then convicted in 2009, even after dna evidence on the victim's body only pointed to one man, rudy gaday was convicted of the murder. the evidence against knox remained thin, leading to an appeals court to overturn the verdict in october of 2011. >> amanda knox was wrongly convicted. >> reporter: amanda knox was free after four years in an italian jail, vowing to never return to italy. >> thank you to everyone who has believed in me. >> reporter: knox attempted to fade into normal life in seattle. she's changed her appearance, keeps a low social profile. she calls herself a free throw lance writ-- freelance writer. but the case merely changed chapters. the acquittal overturned in 2014. the saga continuing. >> when i look at her, i see the victim of what i call the pagan scapegoating ritual. >> reporter: nina hurley spent a year investigating the case. she says the salacious narrative took over the mundane looklihood that this was just a burglary gone wrong. >> there were mistakes made early on. like many prosecutors and many police around the world, not just in italy, when they make a mi