vitaly kulyk, director of the center for researching civil society problems a-a p vitaliy good health, thank you, it's time for us, you 're a simple and difficult question about china's 12 points , all zinkina, does china really want to play or does it want to show a desire to play and just if join this circle of countries that are now deciding the fate of the world. i may have said it defiantly, but it seems to me that this is what the chinese are really doing, or is he just throwing the ball and waiting to see what will happen , but he has already thrown the ball and if any negotiations begin, he is already there if he participates, if there is one superpower, not only america, but also the chinese superpower. in the sense of the official pickin, that is, what do you say about these 12 points, in my opinion, this is not a plan, it is , by and large, a vision of the vision of the war in ukraine, which is happening in ukraine from the side in china, these are by no means action plans that can be chosen and implemented . there are no such points that would arouse our unconditional supp