those two countries leaders now during a white house meeting with the nato secretary general young stoltenberg the president repeated his sharp criticism of germany for not paying enough words own defense he singled out germany for benefiting from nato while to same time paying russia billions for energy supplies let's take a listen yemen a must demonstrate leadership in the alliance by addressing its longstanding shortfall in defense contributions germany has not contributed what it should be contributing and it's a very big beneficiary far bigger than the united states frankly in addition to that as you know that by massive amounts of gas from russia. paying billions and billions of dollars. ok let's go now for more to sochi on this president's comments coming just as the german chancellor and the russian president meet their insults you for talks so to focus on bilateral issues including iran's nuclear deal we're bringing in emily sure one from one this morning emily the u.s. president they're attacking germany for economic ties to russia how strong is that bilateral relationship right now