i'd like to take roll commissioner president wu commissioner fong commissioner antonini commissioner richards we do expect commissioner hillis and commissioner johnson momentary commissioner first on our agenda is proposed items for continuance item one at 1814 through 16 ann district attorney request for conditional use authorization and item 2 at 2312 market street request for conditional use authorization until november 13th he have no other items proposed for continuance and no speaker cards. >> okay any public comment on this item? for items proposed for continuance? seeing none, public comment is closed commissioner fong >> move to continue. >> second. >> on that motion to continue commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner richards i can only vote on the tennessee i actually the market street one i'm living within 5 hundred feet i'll not be vociferating or participating that. >> in this case can we change the motion to - >> move to continue item 1. >> second. >> thank you commissioner antonini on that motion to continue item one. >> commissioner antonini commissio

commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved,, that motion passes unanimously 5 to zero and places you under our consent calendar to be routine and may be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the commission. there will be no separate discussion of these items a member of the commission, the public, or staff so requests in which event the matter shall be removed from the consent calendar and considered as a separate item at this or a future hearing. item 2 case no. 20141.09-c to the 577 castro street request for conditional use authorization and item 3 at 1245 alabama street request for conditional use authorization i have no speaker cards is there any public comment on the consent calendar seeing none, public comment is closed. >> commissioner fong move to approve items two and three. >> second. >> second. >> commissioner johnson i have a quick question can we pull that off of consent calendar i have a question. >> then once in a while we'll take it off cds and hear it at the regular calendar. >> yes. >> okay then the motion.

unfortunately, i'm battling a little bit of a cold i apologize for coughing commissioner president wu commissioner fong commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner hillis first on your agenda is for continuance this is the first case at 815 on 1010 is proposed until october 16, 2014, item two at 1912, 20th street request for discretionary review for december 4th and further on our agenda calendar under your discretionary review calendar at 16 through 18 iris after a announced discretionary review is proposed until december 11, 2014, to accommodate an individual dr that was filed recently i voluntary no other items proposed for continuance. >> any public comment on items proposed for continuance? seeing none, any public comment on that item? public comment is closed. >> commissioner antonini move to continue the items one and two to the date specified and item 13 to december 11th. >> do i hear a second. >> second. >> on that motion to continue commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner johnck's commissioner fong and commissioner president wu

unfortunately, i'm battling a little bit of a cold i apologize for coughing commissioner president wu commissioner fong commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner hillis first on your agenda is for continuance this is the first case at 815 on 1010 is

commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong no commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes that planning commission motion passes 5 to one with commissioner fong voting against expirations that places you on general public comment i have no speaker cards is there any general public comment? >> you may. >> when we were planning after all there were 8 houses we live in two house near the area all the houses are the same it has a living room and diagram not a bedroom and the reason i know hal la i handled her real estate and she's had the back unit where it says all utilities will be paid by her, she knew you it was adjacent to her unit before all of this started we actually called liz to the planning department i have a voice recording that told us what to do we went into down to the planning department they said we need the report fixed the inspector looked at the property and investigated if better than to get the building cards from 891 to 1950 it states it's an adjunct space the tenant was aware when we approached her in january

. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and commissioner fong and commissioners my name is missouri i didn't protective aid to supervisor cohen a quick if i notes this is a mail congressman's to the alcoholic district that is small business friendly the alcoholic process was passed because of a high density of the liquor establishment we have related crimes since some of the will challenges still exist by we've been macro significant headway working with sfpd and others and as we make headway we're going to be smart about the ordinances we create or all the time this opportunity came by the way of a brewery we've had the pleasure to work with in the past few months and received letters of support from a number of community organizations including the bright group, the india based on organization and the 32 neighborhood and the bayview hill and bayview merchants association this is just a small change again to the third street district that is business friendly and a job creator and brings the kinds of change we want to see in the third street corridor thank you. >> thank you. >> i'v

commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson no commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 4 to 2 with commissioner johnson and commissioner fong voting take a 15 minute break. >> good morning welcome to the for planning commission regular hearing october 23, 2014, i'd like to remembered members that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind devices. and and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. i'll have to ask those of you standing please find a seat please thank you very much commissioners we left off on item 11 for 436 central after a conditional use authorization. >> commissioner hillis i need to ask for a are you custodial i live on the same block. >> move to recuse commissioner hillis. >> on that motion commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu thank you, commissioners you are here by recused. >> good afternoon mary radius woods of departmental staff this is for a prior

commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you under your consent calendar to be routine and may be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the commission. there will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of the commission, the public, or staff so requests removed from the consent calendar and considered as a separate item at this or a future hearing. you only have one item case no. two at 1098 jackson street quebec they adapted a motion to continue the matter until october 2nd are there any members of the public who wish to speak on the consent calendar seeing none, public comment is closed. oh. >> do i want to comment on this. >> i'm asking that the commission yeah. i - >> this is new. >> so we'll have to pull it off of content. >> okay. thank you. >> so commissioner this is pulled off of commensurate and heard at the beginning of chartered. >> commissioners we are again moving commission matters and department matters until the

. >> sxhvg commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you on general public comment and i do believe we have two speaker cards. >> yes. >> again i am macintosh i live at the martin luther king in the paermentd here in san francisco i want i told you open the september 4th yes. the reason we were dealing with the discrimination lawsuit the disabled act in that action certain spipgz by the john stuart company to fellow such things related to this statement consequences of breach section 2, 3, 434 the respondents understand that failure to carry out the terms may result in suspension of termination of or refusal to grant or continue fell financial assistance or other actions tlosz by lieu they should be indicted on charges for fraud, conspiracy and i suspect shoddy work article 7 as part of the election portion for which all deals with the parties with their duties position whether their board members or not they have not carried it auto and olsen lee is another on

commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 9 a and b for 181 fremont street request for a approval of the downtown authorization. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and members of the commission i'm kevin guy before i get into my a staff report i want to introduce my colleague from supervisor kim's offers who wants to say a few words. >> good afternoon. i'm april with supervisor kim's office located others one 81 fremont is located in our district 6 the supervisor has co-sponsored with the mayor that's before you we ask firing support on the development all the time as well as the downtown authorization amendment the supervisor prefers on site affordability but this case and circumstance the developer has agreed to contribute supra funds and there have a prediction of more housing moving us forward with the housing and this mayor's office of housing is here to speak about the hoa and how that was a consideration as well in terms o

commissioner johnck commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards is commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. >> yeah, the commission will you'll remember the program is pilot into the small cap between 25 and 50 thousand square feet and there with he have available for the square feet we'll take everything out the the pipeline we still have over one mill square feet no longer than 50 thousand square feet gunning again as you can see we have 2 hundred 1 million square feet in the cap today, if i took out the preponderance of the evidence projects and essentially all the project with form application we're going looking at the a deficit of 7.9 million square feet before we go into the promotions one caveat those are bans the information we have today and the universal truth about the development in san francisco is that they're all subject to change over time and so want to make that clear that is bans our information today also the project are listed by quarter not necessarily in exact order of approval we can't know which pro

commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu snoement unanimously 7 to zero. >> the commission will take a bre >> that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind please silence all electronic devices. during those procedures if you don't know anyhow to how to silence them turn them off case 20148 d at 333 pennsylvania avenue request for conditional use authorization. >> a new planner joined the department in december of 2012 in the southeast quadrant a bachelor's from cal poly i didn't and international planning experience working with planning affirms and is has interest in sustainable systems and relocated here from hawaii welcome to the commission and. >> welcome. >> thank you, john for the intro good afternoon jeff spears department staff the item before you is a request for conditional use on pennsylvania after the proposed project to construct a new four story two family dwelling it has the height of 40 feet a set back and rear sent even if approximately 33 feet and overall building depth of 49 feet during th

commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu snoemdz unanimously 6 to zero and places you on. >> close the public comment grant the variance with the reasons previous stated. >> thank you zoning administrator and that will place us on item 14 at 2809 on polk this is is a kwe6 an abbreviated one. >> i'm carli planning staff the item before you is a request for discretionary review for building permit at 2809 through 11 possible street in a 40 x heightened district it includes a one story height and deck and 4 foot decrease on an existing 4 story this and has a configuration including an additional of an elevator the person who royals subject adjacent to the public filed a discretionary review mr. the gentleman states he is concerned that increasing the building area will be out of character and the 3 story will block whatever light that is enjoyed by the residents the project sponsor says the dr requesters property is blocking its own air and it is respectful the neighbors to date the department has one letter of support and one

. >> commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu snoemdz unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 10 planning code related to the consolidations reorganize article two and make changes to simplify code changes that is a planning code amendment. >> good afternoon aaron starr acting manager this is an ordnance that easements the planning code to reorganize article two for rezoning tables to update and clarify and simplify it's code language i presented this effort to the commission on june 30th, 2013, at a public hearing in an effort to introduce the concept to the planning commission as well as the public to get feedback on the process on july 24th of this year the commission voted inform uphold it they have two outreach meetings and internally by two planner and since staff initiation staff has made modifications from the feedback it is in our packet an exhibit g we are asking you recommend approval with the modifications to the board of supervisors idea to reorganize article 2 has been around since 1980s when seven and eight we

commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you on item 10. >> for case 17 m and e the urban forest master plan the presentation and initiation hearing. >> dpmg commissioner commissioner i'm governor jerry brown with the planning staff i'm also the manager of the san francisco urban forest master plan joined by a colleague carla from the department of public works she's the departments urban forester and will be making remarks during this presentation. >> so eager to give you a quick he overview on san francisco urban forest and talk about the plan in details and at the end of the presentation we'll be requesting the commission to take requesting action san francisco uttering we have 7 thousand trees trees managed in the jurisdiction of the 71 one hundred and 5 thousand street trees and one hundred thousand trees in our state parks those trees provide a wide range of benefits there are a tremendous you urban infrastructure there's no other capital in t

arrest commissioner johnson commissioner moore no commissioner richards no arrest commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 4 to 3 with commissioner johnck commissioner moore and other commissioner against that is the pine street mixed use for the final environmental impact report the draft public comment is closed the draft eir end on june 30th, 2014, and public comment will be received when this item is called, however, the comments may not be put in the final eir. >> good afternoon, everyone. with tplanning staff that is a financial environmental impact report or eir for the proposed 1527 to pine project case which entails domination of 5 xoifts buildings on the south side even if pine between van ness on the west and austin to the south and a construction of one hundred and 37 square feet at all story building with retailer space soon the ground floor and one hundred 37 housing in the upper levels a copy of the eir draft is in front of the commission and published on may 14th and the public hearing was held and the public comment closed comments and responds

commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 15 at 3826 to 28 caesar chavez discretionary review. >> good evening planning commission david washington the south west team leader the subject proposals an sharlz street to reduce two illegal units on he caesar chavez street between delores and church property is 25 street flowage and one hundred and 14 feet deep with a two-story victorian that contains two stories in 1990 with one thousand 4 hundred and 37 square feet the detached cottage is between three and four hundred square feet the property owner died and the two legal flats are vacant and it is - the tenant is residing on the property since 2345067 paying over $1,400 per month it appears it is in existence for a few decades that is confirmed by a planning department the tenant called dbi and the planning department approved the permit and ms. miller appealed the permit and it was substantially suspended the board permit hearing it was cu

commissioner johnck commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards is commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. >> yeah, the commission will

commissioner antonini commissioner johnck commissioner johnson commissioner richards commissioner fong and commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to take a 10 minute break. >> back to the spags regular hearing for october 16, 2014, i'd like to remind members of the audience that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind please, please, please signs our electronics and and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. those of you standing near the doorway clear the area move to the other side of the room folks those of you standing excuse me. gentlemen those of you standing next to the doorway clear the area commissioners we left off under our discretionary review calendar for the cases d and v ottawa street discretionary review and request for variances. >> commissioners my name is sarah of the department staff the item before you is a mandatory discretionary review for a demolition of a unit inform coal valley the project sponsor was granted a permit and the building was demolished the building is now parking lot

central portion by one foot and raise the windows to 36 inches commissioner wu and commissioner moore and commissioner hillis and commissioner fong voted no and commissioner moore's and commissioner johnck and commissioner fong said they didn't support the project so you had 6 commissioners who want this project changed the plans before the commission were the same envelope plans before you tonight so there will be no further misunderstanding the coordinators were produced in a certified transcript of the hearing the copy were sealed in an envelope with the original signatures should you decide to accept it i have a number of copies with highlights that i'm going to read from until i run out of time do you have a copy for the planning department? well, the document is new the words is in the part of the administrative record and available o'ly want to emphasize from the transcript no doubt at least 6 commissioners wanted this envelope us reduced the envelope before you what's most unusual about the case not a 33 tie all 6 wanted dr that's a difference between what kind of changes they wanted they couldn't make up their mind and t