i'm anne-marie green. well, federal transportation officials have begun their investigation into the deadly crash of a new york city commuter train. at least four people were killed and more than 60 others injured. the metro north train was on its way from poughkeepsie to manhattan when it jumped the tracks as it rounded a curve yesterday morning. investigators are now looking into the train's speed, possible mechanical issue, and human error. marlie hall is at the crash site. marlie, good morning. >> reporter: good morning, anne-marie. federal investigators continue to pore over this crash site this morning trying to determine what led to that deadly train derailment. investigators are trying to determine what caused a commuter train to jump the tracks, killing four and injuring more than 60. the investigation appears to center around how fast the train was moving as it reached a curve in the bronx just north of manhattan. >> we have not spoken to the conductor. we anticipate interviewing the train crews

i'm anne-marie green. well, this morning it is still unclear what caused the ceiling of a london theatre to collapse. the 112-year-old apollo theatre was packed when large chunks of plaster began falling during the performance of "the curious incident of a dog in the nighttime." a many as 80 people were injured, seven of them seriously. charlie d'agata is in our london bureau. charlie, good morning to you. >> good morning, to anne-marie. the ceiling collapsed about 45 minutes into the performance 678 now, one theory they're looking into is weather a torrential rainstorm may have had something to do with it. part of a ceiling collapsed in the middle of a performance of a blockbuster play packed with hundreds of creator goers. >> loud. bearing. i don't think the ceiling came down. dust, chandeliers, wood, that sort of stuff. >> reporter: many thought it was part of the play. >> we thought it was part of the theater and then -- yeah. we just looked up and the whole ceiling -- it was like slow motion. it just

anne-marie? >> thank you, susan. >>> house budget chairman paul ryan, one of the authors of the compromised budget deal will discuss the agreement later on on "cbs this morning." >>> now, it's been an all-nighter in the senate. the senate is dealing with 11 of president obama's judicial nominees, but republicans are holding up the votes as payback for the last month's change in majority rules by the democrats. by reducing the number of votes needed to end a filibuster, democrats weakened the republicans' ability to nominate the nominees. if they use all of their allotted debate time, the senate could be in session through the weekend. >>> and this morning nasa is trying to figure out what caused a cooling pump on the international space station to malfunction. there's no danger to the six crew members. the problem forced nasa to shut down nonessential equipment in the lab complex including some research gear. it's believed a valve inside the pump is the irv, and it may require a spacewalk to fix

i'm anne-marie green. >>> a compromise budget deal is headed to the senate after it was overwhelmingly passed by the house. last night's vote came after speaker john boehner unleashed a heated and unusual attack against conservatives who lobbied for the defeat. he accused the group of working against the interests of the republican party. susan mcginnis is in washington. susan, good morning. >> good morning, anne-marie. the house passing this budget has been a rare show of compromise here on capitol hill. the process of getting it through the house has also made very public deep division between house republicans and house republicans. the house easily passed the budget with bipartisan support. house speaker john boehner himself announced the final tally. >> on this vote the ayes are 332, the noes are 94. >> reporter: it's a victory for the speaker who battled tea party aligned groups who urged the republicans to vote no. boehner says those organizations have gone too far. >> they pushed us into this fight

i'm anne-marie green. well, beginning today nelson mandela's body will lie instate for three days in the building where he took office as south africa's first black president. the union buildings in pretoria is where mandela served only one term. family members are expected to view the casket today. alphonso van marsh is in pretoria. alphon alphonso, good morning. >> reporter: good morning, anne-marie. some are calling it a pilgrimage because people have come so far. behind me in the union building that's where the body of nelson mandela lies instate. police escorted nelson mandela's body to the union buildings in pretoria, south africa, where he'll lie instate for the next three days. mandela's oldest grandson was on hand to receive the flag-draped casket. the family was the first to view the body followed by dignitaries and the public. >> i feel bad because my heart is so -- because my tata is gone. >> reporter: the somber mood at the government buildsiings is i stark contrast to the streets. there south

i'm anne-marie green. well, this morning nelson mandela is being remembered for his resolve and ability to forgive, traits that helped peacefully end the brutal segregationist policy in his native south africa. south africa's first black president died yesterday at the age of 95 following a long illness. he was surrounded by his family. mandela's fight against apartheid made him an inspiration to millions, including president obama. >> i would study his words and his writings. the day he was released from prison, he gave me a sense of what human beings can do when they're guided by their hopes and not by their fears. >> when mandela died, crowds gathered throughout south africa to mourn his death and celebrate his life. debora patta is in johannesburg with the latest. debora, good morning. >> reporter: good morning, anne-marie. well, i'm outside nelson mandela's home. they woke up to the news he had died. it came as no surprise because his health has been very, very poor for six months, but it still has th

anne-marie? >> i never hear about these glitches until after they're already fixed. >> me either. >> i want to be one of the lucky ones. marlie hall at the new york stock exchange. thank you very much, marlie. >>> well, ups and fedex are playing catchup this morning. the shippers are still digging out of a holiday backlog created when they missed delivery deadlines. as manuel bojorquez reports they're dealing with disappoint and angry customers. >> reporter: ups workers spent the day racing to catch up. the company had delivered 132 million packages in the week leading up to christmas, a pace of 300 per second. but it wasn't fast enough to clear an avalanche of holiday orders, including a package for jeff cormier in dallas. >> i don't know what more to say about how frustrating it was. >> reporter: it was an iphone case with his daughter's picture. his grandmother flew back home without it. >> that's what i miss the most. you miss the aha moment. >> reporter: you want her to reopen it in front of

i'm anne-marie green. well, this morning's commute for folks from pennsylvania to new england is going to be a mess. a powerful and deadly storm that started in texas moved east, dropping a mixture of snow, ice, and freezing rain that caused traffic headaches and flight delays, and this morning winter weather advisories and warnings are posted from missouri to maine. marlie hall is here in new york and she is definitely dressed for the challenge this morning. marlie. >> reporter: good morning, anne-marie. this surprisingly strong storm swept across the country, smacking the mid-atlantic region with snow and dangerous deadly ice. the storm slowed traffic and caused numerous accident including a fatal crash on the pennsylvania turnpike. 50 cars were involved in fender benders there. some motorists were stranded for up to seven hours. traffic was snarled from pennsylvania to new jersey. >> the driving today was terrible. it was wet everywhere. my car slipped around the road everywhere. you know, just really b

anne-marie? >> all right. >>> three railway workers were killed when a train derailed in southern new mexico. the train was carried iron ore when it derailed saturday. the three victims were the only people on board. the locomotive jumps the tracks and ended up in a ditch. the others remained on the track. four turned on their side. >>> in scotland the death toll rowe rose to nine this morning in a helicopter crash. a police schoper crashed into a crowded nightclub in glasgow on friday. as charlie d'agata reports crews continue to comb for victims. >> reporter: beneath the debris and twisted helicopter wreckage, search teams found what they feared. deputy police chief rose fitzpatrick delivered the news. >> i can confirm that earlier this morning the body of another person was removed from the incident site. >> reporter: police warned there may be more. they released the names of some of the victims, including 36-year-old police officer kirsti nelis seen here in front of the very helicopter she d

anne-marie? >> marlie hall, thank you very much. >>> well, this morning a large portion of the country is under the grips of a severe winter-like storm that could bring up to 2 feet of snow to the rockies and northern plains. winter storm warnings are posted from nevada to wisconsin. as an arctic air temperature moves in, temperatures are in the western half of the country are plunging, in some areas, by as much as 40 degrees below normal. now, the snow has been falling in boulder. on tuesday it was 56 degrees. today the high is expected to top out at 11 degrees. higher elevations could get up to 3 feet of snow. denver could see up to 9 inches of snow today. >> and some of the heaviest snow is expected to fall in northern minnesota. areas near duluth have already picked up between a foot and 2 feet of snow go along with the high winds. >>> later today president obama talks about the economy and his call for increasing the minimum wage. in his speech the president will address the income gap betwe

i'm anne-marie green. have a great day. omg, jack.roduct ideas people post on your page? they're kind of amaze. ...ing. yeah - that's where i got the ideas for my new- fajita ranch melt. seasoned chicken with a gooey blend of pepper jack cheese, roasted peppers and onions, on toasted sourdough for just $3.99. is that where you also got the idea for that clock bracelet you always wear? my watch? no...these were invented a long time ago. like in the 80's? chelle >>> by golly we made it. good morning everyone, it's tuesday, happy christmas eve by the way. i'm frank mallicoat. >> and i'm anne makovec. michelle has the morning off. it is 4:30 and roberta gonzales is in this morning with a check of weather. >> near and record warmth here in the bay area. right now as you are getting up and heading out the door, temperature-wise into the. 40s and even 30s, 40s and even 50s. we'll pinpoint the warmest locations for the christmas eve and that snow coming up. >>> some folks are working on christmas eve. we are and we're here to talk about the c

i'm anne-marie green. this morning much of the country is in the grips of a ended up. our affiliate in boston has more on the dropping temperatures and the weather. >> a big cold outbreak is in progress and it's going to be felt across the west first. look at the heise. 12 in denver. many spots will stay in subzero temperatures all the way through next week. the cold air continues to move down the plains and by the weekend stretching over toward chicago. high of 21. just a goose egg in minneapolis. the only safe spot on the map is going to be south georgia and florida. that's where you're going to want to go to escape all the cold. you're talking significant snow across the rockies but then it works its way toward the ohio valley and reaching back. places like eastern oklahoma, tulsa, 6 to 7 inches over the next 12 hours. ice and sleet. this is what makes driving so dangerous. east ward toward paducah could see over a quarter inch of iegs which could lead to power outages. nasty situation for folks over th

i'm anne-marie green. it's still unclear why, but federal investigators have determined that the new york commuter train was going way too fast when it jumped the track sunday morning. here's the latest. the metro north train's data recorder showed that the train was going 80 miles per hour when it entered the curve where the posted speed is 30 miles an hour. it's still unclear whether it was mechanical or human error. the train's engineer has been tested for drugs and alcohol. and his cell phone is also being examined. this video released by new york city shows how devastating the crash was. four people were killed. and over 60 others injured. and this is part of the initial fire department emergency call. >> we have approximately five cars stranded. the train is on its side. we have multiple people trapped. >> ko im has more on the investigation from the crash site. >> reporter: federal authorities say this metro north commuter train was rolling at almost three times the speed limit when it left the trac

i'm anne-marie green.ell, a federal judge has ruled that the national security agency's bulk collection of phone records of millions of americans is unconstitutional, it's a blistering attack on the program. the judge ordered the government to stop collecting data and then suspended his ruling because of national security interests. tara mergener has more from washington. good morning, tara. >> reporter: good morning, anne-marie. the judge says the nsa's methods may well violate the fourth amendment. now, this federal ruling carries so much weight because it's the first against the government spying program. a federal judge has ruled the national security agency should stop its full collection of american's phone records. saying it is likely unconstitutional. under the nsa program, the government said, it collects and stores metadata on hundreds of millions of telephone calls in the hunt for potential terrorists. >> what number called, what number, what time, and what date, how many times, and how long, th

i'm anne-marie green. the secret service is investigating a credit and debit card security breach at one of the nation's largest retailers, target. the data theft could potentially involve millions of target customers. tara mergener is in washington. tara, good morning. >> good morning, anne-marie. >> this is believed to be an extensive security breach that took place at thousands of target registers from coast to coast, but this morning most customers don't know it. cbs news has confirmed the secret service is investigating a security breach that involves stolen credit and debit card information from potentially millions of target customers. >> i almost never use cash anymore. i almost use credit cards all the time, so that scares me. >> reporter: a closely watched security blog says the breach started on black friday and lasted until this week. the report states investigators believe thieves stole the data from credit card machines in almost all of target stores nationwide. >> it sounds like the actual p

i'm anne-marie green. well, hundreds of thousands of families from michigan to maine into canada face another day in the dark this morning. utility crews are working hard to fix power lines damaged in last weekend's ice storm, but some face another round of winter weather today. forecasters are calling for 2 to 6 inches of snow and strong winds. as bigad shaban reports, the lack of electricity didn't dim christmas for some families. >> reporter: it was a cold christmas for hundreds of thousands of people in the northeast and the upper midwest who endured another day without power. 8-year-old cheyenne decatur wasn't sure if her family would find her since she and her family spent the holiday at a shelter. >> i'm thinking my mom went to our house and put a note under the tree so when he came there, he took a few christmas presents that he put down and came over here. >> reporter: the decaturs' home in central michigan has been without electricity since an ice storm hit last weekend. temperatures are in the t

i'm anne-marie green. we begin in south africa where the official ten-day mourning period for nelson mandela is over. this morning in the capital of pretoria, a 30-foot steel statue of the former president was unveiled in front of the union buildings where his presidential offices were and today also happens to be south africa's day of reconciliation, a national holiday that came into effect in 1994 at the end of apartheid. yesterday more than 4,000 people gathered in mandela's native village to pay their final respects. allen pizzey has that report from qunu. >> reporter: transported on a gun carriage over the land he loved most, nelson mandela was eulogized, remembered, mourned, and finally laid to rest. he had to be buried at midday so many of the 4 and a half thousand invited guests had started traveling before dawn. 95 candles, were for each year of mandela's remarkable life formed a coffin behind his coffin which sat on two skins of cattle that represents wealth here. tradition played a role in these

i'm anne-marie green. this morning much of the country is in the grips of a massive winter-like storm system that's spreading arctic temperatures and heavy snow. an icy messy commute is in store for folks in duluth, minnesota, this morning where the snow dumped two feet of snow in some areas. at least five of them have been fatal. temperatures there will be in the low teens today. in fact, it is so cold salvation army bell ringers have been forced inside. in salt lake city, a driver who had been in the accident, he forgot to put the car in park. the driverless car headed down the icy interstate with the horn blaring. we don't know where the car ended up. our affiliate in boston has more on the dropping temperatures and the weather. >> a big cold outbreak is in progress and it's going to be felt across the west first. look at the heise. 12 in denver. many spots will stay in subzero temperatures all the way through next week. the cold air continues to move down the plains and by the weekend stretching over t

i'm anne-marie green.ell, beginning today nelson mandela's body will lie in state for three dates in a building where he took office as south africa's first black president. the union is where he served one term. alphonso van marsh is in pretoria, alphonso. >> reporter: good morning, an marie. some are calling it a pilgrimage because people have come so far. behind me in the union building that's where the body of nelson mandela lies instate. he will lie instate for the next three days. mandel mandela's oldest grandson was on hand to receive the flag-draped casket. >> i feel bad because my heart is so -- because my tata is gone. >> reporter: it's in stark contrast to the streets. there south africans sang and danced as they waited for their first glimpse of mandela's body since he passed away last week. a motorcade will bring mandela's body from the military hospitals to the union buildings back every day until friday to give more opportunity for south africans to line these streets and say good-bye. >> we

i'm anne-marie green. well, a second deadly terror attack in less than 24 hours is raising new safety concerns in russia just 39 days before it hosts the olympics. a bomb ripped through a bus in volgograd this morning, killing at least 14 people and injuring others. on sunday a suicide bomber killed at least 17 at a train station. volgograd is about 400 miles from sochi where the winter games are being held in february. susan mcginnis has the latest. in washington. susan, good morning. >> anne-marie, good morning. the death toll for both of these bombings could still rise from here. there is said to be widespread panic in volgograd and large worries about the upcoming olympic games with a rebel cheh chen leader calling specifically for attacks at the olympics. a burned out shell is all that's left after a bomb ripped through this bus in the russian city of volgograd. this is the second attack in the city in just two days. on sunday at least 17 died when a suicide bomber detonated a device at the entrance t

i'm anne-marie green. and we begin this morning with bone-rattling cold weather that's covering the central u.s. and moving east. the arctic air mass has produced snow and ice, causing power outages from wisconsin to maine. there are windchill warnings in north dakota, minnesota and michigan. travel is difficult due to heavy snow in iowa. and the northeast may be in for a major snowstorm to begin the new year. meteorologist eric fisher of our boston station wbz has more. >> here we go, the final day of 2013 and cold is going to be the rule for a lot of folks. especially in the north central united states, up in the northeast, as well as below average temperatures it will be bitterly cold in places like minnesota and north michigan. so you definitely have to bundle up if you're heading out to end one year and start another. and there's the core, 6 below zero in minneapolis. 8 below in bismarck. even atlanta into the 30s. the warm stuff in south florida or southern california with 50s in los angeles at the s

good morning, marlie. >> good morning, anne-marie. retailers aren't ready to call the holiday shopping season over just yet. retailers from amazon to old navy are launching aftersales. they're hoping to lure people back into the stores to make up for the sales slump this season. some brick and mortar stores open up at 5:00 a.m. while some etailers kicked off. >>> the shanghai composite lost more than 1%. tokyo's nikkei added 1%. hong kong's hang seng is closed for the holiday. the markets here reopen this morning after traders took christmas off and called it quits early on tuesday. an unexpectedly large increase in orders for manufactured goods pushed stocks higher. on christmas eve the dow ended the shortened day up nearly 63 points. the nasdaq finished 6.50 ahead. >>> the numbers of debit and credit card numbers from target could be more damaging than they thought. the hackers also got away with the pins needed to withdraw cash from victims' bank accounts. targets said no unencrypted pins were compromised. >>> mcdonald's shut down

i'm anne-marie green. well, two winning tickets were sold for last night's mega millions jackpot, the second largest lottery prize in u.s. history. lottery officials say one ticket was sold at a newsstand in atlanta, georgia, and another at a gift shop in san jose, california. the winning numbers are -- lottery officials say the jackpot is expected to exceed $647 million when the final ticket sales are calculated later today. now, the seller of the winning ticket gets a small percentage of the winnings and early this morning outside the san jose store, the man who says he is the owner was clearly excited. >> the lottery called me and let me know. i come and take a look, you know. but everybody here, whoa. >> mega millions changed the rules in october making it harder to win. the odds of winning the jackpot are now about one in 259 million. there were 20 tickets sold that had the five winning numbers but not the mega ball number. those tickets are worth $1 million. >>> now, nasa has ordered the to american

i'm anne-marie green. it is deadline day again for theardable care act. the obama administration is giving americans who want coverage on january 1st one more day to sign up. as nancy cordes reports a lot of people need the extra time. >> reporter: these last-minute shoppers at highland mall in austin, texas weren't there to buy gifts. >> there's a policy number and then there's a member i.d. >> reporter: they were there to purchase health insurance through a federal exchange with the help of staffers through a nonprofit. the group insure central texas signed up more people on monday than all the time. >> we'll probably surpass the day. >> reporter: there was a mad dash in virginia and on online. more than 1 million people have visited healthcare.gov. about five times more than last monday. some users were told to wait here when they tried to logon or to read their e-mail so they could be notified when demand flowed. the administration announced the 24-enrollment extension at midday but warned you should not wait if you're aiming to get coverage january 1

i'm anne-marie green. thanks for watching. i'm anne-marie green.ptions by vitac -- www.vitac.com >>> your realtime captioner is mrs. linda m. macdonald >>> good morning. it is december, 25. merry christmas to those who celebrate. michelle is off today. i'm anne makovec. >> hi, everyone. i'm frank mallicoat. it is 4:30 on this christmas day. and liz is off. roberta is in. and she is double dipping on this christmas morning. good morning. >> this could be interesting. >> we're looking forward to it. it will be a memorable christmas to say the least. good morning, everybody. it's memorable because today, temperatures are going to again be unseasonably mild and a direct result of the stagnant air mass is this is the 18th "spare the air" day of the winter season. hazy as highs are in the 60s and low 70s. right now, into the 30s and 40s and for some azy crreason you need to get out the door and jump in the car, a live look at the bay bridge on this christmas morning. 'tis the morning of christmas and all is quiet. there are a few cars out there. caltrans

her partner anne marie is in the audience, along with all of her colleagues who could be here in theernoon. >> i am a little nervous. i don't know there would be this many people here. commander, thank you for being who you are. >> would you state your name for the record. >> kathy broussard. >> thank you for being who you are, i have always known how busy you were working on the administrative side of our department and the countless meetings, negotiating and campaigning all the way to the top of us, work on the inside now i got a better glimpse of what you do and have even a better understanding of how you did what you do. everyday you made a difference for us. you have shown me how much you can love us, yet keep us disciplined at the same time. you taught me to never spare effort or i would meet disaster. my spirit of sacrifice is now great. thank you for believing in me, now and also in the past when i wasn't sure when i believed in myself anymore. your believing had in me has led me to succeed and do better. you have inspired me in so many ways with your words and action and wit

anne-marie slaughter, president of the new american foundation. great to have you with us. thanks for joining us. >> thank you, it was a pleasure. >> coming up - the white house relaunched its revamped obamacare website and claims 90% of the problems are fixed. why an insurance companies concerned about a knew issue. we are tracking what is happening on the web? >> there's a customised way of treating patience that may change the future of medicine. we ask you to send us your movember moustaches, and you did. join the conversation throughout the show on twitter, and google+ and facebook places. >> for those suffering from frustrating obamacare shopping experience, december is a crucial month. they have until december 23rd to sign up if they hope to get coverage by new year's day. the white house declared healthcare.gov is 90% cured of its troubles. with a consumer crash, how will it hold up. joining me to discuss the latest is jennifer haberkorn, a reporter for "politico," thee covered the affordable care act since 2009 and michael shure is a political contributor to al jaz

what is anne-marie slaughter saying about it today. >> millions of americans wrap up holiday shopping, did the supreme court make your future shopping seasons more expensive. >> i'm antonio mora. we begin with the question after the worse in iraq and al-qaeda - are we safer. osama bin laden was emim nated. he'll fire missiles from drones killed al qaeda operatives, and barack obama said it again. >> the core of al qaeda is on the path to defeat. our nation is cure, and our homeland is safer. >> two important members of congress in a position to know, including a democratic ally of the president don't agree with him. i'm pleased to be joined by jane harman, a former democratic congress woman who served on department of homeland security commit he is and is director, president of the woodrow wilson international centre for scholars. great to have you with us. let's start with barack obama. he said on 9/11 that we are safer because we decimated al qaeda's core leadership. on sunday senator fienstein said something different. >> i think worldwide is up worldwide. statistics indicate that.

and i'm going to start with you anne marie slaughter, over all when you consider u.s.oreign policy over the last year, how does it look to you, was there an over arching theme that you saw. >> i think the overarching theme is leading through diplomacy or putting diplomacy very much first. this is -- 2014 will be the year we pull our troops out of afghanistan. the presidenting will able to say that he ended two wars and he put diplomacy front and center and on iran, i think he really skeeted, that framework agreement is the best news that we have had in a long time on iran. i think behind the scenes diplomacy in china with china and japan and other countries in east and south aiz yar, very effective. on syria, on the other hand, yes, good diplomacy to get chemical weapons out but where i think they have really fallen down is no successful diplomacy with respect to the underlying conflict in syria which just gets worse and worse, and at this point, no credible threat of force which means it's hard for their -- to make diplomacy bork in that case. >> we will pick up on th

it's no longer private. >> ann-marie says she tried everything.her ordeal went on for almost two years. i went to lawyers in 2010 to handle this civilly. the first one said, "you know, you should get better boyfriend, i won't take the case." the second i approached said, "it will be a $5,000 upfront retainer and could run from $10,000-$15,000." i'm a single mum of two, i work two jobs, i don't have 15. >> the english professor plans to lobby for the new laws, hoping to give other victims the justice they receive. >> your ex never faces charges. >> nothing. >> he has the images. he could strike again? >> of course. >> how concerned are you that this could happen again? >> it's in the back of my head. there's a part of me that thinks bring it on, dare you. the internet is a wonderful tool and a wonderful weapon. unfortunately too many people have chosen to use it as a weapon. my ex. his words were i will destroy you. he chose the internet as his weapon. he was far from successful. >> correspondent adam may reporting to us. >> turning to afghanistan

that's the cbs news for this tuesday, i'm ann marie green. have a great day. arrived and president zuma, president of the country, was booed. that's a very interesting dynamic. >> this is a famous gospel song, and i'm frank mallicoat time is 4-- here >>> good morning everyone, it's tuesday, december 10th. i'm michelle griego. >> hi everyone, i'm frank mallicoat. nearly 4:30 on your tuesday and lout the door and -- out with door with a little traffic and weather. let's get it going. >> we're back in the deep freeze again this morning. it has been day after day of very cold temperatures down to 26 in concord right now. 24 in napa. and 24 degrees in santa vow s. the good news -- rosa. the good news is the cold snap will soon come to anened. >> thank god for seat warmers. >>> everything is good coming into san francisco. but we're getting word of a new accident on the opposite end. southbound 101 near eastbound 80. all the details on that coming up. >> thank you liz. >>> well happening right now, tens ofthousands of people and several world leaders including presi

i have anne marie slaughter. bret stephens is columnist for "the wall street journal," and the economics editor of "the economist" and ian bremmer looks at political risk around the world. so brett, how do you think president obama did for a completely fair and unbiased assessment? >> about as well as president bush did at a similar time in his tenure, 2005, which is to say it has not been a good year for him domestically for all of the reasons that we know since the disastrous rollout of obamacare which i think will be a rolling disaster. we haven't seen the end of it by any stretch. in foreign policy, this has been a year of american weakness. we saw it in gyrations about what to do with syria and the assad regime's use of chemical weapons. we've seen it in my view -- i have a sense there will be disagreement with this very ill conceived deal with iran. we've seen it in the skepticism of allies from japan and israel and saudi arabia who no longer feel can haonfident about amerin security guarantees that have be

i do understand the number of amendments i want to ask ann marie rogers to go over those >> thank you members of the committee i'm app. those are technical clarifications that we've worked out. the first one is on page 3, line 3. it said those controls are applied to commercial buildings we had some questions about the controls of one hundred percent commercial buildings or to other buildings that have residential uses and the supervisor wants those applied to any building with commercial outdoors. that doesn't have to be a one hundred percent commercial building only the use in the building. also on page 3, line 21 buildings built prior to 1979 it would be hard to ascertain when the building was built but we have information about when it was first - it indicates the issuance of certify of okaycy. on page 4 lines 3 and 4 this year's references to those shall require through or a conditional use and a conversation with our staff every application should require application use and certainly the threshold for authorization those require cu plus prop m review. and those are the changes