youtube says since this has come to light, it has taken action to remove the comments. our media editor reports. reporter: youtube has reinvented the very idea of broadcasting, allowing anyone with access to the internet to create their own channel and build a following. the site has a billion users and pulls in 4 billion pounds in ad revenue every year. users have to be 13 before they can upload and share videos. but millions of teenagers use the opportunity to share in her inner thoughts with the world, and just to have fun. that is why and where sexual predators often stalk them online. these comments found by the bbc are a fraction of the total material on youtube, but they show how digital platforms have emboldened some would-be offenders. new research by the bbc's social-media investigations unit has discovered that for close to a year, something went wrong for the system for removing obscene comments. >> i'm really, really concerned that the public function of reporting isn't working. it is something i will be writing to youtube about straightaway, and i will wan

there doesn't seem to be any outrage. >> when asked youtube about his account, all of williams' youtubeideos were turned down, because of hate speech. williams had 90,000 subscribers, sometimes posting 20 times adark, until they took him down, monologues pep perred with gross falsehoods. >> this is breaking news that nobody has this story but your doctor. they said this particular man that donald trump has implemented on the muslim affects your former president barack hussein obama. it appears that some left wing cook, it was actually rand paul's they he decided to put one of those football tackles on rand paul. i betcha his neighbor is a bernie sanders or hillary supporter. >> the "new york times" business and tech columnist who wrote the piece on the rapid response partisans joins me now. it's a fascinating piece. there is a bunch of things happening here. let's talk about something uploading to youtube is fine, the most important part is what happened in souther land sprngs you get this? >> i think five or six of the first ten videos that showed up were these conspiratorial shock joc

and adidas, said they do not want anything to do with youtube when it isa anything to do with youtubehiles. another one, as in the report that, bbc trending finding their mechanism, the system by which you can flag that something is wrong, that is not working as it was meant to for a year or so which means that some things that were meant to be taken down simply were not. and the parent company is doing what about a ? not. and the parent company is doing what about a? we have been speaking to senior people in the world of advertising and they say google has taken this seriously, they find this abhorrent and in the last few months have acted to try to take this stuff down. they have disabled accounts which should not be there, taken thousands of comments which should not be online down as well and hired human moderators to prejudge whether certain things should be online. but a key point here is the sheer volume of material online, 400 hours of video uploaded every minute, this will be solved by machines rather than human beings and i‘m afraid this is a war without end. amol rajan, tha

youtube says since this came to light it has taken action to remove the comments.be has reinvented the very idea of broadcasting, allowing anyone with access to the internet to create their own channel and build a following. the site now has a billion users and pulls in around £4 billion in ad revenues every year. users have to be 13 before they can upload and share videos, but millions of teenagers use the opportunity to share their inner thoughts with the world, or just to have fun. that is why and where sexual predators often stalk them online. these comments found by the bbc are a fraction of the total material on youtube but they show how the digital platforms have emboldened some would—be offenders. new research by bbc trending, the bbc social media investigations unit, has discovered that for close to a year something went wrong with the system for removing obscene comments. i am really, really concerned that the public function reporting isn't seemingly working. it's something i will be writing to youtube about straightaway and i will want them to take imme

the right-wing shock jocks who infiltrate youtube and social media next.her nature sure smells amazing. even in accounts receivable. new gain botanicals laundry detergent, bring the smell of nature wherever you are. do you want the same tools and seamless experience across web and tablet? yes? great! then you're ready for power e*trade. the platform, price and service that gives you the edge you need. sweet! e*trade. the original place to invest online. they always refer to me as master sergeant. they really appreciate the military family, and it really shows. we've got auto insurance, homeowners insurance. had an accident with a vehicle, i actually called usaa before we called the police. usaa was there hands-on very quick very prompt. i feel like we're being handled as people that actually have a genuine need. we're the webber family and we are usaa members for life. usaa, get your insurance quote today. >>> within hours of the mass shooting in sutherland springs, on sunday, if you were to search youtube for information about that massacre, you may have

youtube says since this came to light it has taken action to remove the comments.nvented the very idea of broadcasting, allowing anyone with access to the internet to create their own channel and build a following. the site now has a billion users and pulls in around £a billion in ad revenues every year. users have to be 13 before they can upload and share videos, but millions of teenagers use the opportunity to share their inner thoughts with the world, and just to have fun. that is why and where sexual predators often stalk them online. these comments found by the bbc are a fraction of the total material on youtube but they do show how digital platforms have emboldened some would—be offenders. technology, social media, it's a new frontier. what it does bring is anonymity. so what maybe you wouldn't do, or you might not be bold enough to do because it's attached to your name, your face, your character, there's a lot to lose, potentially, you might be more keen or willing to do it if you think you'll never be caught. new research by bbc trending, the bbc social med

and the sheer volum — of content on youtube, —— and the sheer volume of content on youtube, with 400tely, this is an issue that would be managed not by human beings, but by machines. digital giants like google are adamant that social problems in the internet age have technological rather than regulatory solutions. but the prevalence of sexual predators online is an issue that will never be fully eradicated because the anarchic freedom of the internet will always afford them a home somewhere in cyberspace. to fight them is to enter a war without end. amol rajan, bbc news. black friday has been and gone but this year, it seems that most of the bargains have been snapped up online. it's thought that british shoppers alone have spent more than 2.5 billion pounds injust one day, but not all retailers are happy. emma simpson reports from eastern england. everywhere you look today, a blizzard of deals, from the high street right to your inbox. black friday in full swing. it's first light and we've come out to see who's shopping. forget the stores — we're on the train, because it's all about

and coming up next on the cbs evening news, youtube finds removing offensive videos is not easy. and later, the royal wed ago good news today for the father of the bride. symptoms fast own cold with maximum strength alka seltzer plus liquid gels. so we know how to cover almost we've anything.st everything even a "red-hot mascot." [mascot] hey-oooo! whoop, whoop! [crowd 1] hey, you're on fire! [mascot] you bet i am! [crowd 2] dude, you're on fire! [mascot] oh, yeah! [crowd 3] no, you're on fire! look behind you. [mascot] i'm cool. i'm cool. [burke] that's one way to fire up the crowd. but we covered it. talk to farmers. we know a thing or two because we've seen a thing or two. ♪ we are farmers. bum-pa-dum, bum-bum-bum-bum ♪ i kept looking for ways to manage my symptoms. i thought i was doing okay. then it hit me... managing was all i was doing. when i told my doctor, i learned humira is for people who still have symptoms of moderate to severe crohn's disease even after trying other medications. in clinical studies, the majority of people on humira saw significant symptom relief an

youtube have said to us, "we have clear policy against videos and comment on youtube which sexualisednd technical resources." can they do any more than that? absolutely. toughened, do more, we are talking about children. what we need is transparency. we agree that it is scary and if there are predatory people who are able to contact and the comments on children's videos, that is obviously a very worrying situation to be in but when you have the volume of videos that go on to youtube every second, watmore practically needs to be done? that's not an answer, just saying it is a big data problem, that's not acceptable. we have a lot of cancer but we don't throw our hand in the air and sayjust because there is too much we can't do anything. we need transparency around their human moderation system, around their corporate guidelines and most importantly we need transparency around the algorithmic infrastructure that pulls these things together. and we need experts looking at them and giving expert opinion outside of these corporations. isn't it also down to the government to make them take

the fact he is being paid or was until youtube shut down his account. think that's the difference than what we see on facebook and twitter, in those cases, some of the misinformation specialists are having to pay to place ads to get their message out there. in the case of youtube, they're getting paid to do this. >> the similarity is this question of are you a printing press or newspaper? if are you a printing press, someone says, make a thousand of these flyers, you make them, you don't look at the content at all. if you are a number, you say is this true? all the of the platforms, youtube, facebook, twitter are caught in an uncomfortable place between the two. >> they are like printing presses in a way, they're platforms where anyone can upload anything. i think that's good. they've also taken on the responsibility of showing curated algorythmicly sorted front pages to people. that's what brings in the editorial judgment that they have, thus far, not been able take on? >> it's a stamp of approval, if you partner with them that shows up in some way, th

youtube has insisted that it acts quickly on any reports of inappropriate material. reports. youtube has reinvented the very idea of broadcasting, allowing anyone with access to the internet to create their own channel and build a following. the site now has a billion users and pulls in around £4 billion in ad revenues every year. users have to be 13 before they can upload and share videos but millions of teenagers use the opportunity to share their inner thoughts with the world and just to have fun. that is why and where sexual predators often stalk them online. these comments found by the bbc are a fraction of the total material on youtube, but they do show how digital platforms have emboldened some would—be offenders. new research by bbc trending, the bbc social media investigations unit, has discovered that for close to a year something went wrong with the system for removing obscene comments. i am really, really concerned that the public function of reporting isn't seemingly working. it's something i will be writing to youtube about straight away and i will want

. >>> coming up next, youtube finds removing offensive videos is not easy. and later, the royal wedding, good news today, for the father of the bride. i love you, couch. you give us comfort. and we give you bare feet, backsweat, and gordo's... everything. i love you, but sometimes you stink. soft surfaces trap odors. febreze fabric refresher cleans them away for good. because the things you love the most can stink. and plug in febreze to keep your whole room fresh for up to 45 days. breathe happy with febreze. it says you apply the blue one ok, letto me. this. here? no. have a little fun together, or a lot. k-y yours and mine. two sensations that work together, so you can play together. that cough doesn't sound so good. take mucinex dm. i'll text you in 4 hours when your cough returns. one pill lasts 12 hours, so... looks like i'm good all night! why take 4-hour cough medicine? just one mucinex lasts 12 hours. let's end this. casual fridays at buckingham palace? alright, off you go. surprising. what's not surprising? how much money nathan saved by switching

major companies have suspended their advertising on youtube after it emerged the company had not beene company says that it has since taken to remove the comments. 0ur media editor reports. youtube has reinvented the very idea of broadcasting, allowing anyone with access to the internet to create their own channel and build a following. the site now has a billion users and pulls in around £4 billion in ad revenues every year. users have to be 13 before they can upload and share videos, but millions of teenagers use the opportunity to share their inner thoughts with the world, and just to have fun. that is why and where sexual predators often stalk them online. these comments found by the bbc are a fraction of the total material on youtube but they do show how digital platforms have emboldened some would—be offenders. technology, social media, it's a new frontier. what it does bring is anonymity. so what maybe you wouldn't do, or you might not be bold enough -- i will —— i will want them to take immediate action. several leading brands have now said they will suspend their advertising

. >>> youtube is finally cracking down on disturbing videos on its website.on was based on the bottom line. >> reporter: under pressure from advertisers youtube owned by google removed more than 50,000 videos of images of children apparently being assaulted. >> at the end of the day, large tech companies are run by the bottom line, and i think youtube has been an incredibly platform for google and they simply have not paid enough attention to some of the bad stuff on that platform. >> reporter: advertisers pulled their ads. youtube said we're implementing age gates for videos geared toward mature audiences and making 2 million videos ineligible for ads. >> it's a new type of child abuse. child sexual abuse exploitation. >> children can't unsee something. once they look at an image, it is there in their brains forever. >> reporter: the problem on youtube is with some 300 hours of video uploaded to the site every minute, identifying offensive material is a constant challenge. youtube is largely dependent on computer os whan image is appropriate. >> do you have

now, we've had conversations with youtube, and youtube are taking some action, but what we want themients‘ lives rather than something more dangerous. what does your mum think of all of this? shall we call her and ask her? well, we can do, yeah! phone rings. hello? i'm with the bbc. they want to ask you some questions. 0k. are you free to talk? i wanted to ask, what do you think of the crazy life he leads? oh, the guy has worked hard. i am ever so proud of him. it must be quite scary knowing that he's driving to some dangerous places sometimes? of course, of course, i'm always scared. i'm his mother, i have to be. doesn't i? you know, he's alone out there, and you never know what's around the corner. you're worried about him even if sometimes he isn't? he knows what he does. you know, he knows the people he's seeing. he feels quite safe, really. he's always telling me there's nothing to worry about. and do you ever watch any of his videos? of course i do. i comment on all of them. if i could tell the queen about pacman tv, i will, because he's done so much. he's taken so many kids of

. >>> coming up next, youtube finds removing offensive videos is not easy. and later, the royal wedding, good news today, for the father of the bride. it says you apply the blue one ok, letto me. this. here? no. have a little fun together, or a lot. k-y yours and mine. two sensations that work together, so you can play together. thanks for the ride-along, captain! i've never been in one of these before, even though geico has been- ohhh. ooh ohh here we go, here we go. you got cut off there, what were you saying? oooo. oh no no. maybe that geico has been proudly serving the military for over 75 years? is that what you wanted to say? mhmmm. i have to say, you seemed a lot chattier on tv. geico. proudly serving the military for over 75 years. you ok back there, buddy? that cough doesn't sound so good. take mucinex dm. i'll text you in 4 hours when your cough returns. one pill lasts 12 hours, so... looks like i'm good all night! why take 4-hour cough medicine? just one mucinex lasts 12 hours. let's end this. she's had a tiny cough. see you at 5! seriously? prote

glad you are here with us either on-site or online on youtube. before we begin i would like to give you some instructions on how to participate. for those of you have joined us on-site, welcome. we will take your questions. we ask that you hold on to them until the very end of their presentation. if you can, please use the microphones so we can capture your voice online. for those of you watching online, you too can ask questions. log into the chat feature of this youtube channel and type your questions in. i will then ask the presenters your questions at the end of your sessions. you will find two hotlinks. one will take you to presentation the other to live captioning. today's program is entitled "world war ii and the first motion picture films with preservationists. they perform preservation work on motion pictures and records held at the national archives. before joining the lab in 2006, audrey worked with the film collection. heidi completed her education at western washington university, earning a masters in history with a certificate in ar

now, if you are like me, you are a fan of youtube. everybody uses youtube. your own videos, also brings people together. helps form very unique online communities, gamers, film makers, musicians. there are also several of these communities that are a little more niche. and we thought we would take a look at some of these smaller communities in a segment we call "youtube sub communities." [ cheers and applause ] >> seth: first up, some of you may have seen videos on youtube where kids on skateboards will grab on to passing buses and hitch a ride down the street. they're called "bus skitching" videos. but this next youtube sub community features skateboarders hitching a ride, not on passing buses, but on passing nuns. [ laughter ] check out this "nun-skitching" video. ♪ >> yo! she's coming. ♪ ♪ [ cheers and applause ] >> seth: skitching with nuns! you may know there's a community of people who trick out and upgrade their cars and then post videos and pictures of them online. well, there's a much smaller community of people who trick out their bathtubs. let's c

russian agents uploaded about 1,000 videos on youtube. so questions each of you and a short answer on these two questions i am going to put together. to each company -- starting with mr. stretch -- have you completed internal investigations to identify all accounts, advertisements and posts with connections to russia that purchased ads in the leadup to the 2016 election? and if not, what is the timeline for completion? mr. stretch: senator, as i stated in my testimony, the investigation continues, and we expect to keep the committee up to date on any further discoveries. mr. edgett: the same goes for twitter. we are continuing to work with your staff on both -- our relevant period was september 1 and november 15. we are working with your staff on other investigations. mr. salgado: and for google, the answer is similar. as our investigation continues we will keep the committee up-to-date. senator grassley: and one i would like you to write -- give me answers in writing, can you give us an update on what your internal investigations found?

youtube denied there is a technical fault and told us...will disable comments on videos targeted by predators. mike wendling, bbc news. time for a look at the weather with tomasz schafernaker. it has turned quite cold everywhere across the uk by now but it is the north will be your feeling the real chill, by now but it is the north will be yourfeeling the real chill, the picture is icy in west yorkshire with some snow across the highlands as well. and we will see more of that over the next few days. but there will be sunny spells as well. most of us will get at least some sunshine over the next few days. quite a bit of cloud around in some areas, these lumps of cloud are shower clouds and some of them are wintry through the course of this afternoon and this evening, across the highlands but benny central, eastern and southern areas will have a clear evening. let's look at the rush—hour across the uk and in the north you can see the major towns and cities are barely above freezing. around 1—3d and some below. a little slow but mostly across

youtube, hundreds of hours of youtube video a minute. these companies have scaled so quickly and so dramatically and that's not a bug, that's a feature. that was the design. imagine a news organization without an editor. and this is now the primary source of news for america. that's where we are now. that's true of everything from the way they sell advertising. there is no human in the loop. that's why we have things on facebook where you could target jew haters, for example, because there's no human in the loop that's moderating things happening on these platforms. greta: if a news organization puts a beheading or burning of a jordanian pilot or something is that they are scandalized and do so much self-reflection afterwards. i don't see a lot of that -- maybe i'm wrong -- in these social media companies. self-reflection when things slip through. or when people exercise that judgment. peter: with the algorithm approach, cause obviously when you have 4000 being uploaded every minute, but with the algorithm saved 2% of this material could

. >>> what has parents and advertisers boycotting youtube. and how the site is responding this morning. but first this, is "today" on nbc. >>> coming up, jill martin is here. she has day three of our holiday "steals & deals." this is jill's super bowl. this morning, it's all about the kids on your list. looking forward to that. >>> and speaking of kids, we're helping bring some smiles to young, deserving heroes among us. you're going to love to meet you're going to love to meet these little seed to the oat ♪ ♪ to the o, to the bowl, to the spoon ♪ ♪ bowl to the spoon ♪ ♪ to the mouth for the boy in a room ♪ ♪ room for that goodness inside the bloom ♪ good goes around ♪ ♪ and around and around ♪ ♪ seed to oat, to o in the first day of school ♪ ♪ schoolin yo sister on why ♪ and just how to be cool ♪ ♪ cool if she hangs ♪ ♪ you can show her what's good ♪ good goes around ♪ ♪ and around and around ♪ speaking of good you'll love new chocolate peanut butter cheerios ♪ ♪ give extra. get extra. when a achoo!alls... ...answer it. with zicam cold remed

we went to youtube to get answers. parents are sounding off about youtube kids.filters and reaching children. but parent tweeting, we recently purged youtube kids from all devices because it got way too weird. another parent posting on facebook, that's why my kids don't use youtube anymore. we saw the videos pop up more than once and it was disturbing. the concerns show videos with inappropriate, sometimes disturbing content. using well-known cartoon characters to lure children in. one example that slipped through, this video, entitled paw patrol babies, that shows characters in the show in violent situations. >> it's being created by independent animators. so, kids don't stand a chance. they see a title that references a character they love. and before they know it, they're watching something that's inappropriate. >> reporter: the head of creative content at youtube kids apologized. >> we work incredibly hard, day in and day out, to maybe youtube kids a family-friendly, kid-appropriate place for families and kids. you know, just put plainly, this content should

it's almost popular channels on youtube, is that right? >> it is a popular channel on youtube. >> u2 provides a share of the money it makes to the sponsors of those channels. there's actually these google calculators second estimate this. is it safe to say they make a significant amount of money and shared ad revenue from you? is google playing this kremlin owned entity? >> they are making revenue through that. >> is google paying them? >> i'm not sure how the money flow goes, but we would certainly be involved in the renumeration of the youtube channels. >> that sounds like you're paying them. >> i don't know exactly the financial. >> so will follow up in writing. >> couple of final questions. with respect to both of a graphic that was just shown on the one that senator koontz or senator blumenthal, you can at least tell us how many people obey the instruction and texted hillary. you would also know who treated clinton came with the # presidential election between november 8. >> we would know the second one. but we would be able to tell i

we're seeing progress being made just recently did it in the times was a long story about how youtube has finally acetic advance from civil society, counterterrorism professionals, pressure from the government and decided to move completely material from anwar al-awlaki, american-born notorious aqap al-qaeda arabian peninsula claire to inspired and has connections to dozens and dozens of attacks. our guests today willac discuss these issues in the merida challenges posed by extremists operating online and also discuss how private sector, government and society can respond.ca i'll also add the issues we will discuss today, the misuse of technology platforms by hostile actors, hostilell foreign actor, private sector accountability and responsibility and the changing perception of silicon valley towards silicon valley amongst policy practitioners, the media, the public generally resonate beyond extremism and terrorism and to touch upon a number of different kind of issue context and policy context. so we hope it will be informative to you if you're interested in illicit conduct online, e

hundreds of hours of video a minute on youtube. these companies have scales so quickly and so dramatically, and that's not a bug, that's a feature. that was the design. now they have become news organizations. imagine a news organization without an editor. that is essentially what we have, and this is where we are now. that's true of everything from the way they sell advertising. there's no human in the loop. that's why we have things on facebook where you could target jew haters, because there's no human in the loop moderating things happening. >> if a news organization puts a horrible video up of a video of a beheading, they are scandalized. i don't see a lot of that in these social media companies, when things slip through or people exercise bad judgment. >> with the algorhithm approach, you have 400 hours of video content uploaded on youtube every minute, so 0we need somebody human to look at it. >> there's a middle ground where you can have highly accurate algorithms. or you can have imperfect algorhithms that are doing an ini

these are problem on news and youtube. was an incredible media piece on what is happening on youtube kids. users have found a way to game the system and get content on their you probably don't want to -- want your kids watching. what is the responsibility of youtube? >> has mark noted, we want the content to be more responsibly presented and we want some kind of authenticity to be appropriately represented on all these services, but we don't want the companies to be in the role of gatekeepers. my own opinion is ultimately they will have to become that anyway. the children's content on youtube kids -- these are people who are gaming the system out of some perverse desire to torment children and -- emily: or make money. isn't it about clicks? david: i guess it is. it is really disturbing. they are exploiting a system that is just there for exploitation. and i believe that machine learning is going to be applied by all parties in these cat and mouse games. in everything these days on the internet it is really an arms , race b

. >> a raw apal gee from a member of youtube's first family. >> i hate myself for the pain that i caused my wife. >> the story behind shea carl's emotional message to fans. >> i'm tired of hiding from it. >>> it's a bird's-eye view and -- >> it's gorgeous. >> see where the eagle soars alone. >>> plus the buzzword for your shot to win a new ipad mini and a mack dreidel monday. >> is that clip real or fake? i don't know, that's what we have you for. >> time to watch the videos and join the debate. i still see real. >> not happening guys, come on. >> this can get sketchy out there on the roads. check the first video out from hong kong in october. the black vehicle drifts over, makes contact, ooh! >> what are you doing? >> looks like everything's fine but no, what's this? >> oh my! oh no! >> holy macaronis. >> there's no explanation as to why, everyone is just driving on the highway and we see this car drift over, like it's lost concentration. makes a light contact and recovers but when it goes back i think it hits the truck at the front, pushes it over, now it jack knifes hard to the right,

youtube this week says that it is trying to bolster its enforcement in this area.ld. people are concerned about this and rightly so. thank you very much. the time is 12:30pm. let's check out the weather forecast. distinct chill in the air right now. it has turned cold right across the country. it's going to stay chilly for the next few days. as far as this afternoon and this evening is concerned, we've got some showers across northern areas. some of them wintry across the hills. temperatures falling to freezing or below across many parts of northern britain, around the pennines and the welsh hills there could be some ice first thing on saturday morning. a really cold start and frost likely to develop down towards the south coast as well. on saturday many of us in the far north—west getting some showers. some of the showers getting into lancashire, the midlands, wales, northern ireland. the vast majority of us in the south and the east will have a fine, crisp day. temperatures only around four degrees in hull. but chilly weather continuing into sunday with a cool br

. >>> it's something your kids probably watch a lot, but this morning youtube is under fire. why the company just yanked hundreds of thousands of videos involving children. >>> and life is about to get easier when it comes to applying for financial aid. the changes college bound students andheir fa tmi >>> you're watching "news 4 today". >>> ahhhh. >> man, did you see that? you're looking at a pretty wild encounter between a d.c. police officer and a few atv riders. looked like a stunt gone wrong here. this happened along the busy 14th street corridor in northwest over the weekend. police were following a group of atv riders when one of the officers tried to jump on to an atv and missed. it is illegal to ride atvs on the streets of d.c., but after that failed attempt at a stop the atv riders were able to get away. >>> this morning youtube is still dealing with fallout after terminating hundreds of thousands of accounts berating a family friendly content. youtube removed more than 150,000 videos after multiple big name advertisers pulled ads over disturbing content involving c

meanwhile, youtube has become the go-to platform. google has now uncovered 1100 videos associated with this russian campaign. much more of your content was likely spread is through other platforms. but it's not just the platforms that need to do more. the united states government has thus far proven incapable of meeting this 21st century challenge. unfortunately, i believe this effort is suffering in part because of lack of leadership at the top. we have a president who remains unwilling to acknowledge the threat that russia poses. and should address this very real threat pose bid russian propaganda. i believe that congress, too, must do more. we need to recognize that current law was not built to address these threats. on what i believe is the most light touch legislative approach, which i hope all my colleagues on this panel will review. the honest ads act is a national security bill intended to protect our elections from the foreign interference we all want to avoid. finally, but perhaps most importantly, the american people also

youtube has made clear that it has responded once this has been flagged.monitoring and identifying and proactively removing content whenever there is any doubt. vicki, this is the territory that you look at. we have heard this before about technology being ahead of the curve, there is a gap between how you monitor what is going on. is that what is happening? partly. this is an interesting story because parents say all the time it's hard to monitor what children are doing, they don't want us checking accounts and we can't follow their instant messages, this is different, this is a broadcast medium and this is a scenario where i would say to parents you should know what your children are posting online, it's possible to see what's online, it's possible to see what's on youtube, its public. as an organisation, wada you see as the responsibilities of youtube, you've heard the statement, what are their responsibilities in connection with these comments that are left —— what do you. as a parent i would turn off comments on my child's channel, that's a sensible s

and we will let you use youtube for free. it looks like it's good for consumer people but you have at&t, they already own directv then you have comcast who owns universal and nbc. they could say we will allow hbo, private access or another company we will charge places like netflix and youtube and exorbitant fee to push their network through. >> it seems like a big victory for the internet service providers but the other companies that you mention are urging that the rules remain in place. the vote will happen next month. we will check back in with you. thank you so much and happy things giving. >> you are welcome. happy thanksgiving. >>> the judge will appeal a ruling by a san francisco federal judge blocking president trump's executive order with funding to sing summation cities. the ruling said that the order was unconstitutional and said that the president cannot set new conditions on funding already approved by congress. the judge also said the policy was unduly chorus of. the justice department said it exceeded its auth