anxiety. we knew we were busted. we had 500000 vehicles in the u. s. and in the worst case scenario would have to buy them back. ah, the result was a growing tower

developments to can you turn due to the work of another group of engineers. researches here at the university of west virginia began using a different testing method. they measured emissions from cars while actually out on the road instead of in the lab. and to their surprise, the v. w engines, nitrogen oxide levels were up to 35 times higher than permitted we saw a vastly different performance between the tassel and the on the on the highway. then you know, then we knew that there, the vehicles must be exhibiting some different behavior. while scientists and inspectors were baffled, nobody yet was thinking fraud. they informed v w. we fully anticipated the derby a voluntary recall. things have been fixed and we heard nothing more about the virginia study was commissioned by the international council, unclean transportation or i, c. c, t. the developers at v w h q involve spoke new. it contained all the pieces of the puzzle to expose their machinations. an engineer remembers the increasing anxiety. we knew we were busted. we had 500000 vehicles in the u. s. and in the worst case scenario would have to buy the

of civil war institute at gettysburg college. he received his ph.d. from penn state college. professor peter carmichael went on to teach at western carolina university. and the university of north carolina at greensboro, west virginia university. his academic interest include reconstruction, southern history, public history and cultural history. he is author of several books. his most recent work, the war for the common soldier, published in 2018 as part of the littlefield history of the civil war era series. his previous books include the last generation, young virginians in peace, war, and union, through u.n.c. press in 2005. and leads young artillery assist. in addition to his books, he has also published a number of articles in scholarly and popular journals. he speaks frequently to general and scholarly audiences. in addition, every june, professor peter carmichael directs the civil war institute summer conference, drawing hundreds of attendees from across the country. i have attended in 2019 and it was wonderful. so make a plan to attend this event. doctor carmichael is also a friend of history. he works in the national park service at a bottom alex. and richmond battlefield park. he is involved in the brian

professor peter carmichael taught at western carolina university and the university of north carolina at greensboro west virginia university. his academic interests includes 19th century civil war re- construction, southern history public history, and cultural history. author and editor and his most recent work, but more from the common soldier in 2018, and part of littlefield history of the civil war era. in his previous books included us generation young virginians and peace, war and reunion, and 2005, and william rj - from university of virginia press 1995 and in addition to his books is also published a number of articles, popular journals and speaks frequently to scholarly audiences pretty and in addition every june, professor peter carmichael teaches the conference which brings hundreds of attendees from across the country no good to special plug-in, i've attended and 2019 and the wonderful so peter carmichael ia particular a friend of public history the college student he worked in the national park service. fredericksburg and richmond national battlefield park and history inspired him to create - interns

professor peter carmichael taught at western carolina university and the university of north carolina at greensboro west virginiauniversity. his academic interests includes 19th century civil war re- construction, southern history public history, and cultural

of a key lawmaker. senator joe manchin said he could not vote for the legislation. it includes money for expanded medicare, prescription drug reform, universal pre-k, hundreds of billions to fight climate change. the west virginia democrat cited the nearly $2 trillion price tag and possible effect on inflation. 50/50 sena nst n in tht the bill. >>> the surging coronavirus didn't stop the latest spiderman movie from enjoying a huge weekend at the box office. spiderman no way home pulled in $253 million in ticket sales after debuting friday. it was easily the best opening weekend of the pandemic and enough to make it the third best opening of all time behind only avengers end game and avengers infinity war. that's your cbs money watch report. head to cbsmoneywatch.com. i am elise preston. >>> 4:47 on this monday morning. let's get a check on weather and traffic. >> we will start with mary lee. >>> good morning. we are looking at a wet week. we just had our weekend. gotta get some coffee this morning. you can see the clouds in the sky. we are looking at temperatures notice 30s and 40s. it's a cold start in concord. it is 47 in san francisco, san jose 40, 45 for santa rosa. satellite and radar view, a cool cloudy d

manchin was attacked personally and the state of west virginia universally. actress bette midler one time singer went on to say this is a tweet he wants us all to be just like his state west virginia poor, illiterate and strung out. she later apologized but i'm not accepting accepting. it's not just holiday trashing the state as jamaal bowman decided to make this about race. >> it's tremendously frustrating for me as a black man in america because once again it's an example of joe manchin as a white man showing that he doesn't care about black people. he doesn't care about latinos. he doesn't care about immigrants. he doesn't care about women and he doesn't care about the poor. >> brian: what? here to respond is the governor of that state former democrat himself getting ready to coach a great basketball game. high school basketball team but stops with us first jim justice. thanks so much for joining us. i want you to answer those people who decided to rip your senator and rip your state. >> brian, there's no call for it. in all honesty. not tolerated just per

professor peter carmichael taught at western carolina university and the university of north carolina at greensboro west virginia

west virginia radio and said he supports many components of build back better. just as we talk about bbb we should talk about ggg -- get governance going again. pass universalernor of west virginia when he was governor. we need to pass those child care supports as well as climate change provisions that he would support. if we do that, we make our own luck and increase the chances of doing better in the midterms and delivering for the american people. >> congressman, thank you so much. best of luck to you in 2022. happy new year. >> thank you so much. same to you. >>> it is something out of a novel literally. police say the denver gunman named his victims in a book he wrote before this week's shooting rampage. stay with us. unlike ordinary memory supplements, neuriva plus fuels six key indicators of brain performance. more brain performance? yes, please! neuriva. think bigger. with ww, i lost 30 pounds and i feel incredible. i love the new program because the app does all the work for you. it's never too late to start. start the new year with three months free. join today at ww.com. hurry, offer ends january 3rd. narrator: on a faraway beach, the generation

and if that's not enough, he's a graduate of west virginia university. think very well-rounded individual, who would serve well in the court of federal claims. also, i'll be asking to confirm carolyn lerner, who brings her own superb quality ficks to this position -- qualifications to this position as well. she's right now the chief circuit mediator for if the court of appeals for the d.c. circuit. so she deals with litigation conflicts all the time. she's obviously viewed with considerable regardpy the court -- regard by the court to have made her their chief circuit mediator. she served many years in private practice. she'd be very familiar with the private packets of the individuals that -- private practice of the individuals that come before the court of federal claims. again, private person versus federal government is what that court's business is. and she even taught law. carolyn lerner and armando bonilla are both very well qualified, and both came out of, the judiciary committee with voice votes, which means they both had bipartisan support. and

of this year. >> look, i do think that there are things that west virginians do care about. they care about universal pre-k. if you look at west virginiat stands on education, universal pre-k would help tremendously. they care about child tax care credit and the child care provisions these are things that actually help working people. medicaid expansion, lowering prescription drug costs of prices these are things that west virginians and that americans care about and i do think there is a way to accommodate joe manchin's concerns, those are things that he's expressed an interest in and to move a package forward that's going to make a difference not just today but in the future. >> what do you -- mick, what's the time line for you and probability for you on how this -- what is it the 13th, i was shocked it was already the 13th -- >> that's right. don't forget this is how the timeline works it's passed the house. if the senate passes it exactly like it is, it can go to the president's desk whenever. that's not going to happen it's going to change at some point in the senate so we have to then go back to the house you think joe manchin an

of it. i don't know if he was in theater at west virginia university or something like that, but it's time to of drama, that is for sure. hey, look, it's not just one. there are two, it's senator manchin, but the democrats also need to get your fellow arizonian senator kyrsten sinema fully on board. what is behind this? are they political motivated? and are you concerned that even in the new year build back better could be in peril of getting their support? >> i think a lot of it is what they actually believe, but some of it is some political calculations, but the political calculations are wrong. you are demotivating the base of the democratic party, and it will cost us and eventually them at some point when they run for office. and you know, so using the filibuster as an excuse i think is not the way to go. the reconciliation is working at least for bbb, but for voting rights act there is no excuse. you should not be using the filibuster to stop the voting rights act. you shouldn't be using the filibuster at all, but shouldn't use it to stop civil rights legislation. and in the end, i think

of the president going alone and ruling by executive order? laura had good points but i don't think americans are clamoring, for example, for free universal pre-k, west virginiaderal help as joe manchin repeatededly points out. most americans, more than 50% disapprove of joe biden's handling of the economy. part of that is how much money trillions of dollars he's put in to the economy since he started -- since he took off in january. adding billions more will make inflation worse, send things spiralling worse than they are. americans do vote with their pocketbook, don't they, jackie? >> jackie: they do. i can see laura shaking her head no. when you look at the spending that we have endured to this point and the inflation that consumers are experiencing, are you saying they're not feeling the pinch here? >> no, they're feeling with the pinch but i'm going with 17 nobel prize economists saying this won't contribute to inflation. goldman sachs said or economy will shrink. i'm going with the 2.5 million well that have dropped out of the work force. this build back better program will help our economy. americans are fans of the elements of this bill. joe biden is

temporarily on hold to see what comes as a result of this big decision from west virginia senator joe mansion, donna crane with san jose state university. we always appreciate your time here on kron 4 news along with the knowledge in conversation as well. great to be here. thanks. thanks to know. still ahead tonight, proctor and gamble is issued a recall for some products that could be inside of your bathroom right now. >> we'll let you know what they are before you head off to bed tonight. where your money tonight, a voluntary recall has been issued for more than 30 items. some of these could be inside of your bathrooms right now. >> procter and gamble has issued that recall for aerosol spray products, including dry shampoo and a dry conditioner. the recall is because of concerns over the levels behind the cancer causing chemical benzene, which is found in some of these products. among the products being recalled are penn teen. aussie herbal essences and water less. the food and drug administration says so far the company has not yet received any reports of any adverse events related to the recall. the company says it is now pulling t

west virginia. i sort of like how the universe always aligns into areas of your expertise.for being with us this morning, evan. you know both these guys. what do you hear in their comments now and what does that lead you to believe about whether some kind of a deal is possible? >> yeah, john, you know what's really interesting, you heard joe manchin over the last couple of days give us a lot of reasons for why he torpedo ed this bill concerned about inflation, debt, problems at the staff level at the white house, irritated by how he was being handled. one thing he hasn't done is blame this on the president of the united states. that's not an accident. it is important. these are two people who are trying to preserve a pathway to get back to conversation again. you heard the president yesterday talk about they're going to do something, joe manchin when he went on local radio in west virginia this week, making it clear he has no problem with the president. so in some ways, the optimistic reading here is that this is a throat clearing part of the process, where they have now mo

of assistance to be able to afford child care. here in west virginia, child care for one child private pay costs more than a year's tuition at west virginia university is ridiculously expensive and just one more obstacle for people to join the workforce. one example. >> the senators hearing some disappointment, not just if his colleagues in washington, but from his home state. we heard coal miners union encouraging him to pass build back better for the climate provisions in there. do you see him moving on this from your perspective as you communicate, you and others, communicate the needs to the senator? he's not dumb. he's been in politics a long time. he knows to listen to his constituents. >> i think maybe that's the part i'm most disappointed in. you know, one of the biggest struggles has been able to really get senator manchin to hear the people who are benefitting from this, you know from the child tax credit. it is just very difficult task and i have yet to be able to do that. we have gotten as far as the staff, but we never had face to facetime w time with the senato >> how about inflation? inflation hurts the poor the most, right? it is thi

of the university minnesota center for infectious disease research and policy, also served on president biden's covid-19 advisory board. and the chief of the infectious diseases division at children's national hospital in west virginia, thank you so much and, professor, let me start with you. when you see numbers like this, you see hospitalizations like this, sick outs, critical workers, how worried are you that the country could be days or weeks away from not having essential services like health care or law enforcement staffed and operating properly? >> well, it is going to happen. it is not a matter of if. it is just a matter of how bad it gets. we know over the next five to six weeks we'll continue to see transmission of this virus throughout this country much like a viral blizzard. and with that, we are going to see a perfect storm in our health care settings where even if 10% to 20% of the health care providers are sick with the virus, whether it's mild or nonmild illness, it means they're still not there. and there's 9.8 million doctors, nurses, and technicians in this country working in our hospitals. if we lose 10% of those 90,000 or if we lose, you know, even 150,000, we could see major challenges trying t

west virginia radio. i read the transcript of it. seems like he supports some vital components like help with child care, help with universal pre-k which law as governor as renewable energy provisions. so we talk about bbb, but we should talk about ggg, get governance going. so let's pick up the piece parts that we can agree on, pass them and get them signed in to law to help people right now. >> jackie: what you're saying make sense. but there's provisions for tree equity. there's certain things that can go especially at a time when you said gas prices are rising, food prices are rising and people are feeling the pinch. >> we have to be very priblgt call -- practical right now. a lot of women have dropped out of the work force because child care is so unaffordable. millions of women have. so the help to get them back in the works force to make the economy more prosperous has to be job number 1 for congress right now. >> some people would say another way to look at it is you can stimulate the economy this way with spending. you can also leave child care, for example, to be a competitive industry. let people pay for their own child care

of homesickness, is universal. >> it is a rare song that isn't just singing about something, it is causing it. >> reporter: brad paisley grew up in glendale, west virginiaained new meaning once he moved to nashville. >> once you move away, the song takes on way more character and depth. you hear on that radio and you're not in west virginia. you hear that in your car, and it comes on, and you hear that iconic acoustic guitar part. diving down the road, i get a feeling... >> leaving and homecoming has always been something that west virginians have experienced, but we've been at a loss in our population since 1950. so i think it is a perennial mood for west virginians. >> reporter: including this one. i grew up in the capitol city of charleston. i learned to ride my bike on country roads. i left the state after high school, but i'm still nostalgic for it. all my memories gather around her. >> one of the things i've been thinking about is a welsh concept call hiraea. it is a deep longing for some place you can't quite name, that is home, but maybe more. it is maybe a place you've never been or the home you've only dreamed of. this deep pull-toward place.

universal pre-k and obamacare expansion. but get this. no extension of the expanded child tax credit, that popular program that would help pull children out of poverty including kids in manchin's home state of west virginia is sticking by his decision. cnn's jessica dean reports now from capitol hill. >> reporter: christine and laura, we now know that senator joe manchin spoke with president joe biden on sunday after manchin had announced he would be a no on build back better in its current form. we are told that it was a cordial conversation, but no commitments were made. simply that they could discuss re-engaging on these issues in the new year. but again, no commitments made, no specific commitments made is what our sources are telling cnn. earlier on monday, we did hear from manchin from more detail about how he arrived at his decision to not support build back better as it currently exists, and he really put a lot of the blame on white house staff. take a listen. >> it's staff driven. i understand staff. it's not the president, it's the staff. they drove some things, it's in excusable. they know what it is, and that's it. what i'm saying is this. i'm not blaming anybody. i knew what they were, i kne

of his fellow democrats reeling. now this bill which would provide climate change, he universal pre-k may well be impossible to pass. west virginia senator joe manchin dealing a devastating blow to his party's nearly $2 trillion top priority. singing the build back better bill in a sunday interview. >> i cannot vote to continue with this piece of legislation. i just can't. i've tried everything humanly possible. i can't get there. >> you're done. this is a no. >> this is a no. >> manchin joining every senate republican in opposition to the bill after he spent months negotiate, president biden, tanking the legislation in the evenly divided senate and stunning the white house which released a statement saying manchin's comments were at odds with his discussion this week with the president. the president secretary jen psaki said we will continue to the press it to see if he was reverse it yet again to honor his prior commitment and be true to his word. last month, president biden expressing confidence he could overcome concerns about manchin's reservations on the bill's impact. >> he will vote for if this is what he has anticipated.

of west virginia in its current form. let's figure out how to get it in another form. let's figure out how to get the child tax credit. let's figure out how to get universal pre-k. let's do it in a way where whole eye of the world are glaring down on the guy, donald trump, got 69% of the votes. >> spoken like a former legislature and like we say in washington it's never over until it's over even when it's over. we are seeing that right now. manchin's defense. he's never straight of making the basic point but at a time inflation appears to be increasing problem for our economy. he's going to look very carefully these proposals and he's seen agonizing and on fox today that he could not get there. this is going to be a new effort to work on the concerns he has. besides if you are denied having personal concerns and legislative concerns if you are a member of the senate so, they're going to have to come back and look at this again. i am just -- with you joe and thinking i don't see this process being over. that's not what i am hearing from the people at the white house. yes, they were angry but they describe this as a dance. the next round of the dance ahead.

joe manchin of west virginia announcing that he will not support the democrats' social spending plan. now this is the signature proposal by the president that includes funding for universalr child care, money to combat climate change. manchin says he is a hard no citing his growing concerns about inflation and about debt. just moments ago, senate majority leader chuck schumer announced he will bring this bill to the floor for a vote and put every senator on the record, but democrats cannot afford to lose a single vote in the senate. so it's still likely due to fail, t.j. >> the white house did not mince words here, calling this an inexplicable reversal saying it's a breach of commitment to the president. were they really thrown off by this? >> reporter: they were caught off guard, and blindsided, t.j. i'm told they were only informed just minutes before senator manchin actually announced this on national television. senior officials tried to call the senator. they could not reach him. i'm told the president signed off on that statement. his economic agenda now hanging in the balance, t.j. >> wow, he sent them right to voice mail. rachel scott thank you as always. will? >

economic the senator from west virginia argues the infusion of government suspending would make situations worse joining us is austan goolsby, professor of economics at the universityma administration, michael strain, director of economic policy studies at the american enterprise institute austin, looking at some of your comments, nobody knows whether a smaller deal or smaller bill is a possibility and it seems like the door is left opened. manchin reportedly was in favor of some of the proposals, just not maybe that the overall ties and costs, but you say even if he doesn't, biden at this point his major accomplishments will be the rescue plan and infrastructure bill. you think both of those are substantial given that it wasn't a huge win where you swept huge amounts of the senate in the house. he's got an lot done for not having huge majorities in either chamber. >> i'm not sure it means i need a rapid test i think i agree 100%, for a brief moment, you were the second most important joe, you know, in the public eye. we got joe manchin first i think the white house absolutely now needs to decide, do they want to do a partial bill, do they want to figure out what i

universal prekindergarten, precare -- preschool and expansion of the rah fordable care act. hundreds of billions of dollars in green energy spending, that's got to be scary to anyone in west virginiadit and all these other things that were hooked into this. he said and everybody was judging. he said have less programs and actually be honest for funding them more than one year for 10 years and give me that cbo score. if joe biden goes back and says i'm going to take you up on that, the republicans have got to stop dancing in the end zone. they are going to have to absorb and eat $1.8 trillion. steve: well, and, brian and carley, when you ask the average american what they are concerned of, i don't think they are that concerned with getting build back better out of congress. they are worried about inbeflation, as peter mentioned, supply chain issues and crime. and when you look at crime, we were just doing a segment about 20 minutes ago with pastor brooks who is up on the roof in chicago trying to raise money for a facility to help combat gun violence, in every state it seems, particularly a lot of big northeastern corridor cities, crime is through the roof. then you have got chicag