. >> sir angus macmillan. >> we are all deeply saddened by the death of linda norgrove. it was will come that the prime minister took time to speak with her father. at a difficult time, i am grateful to the community at this time of grief. does the family needed any help at all, independent or otherwise? >> i thank the hon. gentleman for the question he put and the way he put it. the family must have all the help they need. i have said that anything we can do to help them and any information we can get to them, we must have. there is nothing that can bring linda back. and that wonderful daughter and the incredible life that she led. i think we can help to get all the information and the knowledge about what happened. i hope we can give as much explanation on the background of why so that's best -- so that this family can find closure to this terrible episode. >> lord adonis said that a pure graduate pact would be unworkable and a catastrophe. would the prime minister take the place of the shuttle counselor who said, for goodness sake, do not pursue a graduate tax. >> she