yazdizadeh. mr.ali akbar says that most of their discussion is actually about the country's social security system. doing this, which is one of the weaknesses of our administrative system , is the separation of the support system from the income system . this is not the case in the world, that is, in the world, if they want to support someone. in general, the name of the tax return in developed countries is tax return, which means taxing you under different headings throughout the year, including value added tax that is charged on the consumption of goods. this all comes from there . pension also goes directly into the government budget , that is, it is not a fund. why? they got here because they realized that in the system of pension funds, they all have a deficit. the government should act like in our own country what are they doing with these two protection and tax systems together ? do you pay taxes? sir, i had so much income , so many medical expenses, so many issues, so many belongings , this i

yazdizadeh, mr. ali akbari, that we are facing a problem called the lack of proper support for our artists , it is not hidden from anyone, that is, it is a fact , my most important reason is, as you said, that this is not a permanent job, it is a temporary job. it's not even seasonal, because sometimes after a certain age, or even related to my age. one person is promoted in a course, then he leaves again and has to eat the stick of being promoted in this course forever because he can't go anywhere else to work. it has a special nature , it requires this guild and a special support system, and how good it is that therefore, according to the current situation , let's make a model because it is applicable, this model is a support model, but i want to say this to you , you are talking about something that does not solve your problem. it makes things worse for the artist 's guild . there is income so that my taxes will be paid now, sir we pay, we have a problem. the argument you are saying is that this t

yazdizadeh, an economic expert , is present as an opponent of tax exemption for artists, as well as mr. ali akbari, a producer and director of cinema. the title agrees with the topic we are discussing, but before praying. let's start. if you agree, there is a report . let's see together the opinions of the candidates for the parliamentary elections . let's go back. hosseini, a university professor and cultural researcher. in germany, the publisher's tax is about half of the rest of the guilds or book postage in all of germany. freelancer mohammad mahdi esmaili, minister of culture and islamic guidance , we are in favor of tax justice for everyone in any job there is no difference between an artist and a non-artist. there is no difference between an artist and a non-artist . what is wrong with an artist whose work situation is prosperous? what is wrong with paying taxes? it is the right of the people and the government to tax him. we also agree with this issue, jamal sadatian. the producer of the cinema should not only cinema. he should pay taxes, but he should also get incentives. cine

yazdizadeh's point is that we check the percentage of you that we want to have 50 people in that system. it must be correct. the administrative system that i mentioned, inshallah, omid god , but sir, i mean you, if they are accountable to you, they will be able to multiply the figure that it costs, for reviewing 90,000 cases, with what they want to tax from these 20 people. no, it means how many digits are there. according to that, there is a tax, the cost may be like this . i said, look, i have to fix my administrative system . you put in the expert organization. article 16 goes once, once again, and renews once. article 251 is very long, for how much later, for example , this tax 5 a million tomanes for 5 million toman is going to 5 commissions, each of these commissions has a salary, they get money, they have water. if you separate it, it means that the system will work no matter how much you want it to work, that's why in developed countries, for every one million people, there are 1,000 people , they have a tax staff, that means we should have 80,000 people , we have 32,000 people.

yazdizadeh, let me start with the question of where your opposition to artists' tax exemption comes from. in the name of god, see, taxes in the world are responsible for a series of tasks, that is, they are levied for a series of tasks, one is to provide government revenue. the side of justice is social justice. thirdly, i would like to invite you to direct funds to some of the areas that are of most interest. the general policy of the tax government with the tools that are designed in it , including lower rates, not what is in our country under the title of exemption in an advanced tax system, you do not have any exemptions. you can have zero for the short term, but in fact, with the existing tools, it must follow these goals, and any tax discount you want to give must be justified. if you are looking for justice , are you looking to direct funds to one sector or not? if not , there is no question of exemption. one of the problems that exists in our country is actually tax exemption, not my zero rate with exemption. or to an account with a tax discount to support a special activity that

yazdizadeh, an economic expert , is present here and in the higher program studio as an opponent of tax exemption for artists, as well as mr. ali akbari, a film producer and director , as a supporter of the issue we are discussing, but before we start the debate. if you agree , let's see a report together about the opinions of the candidates for the parliamentary elections let's go back. hosseini, university professor and cultural researcher. naturally , there are incomes in various fields, both commercial and industrial, as well as cultural and artistic fields, that must be taxed. for example, in germany, publishers' tax is almost half of the other guilds, or the postage of books is free in all of germany. mohammad mehdi esmaili, minister of culture and islamic guidance. we are in favor of tax justice. everyone had substantial income in any job. he must pay the tax. there is no difference between an artist and a non-artist. what is wrong with an artist whose work is prosperous to pay taxes? this is the right of the people it is the government to tax him. we also agree with this. jamal

yazdizadeh's point is about that one percent that you say has a good income, i don't have a problem with that 1 percent, but i say, what about us? we will pay for it , we will check a percentage of 90,000 people, in which we want 50 people in that system, the administrative system that i mentioned should be fixed, god willing , but mr. i will tell you if you sit down he should be able to multiply the figure that it costs to review these 90,000 cases with what he wants to tax these 20 people . it is not compatible with what he wants to tax from these 20 people. it means that this figure is several times that tax and he is spending money. it could be like this , i said. you see, i have to fix my administrative system . you put it in an expert organization. article 16 goes once, it goes again for renewal once. that article 25 is very long. for how long , for example, this tax is 5 million tomans. for 5 million tomans, there are 5 commissions. these commissions go. everyone has a right to take this place they have houses, they have water and electricity , let's calculate the cost, 10 times t