Skip to main content

tv   Smerconish  CNN  March 25, 2023 6:00am-7:00am PDT

6:00 am
this is your kitchen under a microscope. just kidding. your kitchen is probably fine. but if you would like to take a break from cleaning glow is here to help. here's how choose your date and time select your top rated cleaner. and watch your home go from this. to this. book your first cleaning for only $9 seriously, $9. i'm jeremy diamond at the white house. and this is cnn. everything everywhere and all at once. i'm michael smerconish in philadelphia. it was one week ago in this hour. that i shared the news that donald trump had just posted on truth social, his
quote
6:01 am
expectation that he'd be arrested this past tuesday. manhattan, d a. alvin bragg said that was never the plan. maybe it was all a head fake, designed by trump to rally his gop supporters in the house. or paved the way for last monday's grand jury testimony by former prosecutor and michael cohen, critic robert costello. perhaps it was just to make brag. think twice before indicting a former president. trump even posted this on a social media site, making it look like he's raising a baseball bat against bragg. he also called him an animal. that post was later deleted. on friday, a law enforcement source told cnn that bragg had been threatened with assassination in a letter containing nonhazardous white powder it's a lot to process let me try and sort it out. remember signs initially pointed to the first trump indictment, possibly coming out of georgia, where fulton county d a funny willis is investigating his attempts to overturn the 2020 election there. and then it seemed that
6:02 am
was going to be lapped by bragg and the hush money case by the end of the week, brags seemed to be slow walking. special counsel jack smith began to sprint. smith was appointed by merrick garland to look both at trump's role in the january 6th case and his handling of classified documents at mara lago. he scored two major victories this week. in the january 6th case. a federal judge denied the claims of executive privilege by mark meadows and other trump aides ordering them to testify to a grand jury. and in the mara lago case to federal courts forced trump attorney evan corcoran to break the attorney client privilege. at issue was whether corcoran would be compelled to testify about who knew what concerning the classified mara lago documents. smith was successful in convincing both a district court and the appellate court sitting in d. c to force corker to testify in front of a grand jury based on something known as the crime fraud exception to the attorney client
6:03 am
privilege. that means that prosecutors have reason to believe that the legal advice was used to carry out a crime. before its ruling the federal court for the appeals for the district court of colombia required trump lawyers to brief the issue by midnight last tuesday. and then required smith to respond by six a.m. wednesday morning. that type of briefing schedule is highly unusual. and to me, it's a sign of the alacrity with which many are now moving to wrap up their trump investigations. no doubt mindful that the 2024 presidential race has begun. and that includes special counsel jack smith. something else. judge borough howl is the district judge who first ruled that the crime products section applied. she issued an order under seal that nevertheless was reported on and has said that the government had made a prima facie is showing that the former president committed criminal violations. that's not the first time that a court opined that the law was
6:04 am
probably broken in trump's handling of the mara lago documents. remember for that search warrant to have been executed at mara lago, a showing of probable cause would have had to have been made to the court. judge howell's ruling is not a guarantee of trump being charged, but it might be a sign that the documents case is a much bigger problem for trump than paying for stormy daniels. silence. the cover up is often worse than the crime, right? in the documents case, it may turn out that notes from trump's lawyer could reveal a plan and or action by the former president to cover up and or perpetrate improper conduct regarding classified documents. and that will make the case much more about obstruction. then the murky no harm, no foul him to defenses. and the federal case seems to have gained steam. now soon, jack smith. is going to have to make a rather binary decision. did donald trump break the law and cannot be proven?
6:05 am
he'll make a recommendation to ag merrick garland based on the evidence. but garland is not obligated to act upon smith's recommendation. garland has what's called prosecutorial discretion. as pointed out by the new york times. what's that? it's a power by prosecutors in the american justice system at both the state and federal level to decide not to bring a case even if the law and facts would support a conviction in the united states. prosecutors have broad latitude to choose among a range of options in handling a criminal case from selecting more or less harsh charges as part of an indictment. to striking a plea bargain to bringing no charges at all. and then there's this quote in our system so long as the prosecutor has probable cause to believe that the accused committed an offense defined by statute. the decision whether or not to prosecute and what charge to file or bring before a grand jury generally rests entirely in his discretion. that's justice potter stewart. writing in the
6:06 am
1978 supreme court opinion, so that donald trump is a former president. now running for his old job. probably not a matter of consideration for jack smith. but it might be for merrick garland. the president biden and former vice president mike pence also had classified documents at their residences probably have no concern. jack smith. but where that will matter in the court of public opinion, it will likely be considered by merrick garland. and that trump faces legal jeopardy in manhattan and in fulton county. georgia is not going to impact smith's determination of whether trump broke the law at mar a lago. but the totality of events now facing trump and the country will likely be considered by garland. alvin bragg might still beat jack smith and merrick garland to the courthouse. but the first case in isn't always
6:07 am
the strongest nor the first that will reach trial. and that's a problem for donald trump. joining me now to discuss cnn senior legal analyst and former federal prosecutor elie honig. he is the author, most recently of untouchable how powerful people get away with it. okay ellie, you're the authority must merrick garland accept whatever recommendation jack smith might soon bring to him. no, michael, he does not have to do that. merrick garland is the attorney general, the united states. he is the ultimate arbiter he does under the law have to give jack smith's recommendation quote great weight, so he has to lean towards deferring to jack smith . but he does not automatically have to do that. he has to exercise america, garland what we call prosecutorial discretion , and i will tell you from day one at the justice department. i was there you are trained. you are not a robot. your job is not to take the inputs the evidence and mechanically apply it to the law and whatever spits out as
6:08 am
the result, you do that you are to exercise broader discretion. and of course that applies extremely to the attorney general of the united states. so what might that mean? in this case? what might be some of those considerations that merrick garland would have to take into account before deciding to indict donald trump for the mara lago case or january 6th? prosecutorial discretion does not mean you can do whatever you feel like it does not mean you can act on a whim. it certainly does not mean you can consider unconstitutional factors like an individual's race, sex or gender. but it does mean that you have to look at factors like is it fair to bring this case? is it necessary to bring this case? if you're the attorney general? you have to think about how will this case reflect on this department? will it promote public confidence in this department? will it promote a sense of legitimacy? will people believe in this case, so all of those sort of softer factors, but they're absolutely in play for america, garland and michael, if you take a look at the justice manual, which is the
6:09 am
official guidance to every prosecutor at doj from the attorney, general and down and you just word search control, f discretion, you will get dozens and dozens of hits virtually every section says the federal prosecutor has to exercise discretion. you heard what i said in my opening commentary that if i'm jack smith, it matters not to me that there were classified documents found in joe biden's garage or mike pence's house in indiana. but if i'm eric carlin, i've got to think. how does it play in the court of public opinion? there'll be a lot of well, what about him? and what about him if i go after trump related to documents? yeah, i think that's a fair consideration. first of all, jack smith also has to exercise discretion. i would add that if we look at robert mueller, who was special counsel in recent memory, he used his discretion. if we look at his report, there are various things that he recommends or does not recommend in his discretion, but absolutely merrick garland has to take the broader view. now as to the documents case, what keeps coming to my mind is there's a concept in football in
6:10 am
the nfl called offsetting penalties, and that means if both the offense and the defense happened to commit penalties on the same play even if their unequal even if one of the penalties is way worse than the other. the result is it wipes out the entire play and you sort of start back where you begin. now, look, we can all understand analytically. there are important differences between the trump documents case and the biden documents case, trump had more documents. trump looks like he was obstructing. biden was not. however i think you're right. i think it's going to be very difficult for america, holland and he's allowed to think about this. to justify and have public confidence in an outcome where he says, i'm going to give the guy who appointed me . attorney general the democrat passed by the way running for office in 2024, in all likelihood, but i'm going to indict seek to imprison his likely opponent, donald trump. i think that that's a tough needle to thread. uh final and quick point. big picture. it looked like you know, it was alvin bragg, who was going to get there first. and then this week
6:11 am
was a very unusual weekend. jack smith, as i said, seems to have lapped him. what do you see? big picture? i still think alvin bragg is the leader in this horse race, so to speak, because he can move so quickly. i mean, we know the grand jury is reconvening on monday. we don't know exactly whether they're going to hear a witness. but once you're at this point in the proceedings, michael, if you're the d, a. you can obtain an indictment. really almost as soon as you want from this point on all you have to do once you're done with witnesses show them. the draft indictment explained the law. have them vote. i've seen that process take place in under an hour, so i think alvin braga's is still the leader in the clubhouse. i think funny. willis is like likely in second and jack smith while you're right that the pace has picked up quite a bit. he's still got to go through merrick arland, who has shown us that he is not a fast decision maker. he does not act quickly. and yet, i think that it's jack smith, who has the most straightforward facts, ellie, you know, i like to respond to social media. stay right there. i'll read it aloud . let's put it up on the screen and see what what has just come in prosecutorial discretion goes
6:12 am
both ways, says bob. what is the damage to the country of not pursuing charges if the special counsel has recommended them, ellie, you would say what to bob starner? that's an absolutely fair point. i think you have to think about how is this going to play? and by the way if it plays out that way, where jack smith recommends charges in america, ireland overrules him that will be reported to congress. by law . we will know that and i think merrick garland needs to think about that. what will it do to doj reputation if i pass, but this is also another important point of discretion. i want to raise off that really smart point. by the viewer there. one of the factors that federal prosecutors at doj are supposed to consider is this conduct being addressed? is it being charged by some other authority ? and so there is a notion that let's say with january 6th if fani willis charges it as a state level prosecutor in georgia, doj can consider that and say it's therefore less necessary for us to charge that conduct. it's all very fraught a series of landmines that are
6:13 am
going to have to be navigated in the very near future. ellie. that was excellent. by the way, i'll remind everybody in your book like you broke the fact that the southern district passed on that which alvin bragg is now taking a long hard look at thank you, ellie. thanks, michael. still to come in the investigation into hush money trump allegedly paid to adult film star stormy daniels. his defense team put a witness before the grand jury to refute the allegations of his former attorney, michael cohen. his manhattan d. a alvin brags case in jeopardy or is he just cooling his jets? michael cohen's attorney, lanny davis, is here and joins me next. plus tiktok ceo, was grilled on capitol hill about his company's ties to china and its protections for user data. the very same day utah became the first state to pass social media regulations aimed at protecting minors. mental health. is it too little too late? i want to know what you think, go to smerconish .com and answer this week's poll
6:14 am
question. you can use the q r code. if that helps you should parental consent. be required before miners conjoined social media. introduducing new sweet d savory crepes for a limited timeme. buy one get one free. wh five flavors that are delicious any time of day only from ihop download the app free food with every order. i think i changed yeah, it happens. that's why vision works gives you 100 days to change your mind. it's simple. anything else i can help you with. like what? vision works see the difference all across the country, people are working hard to build a better future, so we're hard at work, helping them achieve financial freedom. we're proud to serve people everywhere. and investing for the retirement. they envision from the plains to the coasts. we help americans invest
6:15 am
for their future. and help communities thrive. invested in the future of americans. blackrock. what if my type two diabetes takes over? what if all i do isn't enough. or what if i can do diabetes differently? now you can with once weekly mount jaro. man jaro helps your body regulate blood sugar can help decrease how much food you eat. three out of four people reached an a one c of less than 7. people taking mount jaro lost up to £25. mount jaro is not for people with type one diabetes or children. don't take man jaro. if you're allergic to it, you or your family have medullary thyroid cancer or multiple endocrine syndrome type to stop mount jaro and call your doctor right away. if you have an
6:16 am
allergic reaction, a lump or swelling in your neck, severe stomach pain, vision changes or diabetic retinopathy. serious side effects may include pancreatitis and gallbladder problems with the funnel yuria or insulin raises low blood sugar risk. tell your doctor if you're nursing, pregnant or plan to be side effects include nausea, vomiting and diarrhea. which can cause dehydration and may worsen kidney problems. i can do diabetes differently with mount jaro. ask your doctor about once weekly man jaro behind the series tell you about the greatest roster ever assembled monster the outlaw and you can't forget about the boss . sometimes you just want to eat your heroes subway series greatest menu of all time. science proves quality sleep is vital to your mental emotional. and physical health, and we know 80% of couples sleep too hot or too cold. introducing the new sleep number climate 3 60 smart bed. the only smart bed in the world that actively cools. warms. and effortlessly responds
6:17 am
to both of you are smart sleepers get 28 minutes more restful sleep per night. proven quality sleep only from sleep number. back when i had a working circulatory system, you had to give your right arm to find great talent. but with up work, there's highly skilled talent from all over the globe. right at your fingertips. it's where businesses meet great remote talent and remote talent meets great opportunity. this is how we work now. closed captioning brought to you by meso book .com. we proudly help veterans with mesothelioma. call for a free book 1 808 220400 or go to meso book .com. is alvin
6:18 am
bragg getting cold feet about indicting donald trump, or at least about going first, a week after trump's incendiary posts, claiming that he would be arrested this past tuesday, no indictments have been issued. but the trump campaign says it did raise more than $1.5 million in donations from the false warning about the arrest. this week. the grand jury on the case heard testimony from a witness for trump's defense team, robert costello. a former legal adviser and key prosecution witness from michael to advise her to michael cohen when the new york times ask costello about his two hours plus testimony, he said, this quote i told the grand jury that this guy couldn't tell the truth if you put a gun to his head. pleaded guilty in 2018 to federal charges involving payment to porn star stormy daniels, who said she'd had an affair with trump. claim the former president denies. cohen said trump authorized the payment a claim backed up by federal prosecutors, who referred to trump as individual number one. when they wrote in proceedings that cohen himself has now admitted with respect to
6:19 am
both payments that he acted in coordination with and at the direction. of individual one. the earliest the grand jury will meet again is on monday. joining me now to discuss is lanny davis , a lawyer for michael cohen. lanny nice to see you did alvin bragg just back down because of donald trump's posture this past week? so i'm not going to comment on mr bag or all the time we spent with mr braggs, very effective and very meticulous team, and i'm not also going to do what mr honig was saying, and i think you were agreeing to take into political factors or the president of united states. no man is above the law, and mr bragg is addressing this case. as if mr trump where another citizen in danger of being indicted and potentially convicted but can i just address the costello name that you just mentioned again? i know a lot about this being in the room with the prosecutors and with michael cohen, but i can read to you something that
6:20 am
was published in today's daily beast, which is mr costello's own email. let me read it to you and you speak you. you let your viewers decide on mr costello's veracity all that that be up to them. here's his email quote. our issue is this is when they were trying to lure michael into being on the trump team staying in the tent continuing to lie, as he was told to do on his lie to congress and continuing to lie about the hush money payment that the southern district of new york prosecutors instructed on paper said that trump instructed him to pay directed him to pay. but let me just read this quote from mr costello, and that's all i'm going to say about mr costello. his problem is his own emails speak for themselves and i'm quoting our issue is to get cohen on the right page. without giving him the appearance that we are following instructions from giuliani, and i'll tell you that there are other emails that have been published in the new york
6:21 am
times and elsewhere. where mr uh mr costello is actually trying to impress mr cohen that he's so close to mr giuliani. here's the text of a voicemail message and mr giuliani's quote client. holds you in great favor, so this is all part of dangling gang pardons dangling everything else and that's all i can say about mr costello. lanny do hopefully you can tell us this. do you expect that michael cohen is going back before the grand jury in manhattan this week. i have no idea. i can't say that he can't go back in front of the grand jury unless i'm there, and i've gotten no phone calls and no invitations. we were there in case mr costello needed to be contradicted, and we sat for two hours waiting. and then we were told dope. we don't need you. so that speaks for itself. don't know michael is the answer. doesn't the fact that michael cohen has repeatedly testified before the grand jury suggests the importance of his testimony. and the lack of corroboration
6:22 am
that exists for it. no to the contrary, and i'm not going to be specific here. so i'll say it. generally this case is about documents. it's about the southern district of new york justice department under donald trump, which conducted both the fbi search under extensive warrant of michael cohen's documents, and it's about all their investigations. and here's what the southern district of new york federal prosecutors said donald trump instructed michael cohen to pay illegal hush money to influence an election and that is what michael cohen to jail. so that's my district about okay, but the southern district passed right. i mean, they said that this was trivial, according to elie honig book and he broke it. they passed on taking the case that alvin bragg is gonna now prosecute. elie honig is inaccurate. he's making that up . there was no quote. then why didn't the then why didn't the
6:23 am
feds why i have to ask this? why didn't the feds prosecute for these same facts? trump because he was an incumbent president. let me repeat that. how about when he got out? how about when he got out? prosecutors never once suggested that they didn't have a case against mr trump. in fact, they declared they had the same case against trump they did against cohen. they said that trump instructed cohen to pay hush money, but they couldn't prosecute that he was incumbent president. in fact, they called him and he he's not. he's not the president. now he's not the president. now. surely they took a look at him when he got out of office. so you're absolutely right. this justice department could prosecute for the federal crime that donald trump's justice department declared he had committed when he if somebody goes to jail for doing something, the person that directs you to do it doesn't it's because he was incumbent president now, mr bragg as the frontline prosecutor has taken the lead on the prosecution of
6:24 am
this crime, and the justice department is focusing its attention on the interaction, but certainly yes, there was a federal crime justice. department under donald trump declared that trump directed cohen to pay the hush money. lanny novel, risky, untested all words that have been used not by some conservative outlet but by the new york times and the washington post to discuss the alvin bragg case. if in fact it's so novel, risky and untested because they're trying to twin two different charges. why not just charged trump with the misdemeanor for the falsification of the business records? first of all, it is definitely untested because to raise the misdemeanor to a felony, you have to show another crime. that doesn't make it difficult. it just makes it untested. the second crime i just told you i can't keep repeating myself. michael, the justice department under donald trump. declared that he had
6:25 am
directed the crime, and michael did the time now that crime can be proven in new york state with the same evidence by mr bragg. so the answer to your question is, yes, it's novel. that doesn't mean it's difficult. the mr trump committed a crime under new york state law by doing something directing somebody to do something illegal influencing an election. we'll let the lawyers argue about that. that doesn't make the facts are the same. in fact, this crew and mr bag operation. in my opinion, being in the room are meticulous and detailed, surrounded by documents michael cohen's veracity cannot be challenged as of july. 2nd 2018 just remember that date. that's the date when he went public and said, for my country and my family, i'm not going to lie or do donald trump's dirty deeds that i did for 10 years. and then he did that in front of 100 million people by taking responsibility in a public hearing in congress
6:26 am
that point forward cooperated with every investigator. with mr mueller 700 hours spent in front of investigators, including two grand jury appearances, and he did not take the fifth amendment . in contrast to you know who lenny. thank you wish we had more time. i'm sorry i captured a lot of the time here, but there's a lot of misinformation that wanted to be. but here thank you. next next next time, don't hold back your emotions. tell us what you really think. up ahead. utah first state taking aggressive action to address the negative impact social media has had on teens mental health. with a new law requiring minors to get permission from their parents before they can sign up for a social media site. is this a good idea? please go to smerconish .com. you can use the q r code if you would like. answer this week's poll question should parental consent be required before miners can join social media? from early birds
6:27 am
tonight hours. so many ways to save life ready wallet happy that's 3 65 by whole ods market chasing business premier card is made for peopleike sam who make everyday products design smarter, smart coffee grinder, fresh beans for you, genius. for more breakthroughs like that. i need a breakthrough card hours. 650.5% cash back on purchases of $5000 and more plus unlimited 2% cash back on all other purchases and with greater spending potential making smart ideas. current reality. the new business premier card from chase for business make more of what's yours. want to pay only $40 per month with sling tv to watch cnn , hd tv, msnbc and your other favorite channels. you can stream it all on sling all for just $40 per month. try sling today at sling .com slash watch
6:28 am
now, 300. today 100 500 today. today we must finally hold social media companies accountable by persons legislation to stop big tech collecting personal data on our kids. two days online. targeted advertising their children. future is here. we've been creating it for more than 100 years. putting the most advanced technology into people's hands, generation after generation. tool after tool. again. and again, bringing you the broadest and most reliable network of service dealers always moving forward. we need others follow.
6:29 am
you got me, your it. imagine a world with no drama for the guarantee of high quality promotional items delivered on time, go to four imprint .com print for certain stainless steve maclean's your whole home . oh, you got to do is pick up the phone. it's not just carpet anymore. it's tile, wood stone. really any floor call 1 800 steamer now will clean your home and you'll say wow, so what are we eating today? join me. longoria on a brand new culinary adventure, and first up my new home mexico city restaurant with only mexican fish was revolutionary. so they speak spanish, spanish. every time i'm in mexico, this is my daily ritual. this is a contract. this is so good. oh, my god when i was his age, we had to be inside to watch live sports. but with xfinity, we get the fastest mobile service
6:30 am
and can stream down the street or around the block! hey, can you be less sister, more car? all right, let's get this over with. switch to xfinity mobile and save big on the new samsung galaxy s23 series. i should get paid more for this. you get paid when you win. from xfinity. home of the 10g network. give your small business one tech solution that checks all the boxes. it's all here with the comcast business complete connectivity solution. peace of mind with cyberthreat security. the power of the largest, fastest reliable network. plus, save up to 75% a year with comcast business mobile. the complete connectivity solution. from the company powered by the next generation 10g network. get started for just $49 a month. and ask about an $800 prepaid card. comcast business. powering possibilities™. floyd home dot com. good morning, everyone we do begin with breaking news this morning.
6:31 am
hey quick programming note. you just heard lanny davis say that elie honig is wrong in reporting that the southern district of new york passed on prosecuting donald trump for the stormy daniels facts loosely described . so we're reaching out to ellie. to have him come back on this program and offer a very quick rebuttal. so stick. stay tuned for that. first is the clock running out on tiktok show chew, the ceo for the social media giant face grueling questions on capitol hill this week from both sides of the aisle over national security and data privacy concerns for us consumers. its parent company, bytedance, is based in china, but the ceo claims the company does not share its data with the chinese government. tiktok has 150 million monthly active users in the us chew was also pressed on the negative impact of the app on teens. mental health florida republican congressman gus bilirakis went after the ceo
6:32 am
alleging the platform is promoting content that encourages teens to harm themselves. i want to share the story of chase. nascar a 16 year old boy from new york, who tragically ended his life a year ago by stepping in front of a train the content and chases for you. page was not a window to discovery instead. his four you page was sadly a window to discover suicide. jason's parents were at the hearing sitting behind you clearly overwhelmed with emotion on that same day as the hearing. utah's governor signed a bill requiring minors to get their consent from their parents before joining any social media platform. it's the most aggressive step yet to shield kids from potential dangers online. joining me now is utah state senator mike mckell. he introduced the legislation. what do you seeking to do, senator well, we want to
6:33 am
see some broad change across the system. we are very concerned with what we've seen out there in the public. i appreciate the fact that you bring up the issue of mental health. we've got a mental health crisis. i know you've covered it in your show before. there are a lot of negative impacts from social media and we want to change that. we want to see significant change. i really appreciate congress right now. the president united states, there's good bipartisan support. i think we're all on board and that's the goal. i'm going to put up on the screen. i don't know if you'll see it. but allow me to just read a couple of bullet points as to what your legislation will do. verify adult age of utah residents seeking to open and maintain an account get consent of a parent or guardian for users under 18 create curfew settings that block access overnight block underage accounts from search results. social media company cannot collect a child's data. social media company cannot target a child's account for advertising. let's drill down for a moment on the parental consent. it's like you're
6:34 am
forcing minors to have to get the consent of their parents. critic might say. hey parents ought to be better managing what goes on in their household. why do they need the utah government to tell them that's what's necessary? you know, i wish that was the case. i wish all parents would step up. it's simply not happening. one thing i would point out in the state of the union address of president, biden said. we need to stop this experiment on our kids and one of the things, he said, and it shows up and you'll see in your bullet point is we restrict. you can't collect data on our kids any longer. we wish these programs when we look at the data, kids have multiple multiple platforms. they're all signed up with. it's difficult for parents and monitor that we want. we want to empower parents is i've gone out and we've talked to parents parents want want to be involved in the process. they don't know how it's difficult and what we want to do is catch up and catch up with the technology. i'm really concerned about this problem. you're you're right to note that
6:35 am
i've discussed it on many occasions. a critic might say, however, that socially isolated kids like this is their lifeline to stay connected. and now if we're making it harder for them to be online, they're going to be further marginalized. what would you say to that? you know, i think that's it. i think that's a concern that we all we all speak with. but what i would say is, if we've got kids that are marginalized. we need credibility first and foremost, and we built this process out there in the world for decades with school counselors and utah we have an app called safe u t. and what i would say is we should bolster. we should bolster the credible resources that we have today. i think it's really difficult to say we should turn our kids lose. put them in a chat or forum with individuals that we don't know who you are. we don't know how to trust them. and if we if we're worried about that, let's let's bolster the resources that we've we've been bolstering for decades where there is some credibility on the ground.
6:36 am
senator mckellar. here comes some social media stay with me. i'll read it aloud and you and i can respond together. what do we have put it up on the screen. ha ha! good luck with that. kids will always find a way, says mighty woman with a torch. i mean, it's a good point right there so ingenious. won't they figure out a work around? you know some kids will. there's certainly no question when i drive down the freeway. i might break the law and i might exceed the speed limit. but the vast majority i think are going to comply. there's no question where there's going to be leakage. we're not going to capture everybody as a lawmaker with any law that we passed. we always have folks that find a way to skirt skirt the law. that's nothing new. alright you've inspired today's poll question. it's reconnoiter .com so make sure you're voting on it. and thank you, senator. thank you for having me on here is the question should parental consent be required before miners can join social media? that is, among other things.
6:37 am
that's what utah is doing when you're at smerconish .com make sure also registering for the daily newsletter. thank you for that. it's free, and it's worthy still to come. can a landlord listen to this question? now? can a landlord ask a prospective tenant? whether they've got a criminal record. a seattle court just ruled on that difficult question. i'm going to drill down on it next. subway keeps up in the game w with the subway series. an allll star menu arere delicious. subs like numberer s. the boss meatballs with h marina and pepperoni so many times whose the boss the boss, you are the boss. subways tasting menu upade yet come here. you know their phones their banking witht bank of america. it's your cousin jimmy. over there. his girlfriend just called the book a so he might need a little more help saving for that engagement ring. the groom's parents think they're looking at photos of their handsome boy, they're not
6:38 am
. she just saw how much they spent on ballroom dance classes. won't be needing those anymore digital tools so impressive. you just can't stop banking. what would you like the power to do? pedro was born with a cleft lip and palate that threatened his future and impaired his speech, but his cleft condition didn't define him. he's playful, smart , loving. pedro is like any child, you know, and love. children like pedro need your help. thousands of children are born with cleft conditions and have no access to surgery. with your support operation smile can heal them. scan or go online to give a new smile to a child like pedro. a child like yours. make your dream car. a reality.
6:39 am
mercedes benz certified pre owned vehicles are rigorously inspected to live up to the highest of expectations. big pharma. has been unfairly charging people hundreds of dollars, making record profits. not anymore. cap the cost of insulin $35 a month for seniors. no that was that was that the same thing that happened with the microwave? you got this thing we all do is spreading nigeria. eastern europe all over the world, teenage girls the world as we know it may never be the same. the power series march 31st on prime video. scope squeezed a one liter mouthwash bottle fits in the palm of your
6:40 am
hand. add water control the squeeze control the strength. twice or even three times and find a zone all your own. anywhere new mouthwash concentrate, scope squeeze. some people say the metaverse will only be virtual, but firefighters entering a burning house will one day save time when lives are on the line. visualizing a patient's most recent scam. will help speed up decision making in the er. and while the wooly mammoth is still extinct, that doesn't mean students can't take field trips to visit them. the metaverse maybe virtual, but the impact will be real. you're windham is waiting. when bucket list need
6:41 am
checking points need redeeming? work trips need crushing or anniversaries need. celebrating no matter who you are, where you're going, or why. 24 trusted brands by wyndham to choose from your windham is waiting. get the lowest price at wyndham hotels .com. landlords ask a prospective tenant whether they've got a criminal record. in advertising. they can't say things like the apartments perfect for an able bodied person or that it's a short walk to church or that it's an adults only property. that's because the fair housing act prohibitions on discrimination based on all of these factors. but what about rap sheet? that's the thorny question raised by a legal ruling in seattle this week, the ninth circuit court of appeals struck down part of the city's fair chance housing ordinance, saying it infringed
6:42 am
on landlords. first amendment rights. the seattle city council passed the ordinance in 2017, it barred most landlords from asking prospective tenants about their criminal history or refusing to rent to tenants because of their record. it was intended to help those with criminal records, access housing and to protect against policies that might disproportionately harm renters of color because of disparities in the legal system. joining me now is seattle city council member lisa herbold, who was a sponsor of the original ordinance. council person. thank you for being here. this is a confusing ruling. correct me if i'm wrong, because they say, well, you can ask you can ask, but you can't act on it. it seems contradictory. no. it's um it is a little bit of a conundrum because now if this ruling stands, the city is going to need to determine how we can make sure that information scene is not information used. what
6:43 am
would you say to a landlord who says hey, i just want to protect myself and the tenants of my property by knowing who's there ? because god forbid something happens. i'm going to be held accountable. sure. well, you know, there's no demonstrated research that shows that somebody with a criminal background is more likely to be a bad tenant. in fact, one in three of us in this country have some sort of criminal justice system involvement. and um, you know, landlords aren't responsible for not screening their tenants. because of the fact that there isn't a nexus between somebody's criminal background and the likelihood of them being a bad tenant. there's an exception. correct me if i'm wrong, there's an exception in the law that you initially sponsored for sex offenders. how are they treated in this? so the law the recent ruling is not actually gonna impact that
6:44 am
particular type of regulation because the existing law allows for landlords to screen for sex offender registry information and allows them to use it in screening for adults. it does not allow them to use it for youth, though, because the studies show that youth engaged . um in, uh, prior sex offenses are very, very less likely to receive debate. i mean, i get it . your intent here is to try and give people a fresh start, right? they've done their time. they're now free of the entanglement of the system. and if they don't have housing much like, you know the whole debate about check the box in employment. if you're not going to allow somebody to get a job and to get shelter, then don't be surprised if they end up back on the inside is that it? that's that's exactly it. you know if you support safer communities,
6:45 am
you should support this this policy because housing reduces recidivism and also, this policy also supports strong families because half of our nation's children have at least one parent with criminal system, uh , involvement, and it's also a stand for, um for fairness because our system works in a way that when you served your time, or if you haven't been found guilty at all, you should not be punished again. and, um, you know, an x traditional punishment outside of that system is at our odds with a just society. it reminds me this may sound like an oddity to you, but it reminds me of michael vick, who went away because of atrocities that he did with dogs. i'm a dog person. then he came to my football team, the philadelphia eagles and i had to say to myself. well wait a minute. he paid his debt to society, and you know the man's entitled now to earn a living. here's some social media put it up on the screen and the council
6:46 am
person and i can look at it together. i'll read it aloud. it's public knowledge, really obtainable information. they can ask, and if they choose to disclose that will be a good test, you know, council person. when i talked about this on my radio program this week, people did say any landlord, you know, with access to a search engine could figure these things out. quick response from you. it's true, i think, um, it's interesting that we that we've had this this lawsuit that we have been, uh, dealing with for a number of years since the passage of the law, given the fact that this is easily attainable information and the fact that it's easily and table attainable information and more so with passing years, um also means that it can be more harmful. you know, 20 years ago, this information wasn't so available and it wasn't so much a question. um when making those rental decisions of about somebody's criminal history?
6:47 am
it's a provocative question. thank you for being here to explain it to us. we appreciate it. thank you so much for having me appreciate it, okay, still to come the final result of this week's poll question. of course, i want you to go to smerconish .com. but hold on. i gotta ask this. did we get ellie hoenig back? is he going to come back in a moment? he's going to come back. okay alright, go vote its work on it dot com should parental consent be required before miners can join social media and stick around and quick rebuttal. from elie honig to that which lanny davis had to say a few minutes ago. thehere's always a fresh deal on the subway app like this 1 50% off that feels so good. we don't even need an eight time all started telling you about it. wait what it before it's gone on the subway out. i hear you're more than just a landowner. you're a gardener. landscape e hunter. because you didn't
6:48 am
settle for ordinary same goes for your equipment. versatile powerful durable taboada equipment. more goes into it, so you get more out of it. double check that pretty good. yes crying. are you taking that? and what? what was that? that no, don't worry about that. here we go. question can greatly impact your future qualified to do this . what specially when it comes to your finances. do you have a question? are you a certified financial planner? yes i am a cfp professional professionals are committed to acting in your best interest. that's why it's got to be a cfb. find your cfp professional and let's make a plan .org who's on it with guardians. free jump. we're the ones getting it done. we're managing type two diabetes and heart risk on it with guardians joined the growing number of
6:49 am
people who are on it with the once daily pill guardians. guardians not only lowers a one c it goes beyond to reduce the risk of cardiovascular death for adults with type two diabetes and known heart disease and guardians may help you lose some weight cause serious side effects, including ketoacidosis that may be fatal. dehydration can lead to sudden worsening of kidney function and genital yeast or urinary tract infections, life threatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. stop taking guardians and call your doctor right away. if you have symptoms of this infection , ketoacidosis or an allergic reaction, and don't take it if you're on dialysis guardians with a cell phone area or insulin, blood sugar, the pill that goes beyond lowering a one c. we're on it on it on it with guardians, your doctor about guardians. introducing new sweet and savory crepes for a limited time. buy one get one free. with five flavors that are delicious any time of day only from ihop
6:50 am
download the app free food with every order. dude what are you doing? i'm protecting my car. that's too much work whether tech is so much easier. laser measured floor liners up here. protector and cargo liner back there. nice out here, side window deflectors and mud flaps and the bump step to keep the bumper dent free. cool it's the best protection for your vehicle, new or pre owned. great but where do i order whether tech .com. kennedy center presents the prize for american humor celebrating adamson. with special guests tomorrow atirect
6:51 am
today at 803 9 to 7600 or visit coventry direct .com. well in new york, and this is cnn. okay live television. love it. did the feds pass on prosecuting
6:52 am
donald trump for the stormy daniels case? early in the show . i had michael cohen's lawyer, lanny davis on he said that elie honig my prior guest was inaccurate in reporting in his book that the feds had passed on prosecuting trump for the alleged hush money scheme. here's the exchange. we had here's what the southern district of new york federal prosecutors said donald trump instructed michael cohen to pay illegal hush money to influence an election. and that is what michael cohen to jail. so that's my southern district about okay , but the southern district passed, right. i mean, they said that this was trivial, according to elie honig book and he broke it. they passed on taking the case that alvin bragg is gonna now prosecute. elie honig is inaccurate. he's making that up. all right back with me now to reply live cnn senior legal analyst elie honig. i'm giving
6:53 am
you a 62nd rebuttal. what do you want to say? three points. first of all, of course, the southern district passed on charging donald trump for the hush money . we know that because they haven't charged him in 2018 with michael cohen, who was being prosecuted, they could not charge trump because he was sitting president, but they had a series of meetings in 2021 when trump was leaving office and decided against it. that's a fact. second of all, mr davis leaves off a very important part, he says. the southern district said donald trump told michael cohen to do it. he leaves off what comes before that. in that memo, the southern district says michael cohen says. trump told him to do it. which brings me to the final 0.1 of the big reasons the southern district did not charge. this is because they did not believe michael cohen. they found him not credible, and here's a quote from a letter the southern district wrote on december 7th 2018 to the federal judge in the case. they wrote that michael cohen's statements to the southern district were quote. overstated in some respects and incomplete. in others, end quote
6:54 am
michael cohen tried to cooperate with the southern district. they found him to be not credible, and that's a big reason why they passed on charging donald trump. look i don't have your book here . i read it. i'm doing this from memory. but the word trivial stands out in my mind. didn't you also report that the feds found these facts to be rather trivial on which to base a prosecution of the former president? absolutely this goes back to the discretion point we were talking about before michael. they felt that the evidence was a close call. but on balance they felt like given the nature of this conduct compared to january 6th, which is just happened compared to the mueller investigation felt pretty low on the list of importance. alright i'm gonna have to give lanny a sir. reply loni love you. you'll come back on the program at at a point where you can arrange it and reply to ellie. but i wanted to hear from you. so thank you. thank you, ellie. and i'm ready for a sir. sir reply. okay yes, sir. here's the poll result.
6:55 am
let's let's do it. put it up on the screen. totally different subject should parental consent be required before miners can join social media well, 27,000 and change voted and 91% say, way to go, utah. because that's exactly what the state of utah has just done some of your social media reaction. what do we have? do you think certain social media outlets should force teens to acknowledge that they could face attacks on their mental health that they could face attack? do you think certain social media should force teams to acknowledge that they could face attacks on their candidly? don't understand that point. so instead, i'm gonna i'm gonna dodge and simply say this . there's so much data out there showing that a switch got thrown in this country in or about 2007 and eight with a skyrocket of mental health issues with our kids. just whenever everybody had a smart phone in their pocket. see you next week. oh quick programming note. adam sandler. such a funny guy and
6:56 am
his funny friends are all coming to cnn. the kennedy center presents the mark twain prize for american humor celebrating adam sandler. hey, this sounds great. tomorrow night, eight o'clock, cnn that's eastern time. there's a always a first deal on the subway app like this. 1 50% off that feels so good. we don't even need an eight time all started telling you about it. wait what it before it's gone on the subway out. the new chasing business from mere card is made for people like sam who me everyday products desn smarter , smart coffee grinder, frh beans for you, genius. for more breakthroughs like that. i need a breakthrough card like ours. 0.5% cash back on purchases of $5000 or more unlimited 2% cash back on all other purchases and with greater spending potential , making smart ideas, brilliant reality. the new business premier card from chase for business make more of what's
6:57 am
yours. from friends coming over. two moms coming over. so many ways to save life ready, happy 3 65 by whole foods market. this is the sound of better breathing center is an add on treatment for asthma driven by your cinephiles. it helps prevent asthma attacks, improve breathing and lower use of oral steroids is not a rescue medication or for other eosinophilic conditions may cause allergic reactions. get help right away. if you have swelling of your face, mouth and tongue or trouble breathing. don't stop your asthma treatments. unless your doctor tells you to tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection or your asthma worsens, throat may occur. your doctor about cassandra science proves quality. sleep is vital to your mental emotional. and physical health, and we know 80% of couples sleep too hot or too cold. introducing the new sleep number climate 3 60 smart bed.
6:58 am
the only smart bed in the world that actively cools warms. and effortlessly responds to both of you are smart sleepers get 28 minutes more restful sleep per night. proven quality sleep only from sleep number. guys made up work way back where? build free last teams with more. working is deader than me. your 60. yeah. downey infusions, the sense set the mood. feel the difference
6:59 am
with downey. introducing new sweet and savory crepes for a limited time. buy one get one free. five flavors that are delicious any time of day only from ihop download the app free food with every order. good morning, everyone we do begin with breaking news. joining us now are two lawmakers from different sides of the aisle also live in ukraine. i'm dr sanjay gupta everything's changing so quickly. before the xfinity 10g network, we didn't have internet that let us play all at once. every device? in every room? why are you up here? when i was your age, we couldn't stream a movie when the power went out. you're only a year older than me. you have no idea how good you've got it. huh? what a time to be alive. introducing the next generation 10g network. only from xfinity. the future starts now.
7:00 am
traps, odors and little robot provides real time updates by whisker. eva longoria, searching for mexico premieres tomorrow at 10 on cnn. good saturday morning. it is march 25th. i'm victor blackwell. i'm aymara walker. you are in the cnn newsroom this morning residents and first responders across mississippi are surveying the damage after a night of powerful and really devastating storms