catherine lucey.s is of course, a remarkable transformation for jd vance because look, he in many ways you could argue that he is someone who was on the vanguard of the white working class shift to donald trump back in 2016, there were a number of voters in ohio, western pennsylvania, who voted for obama. and then they voted for trump, right? and his book, hillbilly elegy, a capture some of why this was, but he also has an ivy league pedigree and he was with many in the elite establishment in 2016, paul ryan, among them, the speaker of the house, arguing that donald trump was bad. he called him cultural heroin at one point. he even said in a private message that he might be american marquez hitler. i mean, the rhetoric was very very, very anti trump. i mean, mitt romney told his biographer, mckay coppins for his book, quote, how can you go over the line so stark that and for what it's not like, you're going to be a famous and powerful because you become a united states senator. it's like really you se