accountable but believe this resolution sh absolutely necessary going forward >> thank you for visor farrell. supervisor mar >> thank you. i'm in total disagreement with my colleagues farrell, wiener and cohen. every day we get new reports this from the hayward burns institute on san francisco racism and ethnic disparities and from cj colonel and social justing organization, this is not a appropriate way to look at keeping our communities safe though i know supervisor wiener mentioned that is his approach. i wanted to speak in strong respect to the many people who came out from the mission district again and again from bayview and fill more and others and all the communities. 283 police are not going to make the community safer it is community based programs and youth programs many people from the chambers work in. how we address the killings of [inaudible] lopez, alex [inaudible] and others is a critical part of what we do as a board. supervisor avalos's amendments are a multipronged approach to look how we make the community safer with community resources not just police officers. the need

sfr visor cohen, no. supervisor farrell, aye. supervisor kim, no. supervisor mar, no. supervisor tang, aye. there are 4 aye and 7 no. >> the motion to amend the duplicated file fails. colleagues any other comments? supervisor wiener did you--no. so, we have a duplicated file that is in front of us as well, supervisor breed, how do you want to proceed? >> i want to send the duplicated file to budget committee. >> so we vamotion to send that. madam clerk we need a second on that the motion. second by supervisor tang . do you want to have a roll call on that motion? >> supervisor wiener, aye. supervisor yee, aye. supervisor avalos, no. supervisor breed, aye. supervisor campos, no. supervisor christensen, aye. supervisor cohen, aye. supervisor farrell, aye. supervisor kim, no. supervisor mar, no. supervisor tang, aye. there are 7 aye and 4 no with noes being avalos campos kim and mar >> the duplicated file motion passes and the duplicated file will be sent back to committee. >> that you can r thank you and on the under lying item can we have a roll call vote madam clerk? >

sfr visor cohen, no. supervisor farrell, aye. supervisor kim, no. supervisor mar, no. supervisor tang, aye. there are 4 aye and 7 no. >> the motion to amend the duplicated file fails. colleagues any other comments? supervisor wiener did you--no. so, we have a duplicated file that is in front of us as well, supervisor breed, how do you want to proceed? >> i want to send the duplicated file to budget committee. >> so we vamotion to send that. madam clerk we need a second on that the motion. second by supervisor tang

sfr visor cohen, no. supervisor farrell, aye. supervisor kim, no. supervisor mar, no. supervisor tang, aye. there are 4 aye and 7 no. >> the motion to amend the duplicated file fails. colleagues any other comments? supervisor wiener did you--no.

supervisor farrell, aye. sfr visor kim, aye. supervisor mar, aye. supervisor tang. aye. there are 11 aye's >> the item passed on the first reading. madam clerk item 21 >> ord noons amendment the planning and public works code for development project to shift authority from planning department to public work to require a permit on a street tree within a disance of a advertising plan to [inaudible] to adopt a fee to impose penalities for violation jz for public work staff [inaudible] sequa determination >> supervisor wiener >> colleagues we have been working very hard a broad coalition to try to improve the cities approach to the urban forest including street streets. we have over 100 thousand street trees and the policy dumps responsibility for the trees on the property owners guarantees inconsistent maintenance and is just a very bad approach of having a robust urban forest which is important for our environment and quality of life so need to make a change in the policy. the legislation before us today is one piece, one small piece of improving our approach to our urban