is our system, we were more this mentions vanderbilt cost about 60 grand villa is right at the top 20hose who are already -- our future leaders in just a few years will be running things which is the lender luxury believes enter through the realities that make them possible will threaten every hard work freedom of what -- like public safety, the border, in neutral media, a legal system to make sure they funny? sure. but maybe not so much. because a lot more at stake here than tampons. periods! >> announcer: periods! >> greg: let's welcome the next guest! he looked like mystically after a car accident. million to norton! as a former miss florida citrus, she's curvy and primitive scurvy, also the more -- morgan ortega! she celebrated easter by hanging with her peeps, new york times best selling author kat timpf! and he's got wait line wrinkles and in any -- [cheering and applause] >> greg: jim, i know you're a compassionate person. you're concerned about today's issues. and i admire that the imagine being the parents of that brat. >> while i don't like to see those brave warriors reputa

i'm a proud alumni of vanderbilt.ing squashed, police are being called in. can you speak to the other outlets. you are allowing protests on campus but other outlets for civil debate on a complicated and emotional issue. >> thank you, willie. good morning. we have had lots of discussions. to give you an example, in the week when this event happened, we had both the israeli ambassador and former prime minister of the palestinian authority on campus. we had hundreds of students having discussions with them. it was an incredible opportunity to have discourse on a challenging topic. that is the way to handle the type of issues on universities. there will be students that want to protest. they have to do it in a way that is in line with university rules. they can't do it in classrooms, disrupting them with a megaphone and they can't go into closed buildings, either. >> can you explain the concept of principle neutrality, institutional neutrality that you talked about for some time and wrote about again in "the wall street j

amna: vanderbilt has been among those that have seen their own protests.27 students forced their way into the close administration building. i understand i campus security officer was injured. most of the students had to be escorted out and four were arrested. help us understand the line for you. why were the students arrested and some expelled? >> overall things on campus have done very well. they have had to vigils, in-depth discussions. we had a passover celebration a few days ago with 400 students on our mainline and some students and protesters on both sides, we have had displays of the victims in gaza, displays of the hostages, so all of that is going well, but a month ago we had a small group of students that a force their way into a closed building, an administrative building. they ran over a security officer and tried to get into my office. they tried to push over some of my staff there but did not succeed, and then set down in the hallway, and after a few hours we told them this is inconsistent with university policy, that this is disruptive cond

amna: vanderbilt has been among those who have seen their own protests.e march incident, 27 students for your -- forster their way into a closed administration building. a campus officer was injured. most of the students had to be escorted out. four were arrested, is my understanding. why were those students arrested and some expelled? daniel: overall over the last six months things on campus have done very well. our students have done great. they had vigils and in-depth discussions. we had a passover celebration just a few days ago with 400 students on our main law. and some students are protesting as well on both sides. we have had displays for the victims in gaza, displays for the hostages. all of that has gone very well. but about a month ago we had a small group of students that forced their way into our main administration building where we are still doing construction. they ran over a security office and then try to get into my office. they tried to push over some of my staff but did not succeed and sat down in the hallway. then after a few hours w

i experience better conditions than a vanderbilt. i access to water. i had access to a bathroom. i had access to my friends and the ability to rest. how dare this university deprive of basic humanity? we demand that vanderbilt reinstate the referendum, that they drop all charges against students that were filed under false pretenses. that they drop in suspensions and harassment from administration and that they issued an immediate apology to what we experienced over the 24 hours. >> you must know, oh, you they? feeling that tampon was actually for that guy? a oh, i mean, it did look a little bloated. and, you know, if it is your time of the month, dude, maybe don't plane moa on risking jai. >> instead, try the red roof in. nope, nope but let's recount the facts. >> according to the reporting, they trespass in a building, assaulted a guard, put staffers who offered to meet with them. then they sat down, refused to leave. so how do you think an act wit of uncivil disobedience ends with mommy cominh g to tucks you in? getting arrested is the idea. thate you singt wheridea . we shall

i'm a proud alumni of vanderbilt. the chancellor has done at the school the last few years. i want to ask, we hear at vanderbilt and other places, too, that free speech is being squashed by the administration, that police are being called in. can you speak to some of the other outlets that you're allowing protest, of course, on campus, but there are also other outlets you've provided for civil, open debate on a very complicated and emotional issue. >> well, thank you very much, willie. good morning. we have had lots of discussions. to give one example, in the week when this event happened, we had both the israeli ambassador and the former prime minister of the palestinian authority on campus. we had 100 students having discussions with them. it was an incredible opportunity for them to have real civil discourse on what is a challenging topic. that's the way we should handle these type of issues on universities. there will be students that want to protest, but they have to do it in a way that is in line with university

there's going to be some opposition when it's the tennessee senate, there's some vanderbilt up in the rafters, heckling, but nevertheless it's going to pass a lot of enthusiasm and be signed into law by governor austin peay. now it's going to be tricky because the state men dated biology textbook hunters, civic biology, he did include significant discussions of darwin's theories of evolution, chapter 14 and particular so the state science teachers now will have to carefully use the school's textbook so as not to run afoul of the law. and law, which was part of kind of a growing anti evolution movement in a number of portions of the country caught the eye of an organized founded in 1920 called the american civil union. many of you have heard of them before. they're still around. and the aclu you was an organization formed around world war one during what is known to historians as the red scare when lots of people with beliefs sympathetic to socialism and communism are were arrested for the things that they were saying and and the aclu created by folks on the american left to defend the

. >> i went to vanderbilt university.sh their way into kirkland hall from the chancellor's office and pushed aside in an armed security guard and sat there for 20 hours doing exactly what you are talking about, joe. and the chancellor that runs vanderbilt ultimately said, you are all suspended and then one by one reviewed their cases and expelled three of the students and said, they have given you a place for free speech and to protest and to voice your opinion. and created symposiums where both sides of the discussion can be heard. you didn't participate in that but you broke into the office and set here so three of you are no longer students at the university. that was one of the first schools to do that. and i think you see more of it now since it. jeremy peters from the new york times is writing about this on how the administrators are responding to a surgeon anti- israel protests on campus and also with the ceo of the anti- defamation league, jonathan green,'s group has more data on anti-semitic incidents in the unit

you live near the trauma center at vanderbilt hospital. and so there is something, first of all, that's really intense when it happens in your community and. i think that's part of it for me was the intensity of seeing it happen, seeing that trauma happen in my community was different from studying guns and other places. i think that the first level for me, but then the second part was, you know there's breaking news and this has not this has happened a number of times now. nashville, where the covenant school shooting last year, other shootings, there was one at a middle school, the other this shooting 2018. and you hear there's a there's a shooting, the waffle in the waffle house in, south nashville. and if you live in you know, that's not the cowboy boots and country bars part of town that is the black and brown part of town. that's where there are black communities and latino communities and kurdish communities. and so you think like, well, gosh, that's really intense. there must be a mass shooting in the in the south part of town and

. >> i'll speak for -- you know, i went to vanderbilt university.y've had a lot of this on their campus in recent weeks. a group of students a couple weeks ago pushed their way into kirkland hall, where the chancellor's office is. they pushed aside an unarmed security guard, sat there for 20 hours doing exactly what you're talking about, joe. >> no. >> the chancellor said, you're all suspended, and one by one, reviewed their cases and expelled three of the students. >> good. >> said, "we've given you a place to have free speech. we've given you a place to protest. we've given you a space to voice your opinion. we have symposiums where both sides of this discussion can be heard. you didn't participate in that, but you broke into our office and sat here. three of you are no longer students of this university." that was one of the first schools to do that, and you've seen more since then. jeremy peters of "the new york times" is writing about this. he has new reporting on how those administrators are responding to a surge in anti-israel protests on cam

3 times in a mirror they let the guy go. 6 of the squatters are back in the basement thankfully vanderbilts are delivering them tampons it's the same thing i say in a port authority restroom, how did we get here. look no further then the head of the new york state assembly with him being 1 of the brains behind bail reforms which have been emulated across the nation and universally successful if your metric is body count. more blood on his hands than doogie house after in 18 hour shift. he says i don't believe raising penalties as a deterrent on crime he said that with history and shameless face so if there's amount olympus of stupid we found there is a we've found our suits. where does he get his research is human nature denying the reality it's like denying intelligence because you are. [ bleeps ] stupid. was he ever acted as his parents never slapped him then can we ask them to slap him now does he not realize they -- animals trained their young with bad behavior for punishment. single celled blobs recoiled from discomfort that phrase at around and find out isn't just an expression it's

we had a college president vanderbilt.y just simply said if you are going to break our rules suspended. the students were historical and terrified. all you have to do is deport 5,000 people here and nobody else boo come. we have it in our power to stop the madness. it's such orthodoxy and group think that we don't have enough people standing up and say i'm not going to do this anymore. once people stop doing it. the commercial of in the early 2,000s they filled a hammer and ball into the screen the o. wellian figure shatters. it's not based on any contribution to civil situation it's nihilistic if we all speak up it would crumble. people don't like it. they don't want to be called a racist, sen xenophobe. >> they hate this idea of people living with their families going to church regularly or maybe going to a patriotic music festival as you saw with kid rock over the weekend that makes them very uncomfortable. and they feel like they need to do something about it, victor. i have noticed this and only picked up in recent ye

i know they've reached vanderbilt university in nashville, tennessee.does it bring to mind for you the antiwar protest of the '60s? >> it does. it is, as you say, it's an unusual level of public demonstration. around the country. i suppose, perhaps, the anti- apartheid protest, of the '80s might be on this scale, but i think that you are seeing a number of complicated and important debates over not just the substance of these issues, but the style, if you will. the means by which these protest are being undertaken. i think that part of it, too, is, and this is pure speculation on my part, i wonder if part of it is that the middle east question has, in some ways, given an entire generation that has lived in an era in which public action has not to deliver, that is, if you think about this generation, the students i teach, this will make both of us feel old, they were born after september 11th, right? their lives, the failure of intelligence on weapons of mass destruction, the great recession, donald trump's rise, covid, insurrection, you have this remark

there could be more but what we've seen in a major way, rice and purdue and vanderbilt, columbia in newcity. yale as well. i see notre dame in the bottom corner as well. from the west coast william la jeunesse on the far-left groups paying for and likely stoking these campus protests today. william, what did you find out? good morning. >> good morning, bill. at least 1.3 million came from two liberal foundations, rockefeller brothers and george soros. other democrat led dark money groups funnel money outside the i.r.s. that pay for talking points, posters, recruiting and activists. universities go bank roll activities groups. where is their money coming from? protest groups go by different names. the largest students for justice in palestinian receives funds, among others, from a liberal new york foundation called west pack as well as activity fees charged to each student by their university. according to the watchdog group ngo monitor. none of these universities would tell us how much student money is given to pro-palestinian groups. >> the fact that universities are hiding or giving e

col we have a college presidentus vanderbilt, they just simply said if you break our roles, you willsuspended.ts the students went hysterical and were terrified. all you would have to do is close the border and deport 5,000 people here and nobody else would come. so we have it in our power to stop the madness.'s it is such an orthodoxy in such groupthink that we don't havendn enough brave people standing upo to say, "i'mt not going to dong this anymore."th but once they start doing it it is like the commercial of the apple in early 2000 or less they throw the hammer and the ball on the screen and orwellian figure shadows and it all dissipates. it is not based on any positive message really contribution to civilization. it ivis nihilistic. if we would all speak up, i think it would crumble because people don't like it, they really don't, but they are afraid to speak out because they don't want to be called racist, xenophobe, whatever. >> laura: they really do hate te this idea of americans who are just living their lives with her family is to church regularly,ic may be going to a patr

richard blackett, andrew jackson, professor of history emeritus at, vanderbilt university, discussing fugitive slaves and the coming of the civil war at the end of presentation. the speaker will take questions from the floor. we have two roving microphones. if you have a question or indeed a comment, please raise your hand and the microphone will find you. so further ado, please welcome me. help. welcome dr. blackett to the podium. dr. richard blackett. thank you. okay. good to see so many people gathered in the morning on a saturday morning, of all things. uh, makes reminds me of my. 9:00 class as an undergraduate when people were forced to be. huh. okay. i wish to use to fuze fugitive slave incidences as to our discussion today. the first involve the failed attempt to escape on the pearl from washington, d.c. in april 1848. the second the successful freeing of daniel webster otherwise known as daniel danger. freed from philadelphia in april, 1859. they provide a useful symmetry. the on the eve of the discussion about the need for a more stringent fugitive slave law, the attempted es

have popped up at schools across the country places like the university of maryland, in michigan, vanderbiltversity, uc, berkeley, also an encampment at the university of minnesota where some students were arrested earlier today as the result of an encampment. no expectations this will wrap up any time soon. >> valerie, thank you. >>> now to a first in the nation bill targeting frequent flyers who avoid the usual security line at airports. . the california proposal would ban the screening company clear in operating in regular screening line. it all comes down to equity for travelers. steve patterson has been following this one for us. steve, this got our team talking. first off, remind us how does clear work and why is this service now being targeted by lawmakers. >> reporter: if you're a frequent flyer you've seen those kiosk, a clear, with a guy clipboard trying to get you to sign up, a service $199 a year or so, you're able to scan and you get escorted to the front of the line, you skip the general security line that's the part that lawmakers are concerned about and i want to be clear abo

let's see if they continue in the way that vanderbilt and google have decided maybe they'll start tong moves this week. brooke, omar's daughter was one of those arrested and tweeted this. those of us in gaza solidarity encampment will not be intimidated and stand resolute until our demands are met. di visment from companies -- full amnesty for all students facing repression. that was on x and where to next do you think? >> exactly. what does it say about our society right now that the daughter of a sitting member of congress is arrested at a pro-terror rally where she was amongst people who are chanting death to the jews, death to america, who are saying we are hamas, who were abusive to the police. guess what? 108 people were arrested and i thank the nypd for doing that and paul was right. columbia finally stepped up and asked the police to remove them for trespass. all of them were released from jail and cheering and proud of what they have done. what is the deterrent effect here? will the district attorney alvin bragg even prosecute them? pressure has to be put on the d.a.'s offic

the things talking about the hostages was something that the israeli ambassador talked about at vanderbiltreception that i did bury them. one of the thing that the ambassador told us is they believe him. he emphasized. most of the high value hostages that are left likely surrounding the head of hamas and other key places. it is very difficult to do these hostage negotiations. hamas has to go back to doesn't want to use electronic communication. they are trying to physically get to him for these hostage negotiations. if hamas gives up these hostages, they know it is game over for them. i just want to say it is very important to israelis to get there hostages home. it should be just as important to this administration and all americans that we get these americans home. three have already been killed in captivity. we have 5 left. we should be doing everything to bring them home. >> harris: what kind of a deal? i'm trying to figure this out. you have done a lot of closing arguments. it takes a deal to get to the in the back. there were hundreds of thousands of people in the streets in israel a

article earlier this week that was summarizing expulsions, arrests, suspensions, et cetera, from vanderbilt oh, the courage of these institutions as they face -- the rich is just stunning. lex mcmenamin, thank you very much, and that is tonight reidout. cheers. and by the by, you can follow me on the tiktok and on instagram. and please follow our show accounts on instagram and tiktok at the readout. so you can always be in the know. all in with chris hayes starts now. >>> tonight on all in. >> well, the jury selection is

but you know, the president of vanderbilt university wrote a really great piece, talking about the talentsty for all students, and free speech. it can be reached, but not if administrators react in fear, and that's what they are doing. as far as the political situation, i do think, like the demonstrators at universities around our country, the biden campaign is hoping these students will go home. but you know? these students also have a big responsibility that they have to take on. if they hear river to the sea or pro-hamas, or anti-semitic remarks, they should call their students, their fellow students out. it's remarkable how little these students know about what they are doing. they seem to want to get involved in something versus supporting it. for example, if they want to cease-fire why aren't they calling out hamas for not agreeing to the terms of a six- week cease-fire, along with the release of 33 hostages in exchange, again, for hundreds of palestinians in that six- week cease-fire? they don't even know about it, jonathan. this gets me so angry, and i can imagine how it's really b

at vanderbilt there were suspensions and expulsions over it.en sasse and i am loath to praise the university of florida because i went to university of georgia, go dogs, but they were clear from october 7th on this is how we will do with us and welcome speech but lay down the law when it came to not speech. >> john: very big eight contradiction between what the white house is saying about biden trying to have it both ways and what members of the squad are saying like aoc saying at the by an event coming up praising the protesters listen to what ilhan omar said in minnesota last night. >> i am incredibly moved by her courage and bravery as a student body inputting your bodies on the line to stand in solidarity to end the genocide taking place in gaza at this moment. >> john: they are waving their terrible towels if you are a pittsburgh fan and saying "go team" what about the idea of student -- jewish students being harassed and feeling threatened not safe on campus, anti-semitism? they are delineating saying oh, we will ignore that all of that i

he overknight vanderbilt wants chief of staff released a rare statement in english about the situation. >> we remain at our highest level of readiness. iran will face the consequences for its actions we will choose our response accordingly. >> as military preparations continue, israel is trying to put diplomatic pressure on iran. the country's foreign minister reportedly calling dozens of diplomats around the world asking them to put new sanctions on iran's missile program. this as there were soldiers in northern israel today bracing for the possibility of a wider regional war. wrapping up drills there and just about an hour we are going to see a piece of a an iranian ballistic missile fired at this country. we will bring that to you next hour. guys, back to you. >> steve: all right, trey, thank you very much. live here in new york city let's bring in mike sarraille, host offer day warrior podcast. mike, good morning to you. >> thank you for having me. >> as we just saw israel is getting ready to do something but at the same time we heard from the white house on sunday that we, the uni

there's been in the cabin at vanderbilt for one month or maybe more.s interesting to see how columbia is positioning not only as ivy league but also in new york city has brought such particular attention to our campus. >> with regard to those students, jewish students in particular, who have had to leave the campus and start learning remotely for fear of safety, what has been the reaction to that of the students in the encampment and elsewhere? >> it is a very complicated issue because i think in a lot of regards, the encampment itself has a series of community guidelines, one of his which is no harassment, no engaging with counter protesters or trying to harass students at all. however, there have been one- off incidences and there have been pretty severe cases in which campus rabbis and other leaders on the campus are telling jewish students that it is not safe for them and there reporting to us that it is not safe. there's definitely a tension there and i think part of it is that the students in the encampment are very certain on the sense that thei

i will speak for my own school at vanderbilt. you guys talked a lot about dartmouth, where they're having these discussions. they're bringing in an israeli ambassador and somebody the head of the palestinian authority, and they're explaining their sides. they're having a civil debate. no one has a hammer. no one is yelling. >> it's great. >> they're giving people places on campuses to protest. then, in the case of vanderbilt anyway, when they stormed into a building and broke a window, pushed a security guard aside, and sat there for a day, the students were suspended. they looked individually at all their cases and expelled a handful of them. we've given you all these outlets, jonathan. we give you places to have these conversations, which is what college is supposed to be. you don't have to pick a side. listen to the debate. >> totally. >> but, i mean, do you think any of the people in the building at columbia right now actually want to have that conversation? >> look, president shafik needs to deliver consequences, not make co

time this afternoon talking about the retirement of stanford women's head basketball coach tara vanderbilt ktvu idea of the day. we asked image generator midjourney to imagine the coach enjoying retirement playing bridge with her mom. perhaps on a tropical island somewhere? a well-deserved retirement for sure. the 5:00 news is coming my dry eye's made me a burning, stinging, 5-times-a-day,... ...makeup smearing drops user. i want another option that's not another drop. tyrvaya. it's not another drop. it's the first and only nasal spray for dry eye. tyrvaya treats the signs and symptoms of dry eye disease fast by helping your body produce its own real tears. common side effects include sneezing, cough, and throat and nose irritation. relying only on drops? not me. my own real tears are my relief. ask your eye doctor about tyrvaya. major plane suppliers like boeing and airbus are dealing with production shortages. fox's kelly saberi reports on the latest industry challenges that boeing whistleblower says that he was working on. >> the 787 team when he noticed that the company was taking shor

shaye worked at gao for 25 and holds a doctorate in sociology from vanderbilt university. canada check government affairs director of the financial accountability and corporate transparency coalition, the fact coalition, where she leads the groups encasement with federal policymakers. before joining the fact coalition, ms. hanichak work with u.s.-based nonprofits focus on advancing transparent corporate governance accountability and roll along in the middle east. her work support the passage of the networks that fuel mass human rights violations in series and the middle east, and she campaigned to augment counter terror finance measure to prevent the diversion and abuse of using military aid. i appreciate all of you being here and ms. dezenski please proceed. i i would also like to recommend senator hassan has jaundice, a valuable member of this caucus. >> german white house, cochair grassi, members of the congress, thank you so much for the opportunity to be here to discuss the corporate transparency act and the important work to abolish the opaque corporate structures th

. >>> and coming up on "morning joe," the chancellor of vanderbilt university will join the conversationprotests are playing out there. >>> plus as i mention the mother of an american israeli hostage will be a guest after the release of a hamas propaganda video featuring her son. >>> also ahead live reporting from lower manhattan where donald trump's criminal hush money trial is set to resume later this morning and also to the supreme court where justices await trump's immunity claims today. "morning joe" is just moments away. "morning joe" is just moments away ah, these guys are intense. with e*trade from morgan stanley, we're ready for whatever gets served up. dude, you gotta work on your trash talk. i'd rather work on saving for retirement. or college, since you like to get schooled. that's a pretty good burn, right? later this morning and also to later this morning and also to (psst! psst!) ahhh! with flonase, allergies don't have to be scary. spraying flonase daily gives you long lasting non-drowsy relief. flonase all good. also, try our allergy headache and nighttime pills. with th

he lived off fifth avenue near the vanderbilts and the carnegies. a millionaires row. his fleet class company had captured the region's lucrative accounts, such the new york state capitol in albany and metropolitan opera have been hot. he took home an annual salary. $1 million, approximately $30 million in 2023. monies. he was a virtual doppelganger her for andrew a definite look alike. they were both wealthy, had a similar persona. one was virtuous, while the other vicious a corrupt, weak man. there were the same age. both celebrating their 83rd birthday. the birthdays for two weeks apart. although his wife was the seas for a few years, he had an ongoing relationship with. hannah liz. for over a decade, she blackmailed him when she became pregnant with gwendolyn the prior year the baby died a few months later. for the remaining few hours of this day, the relationship would remain clandestine. 1:15 p.m. hannah's carriage departs. 236 central park, west horse hooves on the cobblestones hannah inhales, the fresh november air. 1:20 p.m. cornell is sweating nervously paces