supervisor walton. walton. present. mr. president, there is a quorum. thank you. colleagues. can we have a motion to excuse supervisors melgar and stephanie made by supervisor mandelman seconded by supervisor walton. and we will take that without objection. madam clerk, do we have any communications or announcements? yes mr. president. the board welcomes all interested in this meeting to attend in person here in the legislature chamber room 250 at city hall. the this meeting is airing live on tv's channel 26 or you may view the live stream at sf nsf.gov tv.org. our office did not receive a request for a language interpretation today, so we do not have interpreters here. but as a reminder, if you anticipate a future need for them, please call (415) 554-5184. at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting. mr. president, that concludes my communication on. thank you. the san francisco board of supervisors acknowledges we are on the unceded ancestral homeland of the ramaytush ohlone, who are the original inhabitants of the san francisco peninsula, as the indigenous stewards of this

one of those innovators, sam walton. so sam walton, who is responsible for wal-mart, it's appropriate, perhaps, that we're in memphis because there are a lot of these innovators that were did important work in memphis. sam walton took a lot of ideas that other people had, and he made them work in context that a lot of other people thought was crazy. so when he was recruiting in the 1960s or 1950s, in 1960s, he would he would somebody who worked as an executive at a discount chain or something like that and say, hey, do you wanna come work for me? and then they would go to their boss at whatever discount they worked for and said, hey, i'm going to go work with this. walton and they say, fine, ruin your life. he's crazy. he thinks that discount retailer is going to work in the middle of nowhere, etc., and then, lo and behold, now here we are, is regularly at the top of the fortune 500 and they have, to coin a phrase, a lot of people to save and live better. what's the harm that wal-mart has caused, in your view, on that? t

. >> sam walton. he is responsible for walmart.t is appropriate perhaps we are in memphis was love is innovators that did important work in memphis. sam walton took a lot of ideas other people had and made them work in a context a lot of other people that was crazy. identify some who worked o executive at a discount chain or something like that and said you want to come work for me? then they go to their boss i'm going to work for this walton guy they said fine ruin your life or he's crazy et cetera. and lo and behold here we are walmart is readily at the top of fortune 500. they have to coin a fridge i love people to save more and live it better. stay what what is the harm walmart is causing your view? >> there isn't any. everybody can tell a horror story mischievous on it walmart walmart employs over 2 million people. it was a horrible thing that happened at walmart. i think on net walmart and searsfor the world. some research a good fraction of the increase in obesity over roughly two decades. but the additional standard of livi

on the motion to continue, vice chair walton walton. i supervisor sapphire. i sapphire chair dorsey. no. dorsey. no the motion to continue passes with chair dorsey dissenting and committee. great thank you, mr. clerk. and on item number one, charter amendment, minimum police staffing and five year annual funding requirement. as amendment moves to the full board on a 2 to 1 vote. it's not moving to the board. it's continued to move to the continued until next week. my apologies. thanks. the matters continue to our november 6th rules committee meeting as amended. thank you, mr. clerk. can you please call item number two? yes item number two is ordinance amending the administrative code to require the chief of police to adopt a foot and bike patrol strategy for the police department and to require the police commission to hold annual hearings regarding community policing and foot and bike patrols. thank you, mr. clerk. and this item is chiefly sponsored by supervisor safai, who spoke to it last week. but supervisor, do you want to anything you'd like to say abou

i see supervisor walton, supervisor walton, vice chair walton. thank you, chair. dorsey just a quick question, chief, because i heard supervisor sapphire's question about what this does with the police commission, and you said it doesn't change the way policies are vetted through the police commission. then why is this being proposed? what i said is if this passes, policies will still pursue policy will still have to be approved and adopted by the police commission. whatever comes out of this would still have to be approved and adopted by the police commission. and why are we putting this on the ballot? that's not a question for me, supervisor. i don't think i just had to let the public know. well what you're asking me, that's not i said that nothing changes. what is going to the ballot. so i think one thing, you know, we have to and this is not on you, chief, we have to let the voters we can't mislead voters. we have to be honest about what kind of conversations we're having, particularly when we have them in public forums and public settings. and chair dorsey, w

vice chair walton. gi want to thank my colleagues for comments on this legislation and to those this came to speak. thank you for your input. and especially debbie for the history lesson, 220 there was a report and i'm happy we are guesting around to impletting what was in this report that supervisor maxwell starred. i'm excite body this legislation and want to thank my chief of staff. and i'm looking forward to watching with the controller office does in developing the standards and when we do to monitor city dollars and make sure they are spent effectively. and to thank all the nonprofits we worked with and the nonprofit this is are out there doing sfuch great work i serve on the board in the city and watching what work can be done by people who are passionet about take care of others was amazing. thank you again. clothes and i look forward to your support and thank you sparz safai for joining. >> thank you. and i guess i would like to make a motion to send this to the full board with a positive recom

. >> guest: one of those innovators, sam walton. so sam walton who's responsible for walmart, it's appropriate perhaps that we are in memphis because there are a lot of these innovators that did important work in memphis. sam walton took a lot of ideas that other people had, and he made them work in the context of a lot of other people thought was crazy. when he was recruited in the 1960s or 1950s and 1960s he would again if i somebody by somebody who worked as an executive at ann discount chains a joy to come work for me? then they would go to the boss of whatever discount chainin to work for and said i'm going to go work with this walton guy and there was a fire, ruin your life turkeys crazy. he thinks that discount rate and is going to work in the of nowhere arkansas, et cetera. and then lo and behold every report, walmart is at the top of fortin 500 -- fortune 500 and have allowed people to save more lives better and what's the honda walmart has caused in your view? >> guest: on that there isn't any. everybody can tell he poor s

-[john] hey, waltons!d none of you need prizes to prove it. now, i know there's still a lot you want to do here, so let's just make sure we all meet back up for fireworks before heading home. clear? okay, go have some more fun! better get ready for that encore, jason. encore! [jason] it's gonna cost you more chores! congratulations. thanks. hope i didn't throw you off too much. managed. well, if you're ever in rock ridge county, look me up. jimmy donnelly. anyway, just wanted to say hi. hi. see ya. bye. well, what did i tell ya? erin, don't be a--one of those. well, i'm not! what did he say? did he tell you his name? i mean, i already forgot it. come on, you don't wanna miss the candied apples, do you? -i guess not. -i'll pay for it. -really? -no. i don't have any money! i'm broke 'cause of you! [red] win a prize! all there is to it. come on... [lively music] hey, you made it. now i'm gonna win that stuffed bunny. i should warn you, it's...harder than it looks. [john-boy] he's right, elizabeth, okay? i don

vice chair walton. supervisor safai >> thank you, thank you supervisor walton and all the people that came out i appreciate the comment on both sides. listen i understand that there is a lot of anxiety in the city now. we all had people touched by this personal low most likely. i personally had my own car and home had my daughter's soccer there is a lot of stuff going on in the city now. that has not happened always. we have to talk about that. and we have to talk about it in an honest way. but guess when. when you pick up the phone, you pick up phone call 911. see if you get someone on the phone in a mandated time? you most likely will not. they are literally working 14-16 hour shifts. i went over there a couple months ago i was horrified. i would not to work in those conscience but those people make sure our public safety net is working they are under paid and under appreciated and they are under staffed. go to the emergency room at general. see how quickly you see a nurse. you won't. you might sit in

>> aye. >> walton, aye. supervisor chan. >> aye. >> dorsey. >> no. >> enguardio. >> no. >> supervisor mandelman. >> no. >> aoups melgar. >> no. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> peskin, aye. preston aye. ronen, ronen aye, supervisor safai, aye. and supervisor stefani, no. 6 ayes and 5 nos with supervisor dorsey, en guardio mandel and stefani voting no. >> item 21 loll call. >> item 21, supervisor walton--mr. president, just for the record. >> this is continuance. >> to continue the item to sfmta to monday the 20th on that item, a roll call please. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> aoups chan. >> aye. >> chan, aoups dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor en guardio. >> aye. >> mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> peskin. >> aye. >> preston. >> preston, aye. >> ronen. >> ronen, aye. >> safai. >> aye. >> and supervisor stefani. >> 111 ayes. >> the motion is approved. let's go to roll call for instructions. -- intro dubsings. --intro dubsings. >> inintro ducktion. --in a valued and admired member pf san fran

seconded by supervisor walton. on that motion a roll call. >> on the minutes supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor supervisor peskin. >> aye. and supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> there are 10 aye's. >> the minutes will be approved as presented after public comment. could you read the consent agenda. >> items 1-8 are on consent and considered to be routine. if a member objects an item may be removed and considered separate low >> would a members like an item or items severed? a roll call. we will take that same house same call. the ordinances are passed on first reading. finally passed and resolutions adopted. >> next item. >> item 9 referred without recommendation from land use and transportation. an ordinance to amend the planning code to charge zone nothing castro street neighborhood commercial to exclude

vice chair walton.nt to thank my colleagues for comments on this legislation and to those this came to speak. thank you for your input. and especially debbie for the history lesson, 220 there was a report and i'm happy we are guesting around to impletting what was in this report that supervisor maxwell starred. i'm excite body this legislation and want to thank my chief of staff. and i'm looking forward to watching with the controller office does in developing the standards and when we do to monitor city dollars and make sure they are spent effectively. and to thank all the nonprofits we worked with and the nonprofit this is are out there doing sfuch great work i serve on the board in the city and watching what work can be done by people who are passionet about take care of others was amazing. thank you again. clothes and i look forward to your support and thank you sparz safai for joining. >> thank you. and i guess i would like to make a motion to send this to the full board with a positive recommendat

>> aye. >> walton, aye. supervisor chan. >> aye. >> dorsey. >> no. >> enguardio. >> no. >> supervisor mandelman. >> no. >> aoups melgar. >> no. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> peskin, aye. preston aye. ronen, ronen aye, supervisor safai, aye. and supervisor stefani, no. 6 ayes and 5 nos with supervisor dorsey, en guardio mandel and stefani voting no. >> item 21 loll call. >> item 21, supervisor walton--mr. president, just for the record. >> this is continuance. >> to continue the item to sfmta to monday the 20th on that item, a roll call please. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> aoups chan. >> aye. >> chan, aoups dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor en guardio. >> aye. >> mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> peskin. >> aye. >> preston. >> preston, aye. >> ronen. >> ronen, aye. >> safai. >> aye. >> and supervisor stefani. >> 111 ayes. >> the motion is approved. let's go to roll call for instructions. -- intro dubsings. --intro dubsings. >> inintro ducktion. --in a valued and admired member pf san fran

and that's the way it is with a family called the waltons. [theme music] [adult john-boy] during thanksgiving season in 1934, we had much to be grateful for on walton's mountain. while the yield on daddy's first corn crop was less than he hoped for, it was good enough to squeak by. farm work was challenging, but we were far better off than most folks. i had been a bit distracted, and at times, my mind would wander about thinking of stories i should be writing. and there were the two girls in my life. as thanksgiving approached, we were reminded that sharing what we had was just as important as giving thanks for what we received. and i learned what it really meant to take responsibility for my actions. [lively chatter] [olivia] mary ellen, help me in the kitchen. jim bob, eat it or lose it. -i'll eat it. -you heard her. -use a fork, jim bob. -what did i tell you? thanksgiving is right around the corner. have y'all thought about what you're grateful for? well, i'm grateful for the baldwins' odd jobs, that's for sure. helps tide us over 'til pla

walton. he is a constant communicator for his community and we are grateful for his leadership, advice and nudge to make us do better. and i will tell you he taught us one important thing. progress is in the measured by how tall our buildings are butt depth of our commitment to the community. thank you, supervisor. appreciate your support. and to our mayor. she has been an advocate. if she would not have pushed in ways like today that no one's done we would not be here and a generation of inference france fremantles would not have homes thank you to the mayor and the city staff to keep the project moving we would not be here without and you madam mayor this , housing you are helping help is a commitment to makes san francisco affordable for sxefrn that is awesome. thank you. now as we break ground. and start think burglar transforming the power pleasant we are not just building housing we are generating a new energy that symbolizes hope. resilience and optimism the important commitment we can

>> aye. >> walton, aye. supervisor chan. >> aye. >> dorsey. >> no. >> enguardio. >> no. >> supervisor mandelman. >> no. >> aoups melgar. >> no. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> peskin, aye. preston aye. ronen, ronen aye, supervisor safai, aye. and supervisor stefani, no. 6 ayes and 5 nos with supervisor dorsey, en guardio mandel and stefani voting no. >> item 21 loll call. >> item 21, supervisor walton--mr. president, just for the record. >> this is continuance. >> to continue the item to sfmta to monday the 20th on that item, a roll call please. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> aoups chan. >> aye. >> chan, aoups dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor en guardio. >> aye. >> mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> peskin. >> aye. >> preston. >> preston, aye. >> ronen. >> ronen, aye. >> safai. >> aye. >> and supervisor stefani. >> 111 ayes. >> the motion is approved. let's go to roll call for instructions. -- intro dubsings. --intro dubsings. >> inintro ducktion. --in a valued and admired member pf san fran

you were elected the mp for walton in the 2010 _ elected the mp for walton in the 2010 general election been an— 2010 general election. and you have been an mp ever since. you held a series— been an mp ever since. you held a series of— been an mp ever since. you held a series ofjunior ministerial roles between — series ofjunior ministerial roles between 2015 and 2018. is series ofjunior ministerial roles between 2015 and 2018.- between 2015 and 2018. is that ri . ht? between 2015 and 2018. is that right? correct. _ between 2015 and 2018. is that right? correct. it _ between 2015 and 2018. is that right? correct. it was - between 2015 and 2018. is that right? correct. it was in - between 2015 and 2018. is that right? correct. it was in july i between 2015 and 2018. is that | right? correct. it was in july 2018 ou were right? correct. it was in july 2018 you were appointed _ right? correct. it was in july 2018 you were appointed as _ right? correct. it was in july 2018 you were appointed as the - right? correct. it was in july 2018 i you were appointed as the secretary of state _ you were

supervisor walton. walton. present. mr. president, there is a quorum. thank you. colleagues. can we have a motion to excuse supervisors melgar and stephanie made by supervisor mandelman seconded by supervisor walton. and we will take that without objection. madam clerk, do we have any communications or announcements? yes mr. president. the board welcomes all interested in this meeting to attend in person here in the legislature chamber room 250 at city hall. the this meeting is airing live on tv's channel 26 or you may view the live stream at sf nsf.gov tv.org. our office did not receive a request for a language interpretation today, so we do not have interpreters here. but as a reminder, if you anticipate a future need for them, please call (415) 554-5184. at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting. mr. president, that concludes my communication on. thank you. the san francisco board of supervisors acknowledges we are on the unceded ancestral homeland of the ramaytush ohlone, who are the original inhabitants of the san francisco peninsula, as the indigenous stewards of this

i just i couldn't believe rihanna, walton, only new barnes for a brief period of her life. >> he wastoon leader. she tells fox 40 news the 2 were station together overseas about 10 years ago. lieutenant at the time barnes was walton's first income tie was overseas. >> i was away from my family. you know, i'm married and have kids. so it is difficult. so nice to have a leader. was supportive >> they're after graduating from jesuit and gonzaga university in washington. the pilot trained at a flight school at fort rucker, arkansas in 2013, walton says she met her platoon leader at camp casey in south korea. we're all in there need to be all and year he would be ready to go on a test flight. >> you know, and i just remember him saying there is gearing his big break smiling. he was just ready to go. walton says barnes was stern would necessary and always the first to lift her up. >> through some stress field training, he was the guy that look, if you're having a bad day, you could just make you feel better just being around him because he just he had a genuine heart. but above all else, w

walton, aye. chan, aye. there are 11i ayes. >> motion approved. please call consent agenda. >> items 1-17 are consent and considered to be retune. if a member objects a item may be removed and considered separately. >> seeing no names on the roster, take same house same call, the ordinances finally passed on first reading and resolutions adopted. next item, please. >> item 18 is third draft of charter amendment to amend the charter of city and county of san francisco to define full duty sworn offices to establish minimum staffing level for sworn officer of the police department. >> supervisor safai and so far you are the sponsor of this charter amendment, the one late charter amendment to be considered today, i will call on you first. >> thank you president peskin. thank you colleagues. there is a lot of consternation around this measure, not exactly clear why. there has been some misinformation promoted about this measure, and to be honest, i didn't think i would be standing here today as the sponsor of thi

walton, aye. chan, aye. there are 11i ayes. >> motion approved. please call consent agenda. >> items 1-17 are consent and considered to be retune. if a member objects a item may be removed and considered separately. >> seeing no names on the roster, take same house same call, the ordinances finally passed on first reading and resolutions adopted. next item, please. >> item 18 is third draft of charter amendment to amend the charter of city and county of san francisco to define full duty sworn offices to establish minimum staffing level for sworn officer of the police department. >> supervisor safai and so far you are the sponsor of this charter amendment, the one late charter amendment to be considered today, i will call on you first. >> thank you president peskin. thank you colleagues. there is a lot of consternation around this measure, not exactly clear why. there has been some misinformation promoted about this measure, and to be honest, i didn't think i would be standing here today as the sponsor of thi

. >> supervisor stefani present and supervisor walton present mr. president we have quorum. >> thank you, ma'am clerk >> thank you, ma'am clerk unceded ancestral homeland of the ramaytush (rah-my-toosh) ohlone (o-lon-ee) who are the original inhabitants of the san francisco peninsula. responsibilities as the caretakers of this place, as well as for all peoples who reside in their traditional territory. elders, and relatives of the ramaytush ohlone community and by affirming their sovereign rights as first peoples. please join me in the pledge of allegiance. >> i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> colleagues, can we have motion to excuse expirations supervisor melgar seconded by supervisor dorsey without objection (gavel) for those two supervisors are excused. amen. >> welcomes at interested in the meeting to attend in in-person in the room 250 this meeting is ar life on channel 26 or life stream you may also wat