alex kim doing business as its market, verses the department of public health. and the department of 1561 fillmore street and an appeal of the suspension on the may 19, 2014 of a tobacco sales establishment permit permit and selling tobacco to minors and we will start with the appellant or his attorney, and you have seven minutes, thank you. >> i am robert comings and i represent alex kim and this is the sole port support of his business and he has paid all of his taxes to the board of equalization and the board and the irs and his permitting and licensing up to date. and as you will see in the brief, he has posted signage, warning that under aged sales to minors will not be acceptable on his premises and there is signage posted outside, as well as when you first walk in and all over the counter where the cash register sits and there is reverse signage that tells the cashier exactly what to look for in the identification and how to check the ids. and he daily on a daily basis, speaks to his employees about receiving identification from each of the customers that