egon. >> okay. so we've heard the reports thank you, mr. egging on. >> thank you colleagues are there any other future questions or comments supervisor campos. >> thank you. was telling supervisor farrell i'm okay you know being society with fruits there's nothing wrong that that (laughter) but i will say what's interesting interesting about this whole discussion others crux of the criticism of the budget and legislative budget analyst report there's all this data that's not under and the reason why the data is not there airbnb refuses to provide that so i wish that folks who or so concerned about that will actual address the question to the actual reason that's a problem airbnb and by the way, the reason why question focus on airbnb is because first of all let's be honest here mr. chow met with airbnb 66 times before airbnb started so airbnb had a lot to do what what writing the law so airbnb and their supporters show you we're picking on them they wrote the law they wrote the law and the thing about the idea of a lemon you know when i if

ml and they' pretty silar pler hers g at had 24 toudowns ufand guchip kel waedo reuit of higscolo egon andant tis y four years annow finally g him. h sa he was be pler availle 20 tfit e ssm. he r in ip in t hlway i never se shmap i sa ge pick he saitnks. here e commissn makg a pc nln agholor at 2 > th th pi in the 15 nlraft thphilalia egles sect ln aghol wide ceiver >> ll it's alayer he kn. >> holors a guy eagl word outwice prate. tey a ry fondf him. o urse th nd a wi recver beuse there's no dsn jason the's no jere maclin on t tam. h's guwho can al return pn ankic ve hap. s isis faly to playor cip kelly. now, asor may t a. kl said thcvertions wittennese neveeven got srio. bcse e aing pre was so hg h id it kind ofike when yu driviaancy neiborhood you e is beaiful hou you want to b bt dot go iide becse the pices too se tas what itale. w' havmore cong u tnig on gles dra bredown and "actionews" sos speclit afr this proam "aion news" at 11. w' have me congpar i spts. yoll hear from coa key hay with hor ad noterribly surpsed h wasot able to me up to gt maus maota. > thko jami >>> phadelia's

rentals and followed by a presentation of the controller's office of economic analysis presented by ted egon as of the planning commission hearing there was quite a bit of condominiums from david rishgd and airbnb the comments were similar to what this commission heard no april at the end of the comment the committee anticipated the reduction of number of dates and the participants will center to wait to - this motion was passed from a 2 to 1 vote that supervisor wiener desenlt and the ordinance to include low language in supervisor jane kim that restricts the short-term rentals from being used for 5 years they moved to move the - they tabled supervisor kim ordinance which was a duplicate from the short-term rental ordinance and this was at the request the supervisor kim at the conclusion of the 6 and a half hour meeting the committee adjourned at the full board supervisor kim's passed it second reading and the requirement for cu for certain uses not castro upper market and cds passed it first reading and the redesignation of the western manufacturing building passed it first reading and the

egon has left but i'm going to ask staff are we - do we look at the same income levels we talked the daytime of $60,000 a year this is prorngsly lower income have we looked at churn within the income levels people are moving out is that part and parcel of this or a different question. >> is it so part of the same question we've not gotten the information but part of i think one of our basic points we want to spend time and energy with the demographics and the current block as general how it is used. >> thank you gil. >> just to put awning emphasis of the million trillion other things you guys are research i think that is important a key back to a woman sitting here the landlord is renting their apartment for $7,500 a month this is compatible to $300,000 a year income most people are not making that kind of money we get something truly it what manhattan used to be like in the 90s you come in and spend our money in rent and endure it and move somewhere else and that's what's happening i try to stay away from ann dotsz people make good money but delve it out for 3 years and either move