joseph bradley had been appointed by republican samuel freeman miller, republican william strong republicanford, democrat stephen johnson. field, another democratic appointee. let's go back to david davis. what was his story. david davis is fascinating. so as you said, david davis is from illinois. he had been a very close confidant and friend of abraham lincoln. he had been appointed by lincoln to the court. davis was, as you said, widely viewed as an independent in the 19th century, independent, i mean, genuinely independent, free of either political party. most assumed because of his reputation as an independent, that the four justices congress appointed who then got to choose the fifth justice, the 15th member of the committee that they would choose davis and the popular belief was that davis probably favored tilden, though nobody knew for certain. but what ends up happening is that at the last minute, literally, as congress is going to vote on this bill, that will create commission, illinois davis's home state, the state legislature here in illinois, decides to select davis as their ne