mr. marshall: i want to know why so many companies are giving money for ads if it is not working. mr. holden: they are giving it so their voice can be heard. marketplace of ideas. both sides do it. whether they are effective or not, who knows? these candidates elected in 2014 that flipped the senate will be up in six years. people vote on issues particular to them. both sides run a lot of ads. that is how it is, for whatever reason. mr. smith: higher spending doesn't on the public. the public votes based on information. repetition is the hallmark of learning right? if you repeat yourself, you will remember it tonight. that is how you get through. it helps voters locate candidates on the political spectrum. in a sense, i think what mark and bill are right, the ads will not change the minds of people who have strong perceptions. they may not change them generally, but they may inform a voter on where a candidate is on a particular issue. mr. rosen: one last set of questions. our job is to figure out what the left and right disagree and agree about. as in the fourth amendment area, we ha

mr. marshall: i want to know why so many companies are giving money for ads if it is not working. mr. holden: they are giving it so their voice can be heard. marketplace of ideas. both sides do it. whether they are effective or not, who knows? these candidates elected in 2014 that flipped the senate will be up in six years. people vote on issues particular to them. both sides run a lot of ads. that is how it is, for whatever reason. mr. smith: higher spending doesn't on the public. the public votes based on information. repetition is the hallmark of learning right? if you repeat yourself, you will remember it tonight. that is how you get through. it helps voters locate candidates on the political spectrum. in a sense, i think what mark and bill are right, the ads will not change the minds of people who have strong perceptions. they may not change them generally, but they may inform a voter on where a candidate is on a particular issue. mr. rosen: one last set of questions. our job is to figure out what the left and right disagree and agree about. as in the fourth amendment area, we ha

mr. marshall. portraits of all the former defense secretary's. they they came with are going to have a ceremony. they did have all they can relationship. it wasn't on his calendar and the marshall really was the guy who gave the insight to think about this new structure. there are professors at ivy league schools, people in the business community. one of the dean's in business strategy teachers at ucla this strategy, that strategy, talks about marshall. marshal from the defense world. and so of course people like. myself, there is this innocence been touring that he has done. one of the quotes of the final chapter, chapter, someone asked marshall what he thought his greatest contribution was. he said, the people i think i've help on the way to have an understanding of how to do analysis better and so on so it is that. on the other thing is whatever a defense secretary grumbles about this guy some secretaries of defense what the politically correct answer. whatever that issue has been raised for once in the late 90s, raises again ten years later it

mr. marshall. so he left the pentagon, the pentagon there is portraits of all the former defense secretaries and the day came when there was a ceremony that would unveil the portrait, they didn't have a lot of good relationships. it will be 10:00 in the morning, pick up the flag and shares, in the outer office and marshall is fair and one of my colleagues said to him are you going to the weinberger ceremony, weinberger instead of his picture. and no matter what happened in terms of the ups and down this of the defense secretary's. one is is mentoring of people in the impact it has. so in 1957, looking for a topic to write about and marshall suggests a topic to her and ends up being pearl harbor which ends up winning all kinds of book awards and a medal of freedom from president bush in the 1990 and fundamentally, intelligence and early warning and circumstances under which we will be attacked. a few years later a book comes out called the essence of decision which fundamentally leads to rethinking

it's interesting that mr marshall also admitted that the consequence of increasing the minimum wage was going to be higher prices. the prices hurt poor families more than rich families who can afford the higher prices. >> i understand your point about choice, but aren't people paying a hidden tax by taking wal-mart workers out of their tax many giving them food stamps income tax credits. various entitlement programs that they qualify for because they earn so little on the job. well, that's better than the alternative of paying these people more welfare if they didn't work. you know i think the idea is that people get into the workforce, learn to show up on time acquire skills a lot of wal-mart managers and executives started out in minimum waning jobs same at mcdonald's. mrgs and franchise owners started out flipping hamburgers taking orders and that upward mobility is what we need to preserve in america. and if you cut out the entry level job for someone with low skills because you raise the wage too high and they are replaced with computers or software programmers teaching computers h

mr. grassley: the united states marshal service performs many important functions marshals protect federal judges, they transport federal prisoners, and they apprehend fujitives. the marshals operate the witness security program and they manage the asset forfeiture program. the work is vital and sometimes even dangerous. given the important nature of the work, it is all the more essential that its leaders carry out their mission with integrity and openness. unfortunately, the evidence suggests there are serious questions about the leadership of the marshal service. the growing number of allegations brought to my office by whistle-blowers is very alarming. the growing number of applications brought to my office by whistle-blowers is numerous. it suggests there may be a pattern of mismanagement. in several letters to the justice department, i have asked about multiple personnel actions allegedly driven by favoritism rather than merit. the first example involves the director of the u.s. marshal service stas shvment a hilton. in september 2011, director hilton sent an e-mail from her personal

board down the hall but i hate to come report blapth and forward commissioner marshall you were here who study study that inform mr. on the other hand hear that was clyde and god bless the young lady chief suhr you played dirt with her i'm not stupid what you did to that woman is you think nibble and immoral and despicable i talked to commissioner brad and i said this is how it went down god greg she investigated you, you and i talked about that two years. >> clyde address tour comments to the board. >> we have the police budget that woman was macro 80 grand a big expense foreperson for the city and county of san francisco please he makes 325 imi'm glad it worked out for her i'm total glad that worked out out for her a recent there's a if i people sitting her once she came before. >> clyde i have to remind you address the whole board. >> you may want to get our information correct. >> we're not going to go back and forth thanks clyde. >> i'm first wanting to say thank you, mayor ed lee for finally doing the dash cantonese and i'll speak to you about the quotation she gave and get it done as quickly as possible ame

. >> with his fame growing daily while bill hickok is elected marshal of a booming rail town. >> congratulations, mrok, you're now a dually elected official of the city of kansas. >> the event marks the first step in his career as celebrity law enforcement. but hickok's new-found fame is both a benefit and a curse. for some, it commands respect. but it also puts a target on his back. >> it was a hotbed of youthful indiscretion. it was a cattle town and rail head. a lot of guys came in there to spend their money. >> you don't know what a country this is for fighting and drinking. a man can do what he pleases without fear of the law or anything else. >> it was fairly lost until hickok came around. >> once you acquire this international fame, which he did, of being the quickest shot in the west, you're going to get some jerk who wants to make a name for himself by taking you down. >> in july of 1870, while hayes city contains the seventh calvary, hickok gains resentment among the troops. the brash young soldiers under general custer's command size up the legendary gun slinger. >> look who it is. >> who

. >> with his fame growing daily while bill hickok is elected marshal of a booming rail town. >> congratulations, mru're now a dually elected official of the city of kansas. >> the event marks the first step in his career as celebrity law enforcement. but hickok's new-found fame is both a benefit and a curse. for some it commands respect. but it also puts a target on his back. >> it was a hotbed of youthful indiscretion. it was a cattle town and rail head. a lot of guys came in there to spend their money. >> you don't know what a country this is for fighting and drinking. a man can do what he pleases without fear of the law or anything else. >> it was fairly lost until hickok came around. >> once you acquire this international fame which he did, of being the quickest shot in the west you're going to get some jerk who wants to make a name for himself by taking you down. >> in july of 1870 while hayes city contains the seventh calvary, hickok gains resentment among the troops. the brash young soldiers under general custer's command size up the legendary gun slinger. >> look who it is. >> who? >> wild

mr. pataki: thank you. [applause] ♪ don't stop believing ♪ >> i am larry gilbert, former u.s. marshalrict of maine. i reached the cap on social security. i understand you are opposed? >> i am not going to answer it. good to see you, thank you. mr. pataki: thank you. >> great job. mr. pataki: thank you. thank you so much. >> i need a picture. [inaudible] >> new hampshire is very important. i love new hampshire. so much of it is -- i love that you sit down across the kitchen table and they ask you a question. i love that. >> do you feel you can distinguish yourself as more of a moderate? mr. pataki: i think i have led for many years a very deep blue state, but changed dramatically. some of the changes i've talked about today shows i can win the election, i can replace dependency with opportunity. i know that in my heart. we are going to fight the fight. i think having been in the private sector is a bonus. i have spent plenty of time in the government. i also know what the private sector is about. >> why here in new hampshire? and why this time around? mr. pataki: i love new hampshire p

mr. tsarnaev will remain in custody of the u.s. marshals. there is another proceeding, a huge proceeding that remains to be completed. and that is a sentencing hearing. there will be a sentencing hearing that will be scheduled. we don't know when. as you heard in court the judge scheduled the status conference, a death status conference, i would hope and expect that they would discuss when the sentencing hearing will be scheduled. at which point victims and survivors will have an opportunity to make an impact statement in writing. we've already solicited written impact statements from victims and survivors. but some obviously will be given the opportunity to be heard in court. so we'll figure that out. but there will be a sentencing hearing. the judge will then formerly issue a sentence, and then the defendant will go into the custody of the federal bureau of prisons. then they will determine whether he goes to atx or terror haute. we have nothing to do with that. the federal prisons will be in charge. (?) >> you or the law enforcement -- [i

mr. tsarnaev will remain in custody of the u.s. marshals. there is another proceeding, a huge proceeding that remains to be completed. and that is a sentencing hearing. there will be a sentencing hearing that will be scheduled. we don't know when. as you heard in court, the judge scheduled the status conference, a death status conference, i would hope and expect that they would discuss when the sentencing hearing will be scheduled. at which point, victims and survivors will have an opportunity to make an impact statement in writing. we've already solicited written impact statements from victims and survivors. but some obviously will be given the opportunity to be heard in court. so we'll figure that out. but there will be a ste

joining him is the president and ceo of the thorough good marshall college fund representing 300,000 students. mr. taylor's accomplishments are many. in 2011 he was named to "ebony magazine" 100. before becoming president of the their marshall fund, helped compass group, paramount pictures and a graduate of the university of miami and holds masters of honors and doctorate of jurisprudence. america is facing key decisions in a wide range of policy areas and right now two of the leading thinkers will discuss what path the nation should take. join me in welcoming jason riley and johnny taylor. >> welcome. >> good to be here. >> appreciate it. >> glad to be here. >> i'll let you start off. >> wow, puts me on the spot. >> yeah, first of all, i want to thank you-all for giving me the opportunity. i would have been here all day. i was invited at the last minute. i'm a stand in for the real guy right? [ laughter ] >> so like saturday night i'm like can you come? i said well, who couldn't? that's why i'm here. in any event one of the things that you couldn't have asked, talking about gratuity, you couldn'

marshal capitol regional task force had been looking for mr. wint. they also thought that they had caught him on wednesday in new york. he got back to this area. but what was interesting is around 11:00 tonight, in the college park maryland area off of route 1, they observed a vehicle with mr. wint on the passenger side. and they also had a box truck that the chevy cruise was following. they allowed that car to get to washington, d.c. to the area of rowland avenue northeast. at that time they came upon his vehicle and made the arrest. now, what is interesting about that is that mr. wint from what i understand mr. wint's brother was also arrested. and a large sum of money was recovered from the box truck. that being said, the question mark now is a question that was raised earlier tonight by greta van susteren on her show. and is was there any accomplice. how could one man tie up three different individuals. and at the same time how did that person get to that location. and then leave in a porsche automobile. >> so you're saying that darren wint's bro

mr. tsarnaev will remain in the custody of the u.s. marshals.there is another -- >>> i'm wolf blitzer in "the situation room." we want to welcome viewers in the united states and around the world. you're watching a live news conference where prosecutors and the phishfbi are discussing the jury's decision of a death sentence for the boston marathon bomber dzhokhar tsarnaev. let's continue to listen. >> >>> -- victims and survivors will have an opportunity to make an impact statement in writing. we've already solicited impact statements from victims and survivors, some will be given an opportunity to be heard in court, obviously. we'll figure that out. there when be a sentencing hearing, the judge w

mr. neore news to come. jerusalem day turned violent in israel. what caused marshals to start throwing punches and rocks. >> plus the religious and political importance of the two women, pope francis just canonized. we're back in a moment. don't just visit orlando visit tripadvisor orlando tripadvisor not only has millions of real travelers reviews and opinions but checks hundreds of websites so people can get the best hotel prices to plan, compare and book the perfect trip visit tripadvisor.com today >>> welcome back. two 19th century palestinian nuns were given sainthood sunday after pope franciscan nonized the two women. >> but it is another decision the pope announced during the ceremony that has israel upset. oren liebermann has more. >> reporter: a very special day for palestinians and christians as pope francis canonizes two saints, in modern times, since the early days of christianity. that made it a day of celebration, day of awakening and awareness. very few christians, make up 2% of the population. this wreck og nrecognition and a very special day for them.

marshall university issued this statement. let me read this for you. the entire university community is shocked and disappointed to learn the details surrounding the alleged actions that led to mr. butler's arrest. the type of violent bigoted behavior reported to have been perpetrated by this student is not tolerated at marshall university period. this is an extremely serious matter. join managere now, cnn commentator lz granderson. >> hey there, brooke. >> so we know that obviously innocent until proven guilty, in a sense here but are you surprised? we talked about him being kicked off the football team. are you surprised the school itself the university didn't act swifter as well? >> well initially i thought that the school had moved relatively quickly on this after the arrest. but then there's been later reports that i've seen that the police officer that was involved in the investigation actually was somewhat stonewalled by the football team. they didn't right away try to assist and identify who the player was. in fact reportedly the driver of the vehicle that the alleged attacker was riding in was also a football player that the football team has not provided that name to

marshal i , reached the cap on social security. i understand you are opposed? >> i am not going to answer it. good to see you, thank you. mr. pataki: thank you. >> great job. mr. pataki: thank you. thank you so much. >> i need a picture. ready? one more. [inaudible conversations] mr. pataki: thank you so much. >> great job, we are so proud of you. are you kidding me? we are so proud. >> my name is john and i came all the way from maine. mr. pataki: thank you. >> we love to your speech. mr. pataki: thank you, it is about you guys. it is all about the future. i love new hampshire and i love meeting people and talking to them. thank you very much. >> governor, why won't you answer my question? mr. pataki: thank you so much for being here, really appreciate it. thank you. thank you very much. it is about you guys, the next generation. giving you the hope and opportunity. [inaudible conversations] mr. pataki i know my entire life : has prepared me for this moment. i have had great experiences with leading and changing, and i have had tremendous experience dealing with people in the private sector on a little farm growing up in p

mr. tsarnaev will remain in the custody of the u.s. marshals. be mindful there is another -- >>> i'm wolf blitzer in "the situation room." we want to welcome viewers in the united states and around the world. you're watching a live news conference where prosecutors and the phishfbi are discussing the jury's decision of a death sentence for the boston marathon bomber dzhokhar tsarnaev. let's continue to listen. >> >>> -- victims and survivors will have an opportunity to make an impact statement in writing. we've already solicited impact statements from victims and survivors, some will be given an opportunity to be heard in court, obviously. we'll figure that out. there when be a sentencing hearing, the judge will officially issue a sentence and then the defendant will go into the custody of the federal bureau of prisons, and then they will determine whether he goes to adx or goes to terre haute, awaiting the appellate process, but we have nothing to do with that. the federal bureau of prisons will then be in charge. >> [ inaudible ] to a point th

mr. savopoulos lied to them about how and when the $40,000 in ransom was delivered. that assistant was not charged. cash could be another clue. at the scene of the capture thursday night u.s. marshals saw a large stack of what appeared to be $100 bills and others traveling with the suspect but not charged admitted to purchasing money orders after the murders. >> it's about the money. who spent the money. who has the money, who has the money orders. >> reporter: d.c.'s police chief says they believe the family was targeted but the why and the who else is involved remain big questions tonight. kelly o'donnell, nbc news washington. >>> in the plains of north texas tonight lots of anxiety for thousands that live among livers that could rise to record levels as relentless rain keeps pounding that region. we have the latest from nbc's mark potter. >> reporter: after heavy rains during the wettest month on record here the lakes and rivers near wichita falls texas are spilling over. racing the clock, residents are doing whatever they can to protect their homes and businesses before the floods come. hundreds along the wichita river are already obeying evacuation orders taking with them what

mr. savopoulos had, quote, lied to them about when and how the $40,000 in ransom was delivered. that assistant is not charged. cash could be another clue. at the scene of the capture wednesday night, u.s. marshall saw a large stack of what and to be $100 bills. others linked to the suspect but not charged admitted to money orders after the murders. >> it's about the money, who spent the money, who hat money, who has got the money orders. >> reporter: d.c.'s police chief said they believe the family was targeted. but why and who else is involved remain a big question. kelly o'donnell nbc news washington. >>> several people arrested in cleveland, ohio, after a judge found the police officer not guilty in the death of an unarmed black couple. protesters marched through the street after the ruling. the march is remaining peaceful. police donned riot gear. the officer shot and killed timothy russell and malissa williams after a high-speed chase. he was one of 13 officers who fired 137 rounds into the couple's car after it back fired. the prosecution said brelo kept firing after the suspects were subdued. ♪ oh say can you see. >> by the dawn's early light ♪ >> today you can head over to capitol hill

marshall. a as i said, the only officer to join lee inside the house. on most days, mr.bigelow can be found working as a costume interpreter for james monroe. we've asked dennis if he would take a few minutes this i afternoon and share with you hisfternoo perspective of having a family perspe connection to an historic event of such magnitude and reach. mr. dennis bigelow. h >> you've been sitting for a whil while. so you don't need a repeat of what you've heard so well in terms of the particulars of what happened in the mclean house and the surrender.render. so i'm not going to read that out of grandfather marshall's book.ha but, i think, you would like to hear this. punctuated by the loss of a third of the army of northern the virginia at sailor's creek on the 6th of april with nor confederate general gordon having been stopped dead by a sea of general sheridan's blue b coats on the morning of the 9th, general lee knew his shrinking army could not remain whole. and could not break out of its encirclement. cou after four years of arduous service marked by unsurpassed d b

mr. governor, he mention eded a little bit about. i want to know if they are safe and secure in the future, or we are gone from the region? thank you. >> right in front of you, marshall, right there. whoever that is. >> i'm a notary public resident fellow at the council and the question is we're talking about militias, but a big part of it is not proiranian and also has a very fashl stick program. is there a way to cooperate with the groups and use them maybe to bypass the pro-irani militias? >> recent lely appointed to command. what's the thoughts on that and next steps to take to include the security forces? >> one more. right here in front waiting very patiently. >> thank you very much. i'm with -- i've listened to the stories of two survivors, believe me, one main concern had been accountability gap. basically, you're asking for decent relation, powers the main thing, and i wanted to ask you, is the face of iraq has become more secular in nature of democracy, and was it more simpler in nature before kmok? part two is that what do you think time frame, when do you anticipate to people of iraq will start creating democracy? thank you. >> group of excellent question

rudy giuliani called donald trump and asked if he would agree to be the grand marshall of the next parade. because of mr $1 million donation to the parade. on september -- on saturday november 11, almost 1.5 million people watched donald trump march down 5th avenue with over 25,000 veterans. that is the kind of guy donald trump is. [applause] on a personal note, i have gotten a chance to know mr. trump very well over the years. he is an unbelievably generous person. my son, who has been running around here today in the orange shorts picking up chairs, is 12 years old. he turned 12 this week. he has had four brain surgeries and two heart surgeries so i spend a lot of my time trying to raise money for children's hospital. mr. trump, just because he knew griffin and is one of the most generous people i know, has bent over backwards to help me and griffin help the children who still need help at children's hospital. mr. trump is forever in my debt, and forever i will be grateful to him for what he has done and to help me and my family. he has also become one of president obama's sharpest critics, never shyi

mr. rafe don't even talk about. i'd like to know if it's safe and secure in the future or we are gone from the region. thank you. >> right in front of you, marshall wherever that is. >> i'm a resident fellow with the atlantic council. my question is we're talking about militias as a homogeneous group but a big part of it is not pro-iranian. is there a way to cooperate with these groups and use them maybe to bypass the pro iran? >> recently prime minister al badi elected an operations command and what are the next steps that al badi could take to? >> right here in the front. >> there is a high level of turmoil and if i'm listening to the stories of two survivors, believe me, and one of your main concern had been i think the credibility action and word of baghdad and basically you're asking for a decent relation. i want to ask you, has it become a more secular nature of democracy or more secular in nature of democracy and part two is what do you think or anticipate the people of iraq will start the democracy? thank you. >> a group of excellent questions. please feel free to address any and all of this. >> when i keep talking about dismantling milit

mr. president, who in their right mind would give a $50 billion signing bonus to iran? it's worth noting that even under one of the strictest regimes of international sanctions iran was still able to marshall the resources to become one of the world's leading state sponsors of terrorism. we can only imagine what iran will do with this new source of funding, which will certainly flow to hamas to hezbollah and to the human houthis as well as their proxies mr. president, i would note this deal goes into effect and tens or hundreds of billions of dollars flow into iran including $50 billion signing bonus and that money is given directly to radical islamist terrorists. the blood of the men and women and children who will be murdered by those terrorists will be directly on hands of this administration. if we allow tens and hundreds of billions of dollars to flow into the hands of terrorists it places complicity for that terrorism on this administration. care is no topic more serious that his body can consider them preventing the murder of americans. terrain is behavior speaks for itself. they are right now today unlawfully imprisoning multiple american citizens. patrick's i eat obligating me --

leadership on the part of the marshals to pull it off, and there is a great deal of investigation that has to be done in this. we have not heard what is the relationship of wint to mre and did he meet savopoulos at the time, and was he fired or is there a reason he would want revenge against him and use his family to do it torturing his child? killing his wife and housekeeper, and then him eventually and that part of investigation is still, you know going to be requiring an extensive amount of work. they are still going to have extensive work in the house with the forensics to try and determine if anybody else was involved, and do they find other dna in the house that has not been identified? was it already in a database? when you are occupying somebody's house for 12 hours, and you are dropping dna off your skin and hair and fabric material all day, all the time and dna would be dropped. >> when you think of all the events that happened in the course of this commission of this crime, the crime scene will be a lot to go through, and then the fact that he has been on the run and was found with the sum of money on him, and we don't know how much money, and we know a

mr. secretary. and i mentioned in my introduction to situation over at this critical those with the iranian navy seizing the marshallnds flag vessel, and i wonder if you could bring us up-to-date, if there's anything new to report on the situation from the navy perspective. >> there has been no change in terms of the situation, at least at 11:00 when i headed down this way. we have the three patrol craft in the region. we have the uss farragut their a guided missile destroyer in the region, and i think it's a pretty good example of presence to give our leaders options. so whatever our leadership decides, they've got a whole range of options because of those naval assets. >> to see is a busy place these days with piracy of the lord the horn of africa unrest around the arabian gulf, and migrants fleeing africa and the mediterranean. how is the navy handling its multiplicity of missions? and they feel you have sufficient resources? and osha our allies be hoping? >> i know this come up on cards but then i ask you asked the question of? is a good reason i'm asking come it's not a bad reason. first question gets the coin

mr. president who in their right mind would give a 50 billion-dollar signing bonus to iran? it's worth noting that even under one of the strictest regimes of international sanctions iran was still able to marshal the resources to become one of the world's leading state sponsors of terrorism. we can only imagine what iran will do with this new source of funding which will certainly blow to hamas to hezbollah and the houthis as well as to their proxies in latin america. mr. president i would note this deal goes into effect and tends and hundreds of billions of dollars flowing to iran including a $50 billion signing bonus and that money is given directly to radical islamic terrorists. the men, women and children who will be murdered by those terrorists will be going directly into the hands of this administration. if we allowed tens of hundreds of billions of dollars to flow into the hands of terrorists in places complicity for that terrorism on this administration paid there is no topic more serious this body could consider them preventing the murder of americans. the iranian behavior speaks for itself. they are right now today i'm awfully imprisoning multiple american citizens. amir hekmati as w

mr. marshall, and so weinberger had left the pentagon and if you could do think there's this hallway of their portraits of all the former defense secretaries and the day came when they're going, there was a ceremony they're going to unveil weinberger's portrait. marshall wasn't invited to they didn't have a good relationship. they're going to pick up the flags and the chairs and so finally we are in the outer office and marshall is there and what my colleagues said to him are you going the weinberger ceremony? and he said very uncharacteristically i would go if they were hanging weinberger instead of this picture last night so it wasn't -- everybody appreciating what marshall had to offer. the other thing i would say is no matter what happened in terms of the ups and downs of the relationship with the defense secretaries, two other things really stand out. one is his mentor the people at the impact it has. in 1957, marshall suggests a topic and then zipping profiled which ends up winning all kinds of book award from medal of freedom from president bush i think in 1990 and it fundamentally has