. >> deborah reinboldt comes forward with a story that says, well, i was with herb and randy that night, and they invited me to come along with them to the rhoads' house. >> what position was karen rhoads in? was she trying to leave and you caught her? >> no, i didn't caught her. >> she was just lying there, watching steidl and whitlock stab her husband? >> yes. the stories from the key witnesses left callahan with a glaring question. >> they made this case based on these two eyewitnesss, but the yie eyewitnesss contradict each other. >> darryl harrington was supposed to have been at the same scene, and her story doesn't include him, and his story doesn't include her. >> they never saw each other, never knew one or another was there. that was a problem for me as a police officer. >> but this discrepancy didn't seem to bother lead prosecutor mike mcpat ridge or assistant state's attorney mike zoff. >> the reinboldt presentation was consistent with the physical evidence that i had. for example, she talked about a broken lamp. one of the firefighters, he found the same thing. in my view, t