in relation to whosequestion. for the last 30 minutes, i listen to most of you and it's very hard for me to determine what was going on here. whether someone was answering the question, asking a question or just making gossip to one another based on some of the statistics that were read. it's very difficult to follow. this is a public forum, a public format. you're not here to talk to one another based on some relative means but to talk to the public and let them know exactly what you're doing. i'm a member of the public and i could not understand what you were doing. and i'm sitting in the front row. it's not clear also whether if you don't have the transcriber or the encryption whether this is being recorded properly, and for the notes that are taken on regular meetings, whether those are transcripts or basically audited versions of what was stated by various members of the public, it's not clear to me that what is taking place here. you have actual audios of speeches and statements, but when you read the minute