i brought with me exhibit a, vivianeles. i read every comment the selection made including hers. they said in effect because she was from public housing she lacked the sophistication to put on an event. i read e-mails where it said some of the commissioners would not drive their vehicles in the bayview. i read the research and that's a violation of chapter 12 of san francisco administrative code that i have followed for 20 years. >> mr. williams, how does this reflect on puc as opposed to the arts commission? >> because the money, this is the source of the funding as the grantor, they are the grantee. there is a contract that i have asked for that is supposed to be signed by city attorney dave herrera and they have refused to give it to me. i have asked for it for 30 days. they are not following the law. we are talking about simply doing that which the grant agreement requires. since they have not done so and followed the sunshine ordinance process, the funding has to be revoked. the grant agreement says it must be terminated if they fail to comply with city ordinances. they have