meeting to have scan fra*ns board of appeals, we are on item number 9, appeal number 16-084, brandon eberhart versus department ofing inspection, 1619a laguna street, appeal thing issuance on april 25, 2016 to mariya semika toe va of an al ration permit. we will salter with the appellant. you have 7 minutes to present your case. >> good evening, members of the board, my name's sal va tor him can know, i represent the appellant, brandon eberhart, he's been a residential tenant at the property since december 1, 2015. on april 25th, a permit was applied for and it's on the overhead. to remove kitchen cabinets and a sink. the permit is defective on its face because on 7a, it lists the current use as commercial, and page 2 of that permit indicates to me that it wasn't reviewed by planning, and my understanding is if you want to remove items from an in-law unit or unpermitted residential unit, it should be reviewed by planning, and this was not. mr. eberhart rented the unit partially furnished, had a bed in it. it was rented to him residentially. we have a copy of the first page of the residential

meeting to have scan fra*ns board of appeals, we are on item number 9, appeal number 16-084, brandon eberhart versus department ofing inspection, 1619a laguna street, appeal thing issuance on april 25, 2016 to mariya semika toe va of an al ration permit. we will salter with the appellant. you have 7 minutes to present your case. >> good evening, members of the board, my name's sal va tor him can know, i represent the appellant, brandon eberhart, he's been a residential tenant at the property since december 1, 2015. on april 25th, a permit was applied for and it's on the overhead. to remove kitchen cabinets and a sink. the permit is defective on its face because on 7a, it lists the current use as commercial, and page 2 of that permit indicates to me that it wasn't reviewed by planning, and my understanding is if you want to remove items from an in-law unit or unpermitted residential unit, it should be reviewed by planning, and this was not. mr. eberhart rented the unit partially furnished, had a bed in it. it was rented to him residentially. we have a copy of the first page of the residential