, yes, this is a very subtle phrase, joseph was precisely one of the most free subtle phrase of viktor kuleis is not just opposition to violence, opposition to violence, false collectivism, but this is a deep internal freedom, which includes god. now there are a lot of such situations, when people argue about what specifically to write about, about this it is necessary, about this it is not necessary, but brodsky teaches this, does not teach, how this does not teach anything, and brodsky gives an example of what is not important, what is important is how, of course, and art is about how, exactly. speaks as a poet, well, i am simplifying a lot, but such is the story, in the beginning was the word, the word was with god, there was god, so the thing here is that the poet, he deciphered, he often in interviews in some other essays there flashed this thought that the poet is an instrument of language for the continuation of his existence, as a person, in fact, the people's tool for continuing their existence. what we found out today with you, dear friends, we talked about brodsky, of course, but