howard, schultz come out, apologized to ingram appaologiig for vile and inappropriate language.elf off msnbc for an indefinite period of time without pay. what's your take on this? >> well, i think he was lucky, to get away with just being off the air for one week. a lot of broadcasters might have lost their jobs by saying something so stupid, offensive and i agree with ed schultz, it was vile and offensive. i give him credit for apologizing and msnbc for moving quickly and not letting this fester. >> he he says he's embarrassed himself, his family. ingram says her relationship with schultz, how would you describe it? >> nonexistent after this point. she's a conservative who works for fox and has her own radio show and ed shultchultz is a passionate labiberal who works r msnbc. but to go into the gutter with that language is hard to understand. i have to tell you, this is not the first time that ed schultz talked his way into trouble. msnb dr. management talked to him about toning things down because he's been personal in calling, for example, new jersey governor chris christie