. >> commissioner warshell. >> here. >> we have a quorum and vice president walker and walker are excused. the will all parties giving testimony today please stand and raise your hand right. do you swear that the testimony you're going to give is the truth to the best of your knowledge. thank you. you may be seated. okay. the next item is c, approval of minutes. discussion and possible action to adopt the minutes for november 16, 2016. is there a motion to approve? >> move to approve. >> is there a second? >> second. >> okay. is there public comment on this item? okay. seeing none are all commissioners in favor? >> aye. >> any opposed? okay. the minutes are approved and for the record commissioner lee is present as well. okay. we are on to item d continued appeals or abatement. case on bush street owner of record bush street apartment street 100 street san francisco california. applicant and action requested by appellant and says it doesn't exist in code and seeks modification or reversal of abatement and this is for information everyone present, the department has seven minutes to presen