money to this christopher steele that gets phony information from russia, this salacious dossier using russian sources to influence americans in the last election. when is mueller going to investigate that because we know the money exchanged hands. we know it was propaganda and misinformation.

wow, could they have used phony russian propaganda? >> let me tell you something, if, in fact, the dossier was a basis for why and fifa warrant was issued, you are talking about going to court and getting a warrant to basically eavesdrop, tap, listen in on conversations based on the document that was not only unverified -- as james comey said, by the way -- but ask this question, why was the fbi considering paying for it at some point in this process? that question has to be asked. i go back to this whole concept. something we've been talking about for a long time. if this dossier was a political creature, we now know it is -- opposition research. if christopher steele was utilizing russian access to get this information and then james comey said it was unverified and they went to court to get fisa warrants customer if you are raising a whole host of civil liberty issues. >> sean: it admissible in the court of law. >> i file motions to suppress the subpoenas in the document that resulted in that, probably. >> sean: >> the fbi has becom

then literally using russian lies to influence the election. propagandizing the american people.op you guys have been phenomenal. good work. we will stay on it. we thank you both. laurak ingraham. i think she is supposed to have a show here at fox. where is she? i she's joining us next, straight ahead.ug oh well, all hope is lost! oh thanks! clearly my whitening toothpaste is not cutting it. time for whitestrips. crest glamorous white whitestrips are the only ada-accepted whitening strips proven to be safe and effective. they work below the enamel surface to whiten 25x better than a leading whitening toothpaste. hey, nice smile! thanks! i crushed the tissue test! yeah you did! crest. healthy, beautiful smiles for life. >> sean: as we continue, joining us now with reaction to all these scandals surrounding hillary clinton, the democrats, and those lies, yeah, russians impacting an election. i assume in the year 2020 she will be the host of the fox news show "the ingraham angle." >> monday! >> sean: i know you are number one on the new york best-

the policy still continues to be run but i do use a lot of russian know. nomen cliche nomen clout to toe the deep state in the united states runs the potus obama used to speak softly.

propaganda machine contributed to the influence campaign by serving as a platform for messaging using russian government funded outlets russian propaganda media outlets like r t i think it's a propaganda arm of government that is definitely not on our side reports have it that russia not only wanted to weigh in in the election but they also want to undermine u.s. confidence of citizens confidence in our electoral process and in our democratic values. i'll give you some background and substance to those statements similar account joins us live on the program. this is not the first attack in recent days on our channel. well it's not just twitter it seems that every social media giants joining this anti r t campaign even earlier this month google actually told r.t. from you tube's premium advertising service without any notice even the r t has been the most viewed t.v. news network on you tube first few years now and of course abiding by all the platforms rules but unfortunately that's not all seems that the us media has also placed pressure on the company they've even attacked google and youtub

machine contributed to the influence campaign both serving as a platform for criminal messaging using russian government funded outlets russian propaganda media outlets like r t i think it's a propaganda arm of government is definitely not on our side reports have it that russia not only wanted to weigh in in the election with the also want to undermine u.s. confidence the citizens confidence in our electoral process and in our democratic values while the experts we talked to believe that twitter might have been pressured into making the move against. it's them trying to curry favor with congress before having to go before congress and i know this is coming from from from from some sector in the government we just don't know which one yet but i think that when the hearings take place and twitter comes up and asked to explain this and they're going to come up and say hey look what we did now leave us alone it's not they're not going to leave them alone they're going to push them even more so when the hearings take place i think we're going to find out who behind the scenes is done this again i

first, the cnn exclusive right now, sources are telling us russian linked facebook ads were targeted at swing states as part of moscow's meddling in the u.s. pamela is working the story for us. key senators in the russian investigation, they are now speaking out. what are they saying? >> that's right. the top republican and democratic senators came out today and said they are still looking into possible collusion between the trump campaign and russia and an investigation that continues to widen in scope. tonight, the republican and democratic leaders of the senate intelligence committee say possible collusion between russia and the trump campaign is still an open question. ten months after their investigation began. >> the committee continues to look into all evidence, to see if there was any hint of collusion. >> do you have any evidence to suggest or rule out the president knew any of these contacts, the associates and russians. >> i thought i was pretty clear. the issue of collusion is still open. that we continue to investigate both intelligence and witnesses, and that we're not i

wow, could they have used phony russian propaganda? >> let me tell you something, if, in fact, the dossier was a basis for why and fifa warrant was issued, you are talking about going to court and

elections to mr trump and russia was blamed for this then they unfolded the russian hysteria and now any failure will be connected to us and one of the loudest complaints is coming from the politician who claims that russian interference cost the american presidency. in germany members of parliament have been hacked by russia. and france that crohn's campaign was hit by a massive cyber attack just before their presidential election. you know the evidence that russia has a hunk you e-mails no civil civil war there is no possible to so you've obviously a stated silversea a criminal group it really can be anyone. still the simplicity of the technical part can make us think it's just a simple person who created it and so this person can be in any country with any kind of motivation. maybe you've even seen the ads and on london underground one russian state funded propaganda distortion bragging watch our t.v. and find out who we are planning to. the fact is they're also opening a new scottish. goes to show you yet again the his stereo the absolute. boggling hysteria that occurs whenever the word russian. whenever it's even

russian government. today you see an indictment brought by an office of special counsel. that is using a very novel theory to prosecute mr. mandel man, regarding a fera filing. the united states government has only used that offense six times since 1966 and only resulted until one conviction. >> sean: six times since 1966, one conviction. like every america, paul manafort deserves the presumption of innocence. however he is being tried and convicted in the court of public opinion by what is an abusively biased trump hating media. as part of the news that came out today, george papadopoulos, he admitted he lied to the fbi. i think he's 29 years old. now i knew everybody in the trump campaign. i never heard about papadopoulos until today. and i think i knew everybody. now the white house says he was a volunteer. it seems that papadopoulos on his own was trying to create an an at this the clinton rush dossier like the hillary dnc president obama funded dossier. and he wasn't successful. so now that we have no trump collusion, here is what we do have to be tnight. this is what the media ig

elections to mr trump and russia was blamed for this than there unfolded the russian hysteria and now any failure will be connected to us and one of the loudest complaints comes from the politician who claims russian interference lost her the us presidency. in germany members of parliament have been attacked by russia. and france crowns campaigned with the head by a massive cyber attack just before their president. now the evidence that russia has a hockey to email no civil civil war that is not possible to seduce bisley a stated goal was to a criminal group it really time be anyone. still the simplicity of the technical code can make us think it's just a simple. creed did it and so this person can be in any country with any kind of motivation. maybe you've even seen the ads in a london underground one russian state funded propagandist or rag watch archy and find out who they are planning to. the fact is they're also opening a new scottish. goes to show you yet again the his stereo the absolute. boggling hysteria that occurs whenever the word russian. whenever it's even mentioned people say. russians are added again how

here in southern russia attending the ball by discussion club and our topic is us russian relations and the state of the world. family and. i think you are you. somehow. i. feel. like. i'm. so. i. can't alone yes embattled president plans to impose direct rule on the region as almost half a million people rally in barcelona and a show of defiance against the national government. earlier on saturday spain's prime minister asked for the senate to dismiss catalonia as leadership and said he wants new regional elections as soon as possible. euro skeptic party wins the czech republic parliamentary elections with a billionaire leader who many compared to donald trump said to become prime minister. the rights organizations warn that deaths could rise in the refugee camp this winter after.

the polish she still continues to beat on but i do use a lot of russian know. nomen cliche nomen clout to go the deep state in the night she is run stop all the.

if the russians are trying to do some things that would get our attention, that would cause us to say you know what, all the things that the russians suspect we have been doing inside russia, supporting opposition movements, trying to hasten democratic reform that they find very alarming, if what they are trying to do is to show they can do things here to knock it off we can test that proposition. just this past week during his first meeting with newly confirmed u.s. ambassador to russia, putin mentioned principles that he thought should guide the bilateral relationship. one is mutual noninterference in the internal affairs of the other side. we could look at that and say this is a bluff. he doesn't really mean that. but we could test it, too. we could pursue that and see. if the russians' goal is to bring down our democracy as opposed to get us to change our behavior toward them, they should not bite on this. they may play this out, play for time, but actually reaching a deal we should see if that hypothesis is true. i think that is one that we ought to investigate. because personall

are here in southern russia in solitary attending the ball by discussion club and our topic is us russian relations and the state of the world. as i do not. the mom now than the time to us most of this about cuts not down in the just that of the city i couldn't. i'm not sure. the months and years on the list my name in this. bill had. many of them no idea is the one that you. could. walk and it had. to end at one. in the house like on afghan women have now and the clock on the screen last month the lights. i had couple of. had it. coming in with. this not none of them says it's an open mind that. this intel thing. besides she added that the finished shift. in the lead into the ball of the body of chicken day in the month the cool thing made so forty. or less i mean the. few months of good. month of the middle of this is. not month to. get out most of us for the love of. the. you know how far the i'll see me. has. to do fall in the. north. on the. way up to the stop on the desert with his among his arms i'm going to play . this song. form in. here todd then let's. get out of the women. had

us an email. breaking news this hour twitter targets are blocking all. the latest attack on russian media the move twitter included in its report to congress. earlier offering. pain ahead of the us elections also. in the balance. in barcelona calling for the regional government to come up with concrete on what's next. the u.s. will release classified files into president kennedy's assassination after a fifty year deadline passes. one of the country's darkest episodes. twenty four hour news live from moscow this is r.t. international my names you know neil welcome to the program we begin with breaking news r.t. twitter has blocked all advertisements from this channel to get more on this joins me live in the studio dan what do we know about what is occurring here it's been a pretty a pretty long. story and one still very much developing we received a message from twitter it began very positively. saying we at twitter believe in freedom of expression and in speaking truth to power that's how this statement began it ended with the news that they're actually banning advertising by all ou

we're here in southern russia in sultry attending the ball by discussion club and our topic is us russian relations and the state of the world. what politicians do. put themselves on the line. to get accepted or rejected. so when you want to be president. some want. to go right to the press it's like before three in the morning can't be good. i'm interested always in the water. first. here's what people have been saying about rejected a night with us exactly just pull along awesome the only show i go out of my way to launch you know what it is that really packs a punch. yam is the john oliver of all. the americans do the same we are apparently better than that is a neighbor you have never heard of. jack tonight president of the world bank so very. seriously send us an email. young lecturer giovanni is handing out hot meals on the rio piedras campus. to. give. the sunday. there's a long line he hands out hundreds of meals every day and he said yes. we're . going to see the good in the city and. they want to see little said to my son you . make up for them on a simple. need a lot of. the sp

elections to mr trump and russia was blamed for this the unfolded this entire russian hysteria and now any failure will be connected to us and one of the loudest complaints is coming from the politician who claims that russian interference last time the american presidency. many members of parliament have been by russia. france. after cyberattack before their president. no the evidence that russia has a hockey e-mails since the civil war there is no possible to say you've stated silverstein a criminal group it really can be anyone. the simplicity of the technical part can make us think it's just a simple person who created it and so this person can be in any country with any kind of motivation. maybe you've even seen the ads and on london underground one russian state funded propaganda distorted bragging watch our t.v. and find out who we are planning to. the fact is they're also opening a new scottish. goes through. the hysteria the absolute. boggling hysteria that occurs whenever the word russian. whatever is even mentioned people say. rush is there added again how are they at it again i don't know but you know how the

if the russians are trying to do our things that would get attention that would cause us to say you know what, all the russians suspect we have been doing inside russia, supporting opposition trying to hasten reform this they find very alarming, if what they are is to show they can do things here to knock it off that proposition. just this past week during his newly eeting with confirmed u.s. ambassador to putin mentioned principles that he thought the bilateral relationship. one is mutual noninterference in internal affairs of the other side. we could look at that and say this is a bluff. doesn't really mean that. but we could test it, too. see.ould pursue that and if the russians' goal is to ring down our democracy as opposed to get us to change our behavior toward them they should this.te on they may play this out, play for a e but actually reaching deal we should not see if that hypothesis is true. we inking that is one that ought to investigate. because personally i suspect that this is something that they in pursuing.rested i will leave it at that. >> thank you very much, george. >

i'm really happy that it was us russians who were the first ones to try this technology in outer space i'm also really excited to see it because i've been in outer space numerous times but no idea how it looks in virtual reality but i know for sure that it's a unique experience that i think everyone would want to share is very cool or. lose your cool knowledge. i don't know i know people made this this is very credible which is doro is great that they not only do the important chops ask cosmonauts the also think about ordinary people who pay a lot of attention to space so make us feel like we are actually there. the front page of r.t. dot com check it out check it out see dot com as well for the latest news and so much more from us i'm kevin o. in for now saying thanks for watching this latest life news update. what politicians do you shop to. put themselves on the line to get accepted or rejected. so if you want to be president sure. somehow i want to. get you to go right to beatrice to see what the before story of the morning can't be good that i'm interested always in the waters in

machine contributed to the influence campaign both serving as a platform for criminal messaging using russian government funded outlets russian propaganda media outlets like r t i think it's a propaganda arm of government is definitely not on our side reports have it that russia not only wanted to weigh in in the election with the also want to undermine u.s. confidence the citizens confidence in our electoral process and in our democratic values the experts we talked to belief that twitter might have been pressured into making the move against dot. it's them trying to curry favor with congress before having to go before congress and i know this is coming from from from from some sector in the government we just don't know which one yet but i think that when the hearings take place and twitter comes up and asked to explain this and they're going to come up and say hey look what we did now leave us alone it's not they're not going to leave them alone they're going to push them even more so when the hearings take place i think we're going to find out who behind the scenes is done this again it's

us an e-mail. breaking news this hour twitter targets are blocking all. the move twittering included in its report to congress on the major russian meddling. offering. of. pain ahead of the us elections. also ahead the. future in the balance there in barcelona calling for the regional government to come up with. what is next. some intriguing will in the u.s. will release. president kennedy's assassination after a fifty year deadline passes lifting the lid on one of the country's darkest. four in the afternoon paulo levon thirty at night in mumbai and nine in the evening right here in moscow this thursday october the twenty sixth i mean you know neil welcome to the program we begin with breaking news. twitter block this channel from advertising on its platform on precedented an out of the blue well let's get straight into it further with our. social media giant said this was to do election interference actually what we know it's a story you know where the pro. really seems to thicken almost on a daily basis now or to you today received notice from twitter which began positively stating that twitter believes in freedom of expression and speaking truth to p

but he still is a little us russian relations through victim to the internal political situation in americacertain forces are using these relations to address the internal political problems in the u.s. but we are patient we're waiting to this process is over. now besides this the russian president also believes that there are many other issues that he needs to worry about that could be much more dangerous or no less dangerous than the difficulties between america and russia for example the north korean crisis because we often forget that russia shares a border with north korea something that always triggers instability in all trade is of course any kind of conflict in the middle east and that brings us to syria and that also takes us back to u.s. russia relations vladimir putin says that working with the americans on taking out the terrorists in syria and also on the syrian peace process is very challenging but still promising and he still hopes to do a lot of things together with washington when it comes to more than a billion dollars in cooperation in the energy sector. is hoping to do a

advertising service in the us without any notice to us the attacks against this channel started after january's u.s. intelligence report of alleged russian meddling there's never been any solid proof that r.t. influence the twenty sixteen us election despite a flurry ongoing of attacks in congress but one propaganda machine contributed to the influence campaign by serving as a platform for kremlin messaging using russian government funded outlets russian propaganda media outlets like r t i think it's a propaganda arm of government that is definitely not on our side reports have it that russia not only wanted to weigh in in the election with they also want to undermine u.s. confidence the citizens confidence in our electoral process and in our democratic values so what's really going on here well the experts we talked to believe twitter might have been pressured into making the move against us. it's them trying to curry favor with congress before having to go before congress and i know this is coming from from from from some sector in the government we just don't know which one yet that's the issue right now and i think that when the hear

if they are spreading this russian propaganda, they've been lying to you, the american people, using phony russian-american sources. this line has gone on for over a year. this is a real rush of collusion. the real russia story. robert mueller, wake up tonight. fox news has also confirmed the information is correct. in other words, we've been right for over a year. we want to point out another part of the washington. it was funded by an unknown republican client during the g.o.p. primary. this was before the dnc and hillary clinton's campaign to cover. okay, i want to know, who is that? was it one of the other candidates? senator mccain who reportedly gave it to the fbi? who is behind this? we need answers. it was mccain. he said he passed this dossier around. we want to wonder if this new information is the reason why the group behind the dossier --r bank records? follow the money. all of the mainstream media, they fell hook, line, sinker. her russian disinformation lying campaign to the american people during an election. the democrats, hillary clinton, they all lied to you for over

market entirely and by any means possible the russian foreign ministry described the campaign against media here as a witch hunt it started back in january with a us intelligence report into alleged russian meddling in the american election the report devoted seven pages just to our channel and it supposed influence on the two thousand and sixteen election accusing our channel of serving as a kremlin propaganda tool however no concrete evidence was given in the report in september the us justice department contacted r.t. contacted r.t. america service supplier demanding it register as a foreign agent in the us a law that was drafted to prevent the spread of world war two propaganda however registering would compromise the personal data of employees which the russian foreign ministry spokesperson explained was a safety issue for staff the fact that r.t. is no longer included in google's preferred u.s. advertising list won't concern the channel too much however r.t. is currently the world's biggest news network on you tube last month our channel smashed the five billion views mark on the website. i. knew. we value most i. i'll be back with more news

that the russian government interfered in the us election last year and moscow continues to meddle in the democratic processes of our friends and allies at that committee nomination hearing he pledged to meet dissidents and end human rights abuses no softly softly approach there and apparently something he was fond of doing during his beijing stint the best thing to do invite a few dissidents who are seeking freedom and want to expand democracy in china to the united states embassy the kind of thing that i used to do in any case his ties to russia go back further than just this week huntsman a corporation a chemical manufacturing company founded by jon huntsman sr has been in russia since the nine hundred ninety s. they still maintain multiple sites with the now traveling to the country previously in that capacity and years later he's back with a nod of approval from the u.s. president even though his relations with donald trump haven't always been warm just to say the least or jon huntsman now has one of the toughest diplomatic gigs of recent times just how he handles it may well hel

of all the discussion club and us russian relations and the state of the world. i'm. intentional. but. i'm just. saying yeah he was in the school for. the most part the a lot of. you know this isn't going to. get his beefy done of this not because of the beat but i mean. look. they would. welcome back to watching our two international flight from moscow i think tank called european values has released a damning report about r t and criticized more than two thousand people who have appeared on this channel and the institute which receives funding from the us and other western governments brands our guests as useful idiots the list of names is divided into seven categories including us political figures european and other international politicians as well as writers journalists and academics and indicates the number of times each guest appeared on r t and mentions the most relevant episodes here's what the authors of the report have to say about. purpose of this list is to identify individuals who either due to an awareness of r.t.s. political agenda or indeed explicit support of it

propaganda machine contributed to the influence campaign by serving as a platform for messaging using russian government funded outlets russian propaganda media outlets like r t i think it's a propaganda arm of government is definitely not on our side reports have it that russia not only wanted to weigh in in the election with they also want to undermine u.s. confidence of citizens confidence in our electoral process and in our democratic values unless we talk to believe twitter might have been pressured into making the move against r.t. . it's them trying to curry favor with congress before having to go before congress and i know this is coming from from from from some sector in the government we just don't know which one yet but i think that when the hearings take place and twitter comes up and asked to explain this and they're going to come up and say hey look what we did now leave us alone it's not they're not going to leave them alone they're going to push them even more so when the hearings take place i think we're going to find out who behind the scenes is done this again it's probably

here in southern russia in solitary attending the ball by discussion club and our topic is us russian relations and the state of the world. a few days later professor corp a sent us some emails and photos of scientists he suspects of being close to the food industry. to americans he came across at a conference on meat and cancer. and nathan bryant. as we checked out these scientists profiles we discovered a document which should certainly never have been on the web. internal report issued by the american meat institute. it lays out the strategy for influencing the decisions of high profile organizations. this organization is the i r c international agency for research on cancer. this institution based. is the worldwide reference on cancer. in two thousand and six i see scientists classified nitrites in the probably carcinogenic category of products group too. and that was bad for business. so lobbyists are fighting to have this classification changed. page sixty four of a document. changing the r.c. nitrate nitrate classification from two to be. possibly carcinogenic. the strategy has

us russian relations and the state of the world. thanks. a million people will protest in catalonia as madrid decides to impose direct rule dismissing key officials and call for a regional election. r t has been under scrutiny with the u.k.'s foreign secretary boris johnson britain's the times newspaper and a european think tank all slamming this channel and insulting our guests. the pentagon hails the liberation of the syrian city of raka from islamic state by u.s. backed opposition forces though the city has been left in ruins.

we're here in southern russia in solitary attending the ball by discussion club and our topic is us russian relations and the state of the world. how does it feel to be a share of the greatest job in the world it's as close to being a king as any job there is what business model helps to run a prison now we just do or don't like and nobody obeys the case and i don't no one comes in anymore when i was a sergeant many more is cost effective that's what they want to do that knowing they don't give a damn if you do the chores are not actually paying enough to put them back into the louisiana incarceration rate is twice as high as the u.s.n. bridge what secret is behind such success. at the plate for many flips over the years so i know the guy even saw. football isn't only about what happens on the pitch for the final school it's about the passion from the fans it's the age of the super money kill the narrowness in spending city to twenty million. it's an experience like nothing else on earth because i want to share what i think i know about the beautiful guy great so well with. the beaks. the h

us russian relations and the state of the world. give me no. if it's this and i'm not to run intentional that's it would be theo i know there's no subtlety but i was just. yeah he was on the stool for the sunday times not all of us hoping to know much about the a lot of the behind the about the. needles on the she does that count she did the militia and got a real. killer the name of the kid is the food out of this not because of this not to be but i mean. he. gets to live it up with a. telly if. they are. like somehow i. thought i feel. like a little. bit. like. that i'd. feel. i was. almost half a million protesting catalonia as madrid decides to impose direct rule dismiss the regional officials poll for us not election. policy has been under scrutiny with the u.k. foreign secretary boris johnson britain's the times newspaper and a european think.

the ball by discussion club and us russian relations and the state of the world. give me. i'm not to run. but. nurse. says yeah he was in the school for the. most part of the a lot of them on how to eat. she does that ounce you don't need to know this and got very. little then i'm a little bit is beefy does this not because of the beat but i mean. look. good. and welcome back to watching r t international a think tank called european values has released a damning report about our team and criticized more than two thousand people who have appeared on this channel now the institute which receives funding from the us and other western governments brands our guests useful idiots and the list of names is divided into seven different categories including us political figures european and other international politicians as well as writers journalists and academics it indicates the number of times each guest appeared on our t.v. and mentions in the most relevant episodes here's what the authors of the report have to say about it. the purpose of this list is to identify individuals

i'm really happy that it was us russians who were the first ones to try this technology in outer space i'm also really excited to see it because i've been in outer space numerous times but no idea how it looks in virtual reality but i know for sure that it's the journey. experience that i think everyone would want to share this is very cool what is the absolute knowledge. i didn't know people made this this is very incredible which is doro is great that they not only do the important tropes ask cosmonauts the also think about ordinary people who pay a lot of attention to space to make us feel like we are actually there. were that. quick reminder as well that's also where you can find the breaking news as well that we had in the russian airstrike taking out twelve high profile commanders from the terror group who are in syria a leader in critical condition thanks for watching i'm kevin go in with more in fifty minutes. manufacture consent to public wealth. when the ruling class is protect themselves. we can all middle of the room see. here's what people have been saying about rejected a

dock emailed about setting up a meeting between the campaign and russian leadership to discuss us russian ties. the white house insists papadopoulos was a volunteer largely ignored, and investigators are looking in the wrong direction. >> there is clear evidence of the clinton campaign colluding with russian intelligence. >> last week it was revealed that hillary clinton's campaign, and the democratic national committee, paid for reserve that much contained claims about connections between the trump campaign and russia. clinton and event monday night promoting her book addressed yesterday's indictment. >> we don't need a lengthy investigation to tell us that trump is ignoring the intelligence community about an urgent threat. >> and lawmakers from both sides of the aisle warned against calls to fire special prosecutor robert mueller or for the president to pardon those indicted. the white house suggested wording very carefully there was no plans to pursue either at this time. live in the sat center, henry rostenkowskioff, cbs-3, eyewitness flues. >> thank you, hen. >> i and cbs this morni

situation with us russian relations i mean with good reason but does it matter it is so much as it used to should we lived. so much because things go awol and it's certainly highly regrettable and in my view largely unnecessary but exactly we do need to keep in mind that compared to the cold war where you had soviet forces in the middle of germany you had nuclear forces on trigger alert and you had to genuinely clash radically clashing world ideologies this is a much much smaller dispute but in the same time the me if you look at mainstream media their threat level seems to be equal if no worse well you're a journalist i used to be a journalist to do newspapers television advertising has to be so right in what journalist ever made a name by playing down a proverb more or a conflict but in my view i mean the areas of dispute local post imperial problems in the former soviet union of a kind which we've seen in formal western them as well and they are of course disputes but in my view heidi to an extent limited disputes.