. >> let's bring in, if we could, jay yarrow from "business insider." are you with us? >> give us your take on this. do you believe this decision has been made pre-ipo? >> i have no reason not to believe it. i don't think you come out and lie about something like that. if you get discovered you're lying it's terrible for you and the company so i would hope he's telling the truth in this case. >> i think both can be true. i think he could have planned it but it could have been accelerated, the decision could have been accelerated. that's all. >> jay, what do you think this means to the company, what does it mean in terms of -- what does it mean, if the decision was made in may, pre-ipo, therefore if that is true does it say anything about his view about the future prospects of the company in. >> he made an investment in 2004. what was he going to do, hold onto these forever? would you prefer he waited until the stock was at 60 and jumped? this is the problem being a public company and having been an investor early on. it's always going to look kind of bad no matter when