robinson thank you visser chairman. >> thank you, senator welch? i think you mr. chairman.i want to thank all the witnesses are being here for you have been tremendous enemies every single one of you. we are done with issues that really affect people in a very personal way. mr. walker, thank you for your courage. thank you for coming forward and telling us your short story aensuring it. i want to say thank you to everyone of you. this whole challenge we have as a society and it is not unique to the u.s. society, defining people who are other as less title to be fully accepted as been an ongoing situation we face throughout our history. recently in vermont will be the first state to pass civil unions the incumbent governor sign that bill nearly lost hisrl reelecti. many of the arguments being made here about why that would be bad dissolved. once the law was passed in people work together then what before had been seen as wrong, we were allowed to see what love existed between this people got a civil union. in a few years later varanasi state to pass marriage. what senator wa