help us find a way to provide relief and specifically i want to thank director patrick reardon at wbai as well as christine gasper tate, hannah patrick hannon and matthew green on in his department liz waddy and erin starr from planning austin yang, rob coppola, kristen jensen and peter million from the city attorney's office and calvin from my office. and lastly colleagues i am asking that we adjourn today's memory today's meeting in memory of joe chavez who died on february 1st at the age of 89. joe was born in redlands, california in 1935. at 18 he joined the navy after tours in japan and the philippines. he was stationed at treasure island, which is when his love of san francisco began. joe later moved to san francisco after leaving the navy and put down roots in the castro. he was a founding partner of castro village wine company, a small boutique wine shop in the in the heart of the castro neighborhood. established in 1980 cv iwc specialized in the sale of fine californian wines. joe and his partner boyd swartz envisioned the store as more than just a business. they wanted to cre