letter read by supervisor tang and agree with everything all the remarks with former supervisor carmen chu having an idea of a stop at the 28 and tara value for only people in the stops is absolutely absorb not heard of anything as rid as that and i would also like to say that i agree that there should be more stops for wheelchair assessable stops than now thank you very much. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please. >> is larry lee here move on (calling names). >> good afternoon. >> good afternoon. >> my name is marianne i'm a citizen of san francisco united states for i live in san francisco terryville street for 40 years and used to commute almost everyday. >> but the 28 stop is very important to me, i'm a senior now right now i could be able to move but i do not know when i may not be able to move as well as see i supposed to be if. >> cut off our staff so i canned walk the hill going up and down and not just me a lot of seniors and disabled people when they want to shop and carry something and go home and walk so long up this - the to get home won't be able to make it then those people

e steemdz supervisor president london breed and former mayor willie brown and mark leon 0 i saw carmen chucorder i hope not to miss anyone else for the buena vista for the administration of those buildings

. >> by carmen chu so ms. chu to come forward and offer thoughts >> good afternoon. >> good afternoon to the mta board first thank you. allowing me to speak i want to number one appreciate the difficult job you have i know that any changes that the mta proposes not one that is easy nor is it often easier to be able to balance the needs you currently have and thank you for supervisor tang's office and raising some of the concerns of residents the riders and the businesses today, i am come to speak not as a supervisor, of course, but i come to speak as a private resident that has observations and concerns about the proposal first, i do want to say i support your decision to have pilots and i'm glad you heard the local businesses around the proposals you're taking efforts to evaluate how those are working before the intrusive measures i want to implore you in gather not having the solutions before you've seen the pilot and evaluate its effect fines that its been a long time coming to build trust with the communit

. >> by carmen chu so ms. chu to come forward and offer thoughts >> good afternoon. >> good afternoon to the mta board first thank you. allowing me to speak i want to number one appreciate the difficult job you have i know that any changes that the mta proposes not one that is easy nor is it often easier to be able to balance the needs you currently have and thank you for supervisor tang's office and raising some of the concerns of residents the riders and the businesses today, i am come to speak not as a supervisor, of course, but i come to speak as a private resident that has observations and concerns about the proposal first, i do want to say i support your decision to have pilots and i'm glad you heard the local businesses around the proposals you're taking efforts to evaluate how those are working before the intrusive measures i want to implore you in gather not having the solutions before you've seen the pilot and evaluate its effect fines that its been a long time coming to build trust with the communit

e steemdz supervisor president london breed and former mayor willie brown and mark leon 0 i saw carmen chu assessor-recorder i hope not to miss anyone else for the buena vista for the administration of those buildings we have among naomi kelly the city administrator and other appointed officials i want to single out for special recognition the war memorial managing drooshgs ethically murray (clapping (clapping.) she has been the heart of the project and its vision for nearly 20 years i want to recognize san francisco public works city architecture edgar lopez and san francisco arts commission decoration tom deacon i didn't i want to significantly out public works veterans building pg&e tara relay la monday night (clapping) if beth were the heart of the project tara was it's soul i'd like to acknowledge andy are you mellone and solace a project of this scope doesn't get accomplished without additional partners and i'd like to recognize a number of them on behalf of the san francisco post to the american legion a nelson the commander the integrity and paul chair of the american legacy war me

was appointed by mayor ed lee to serve as district 4 representative replacing previous supervisor carmen chur she was appointed assessor reporter that same month. before her appointment she served as legislative aide to supervisor chiu. today you'll get to know her and the issues facing the city. welcome, supervisor. thank you for join using us. >> thank you for having me. >> let's start with a little about your background. where you grew up, went to school and what kind of jobs you had in the past. >> sure, i grew up in the sunset district. still live there. spent about 20 years living in the sunset district and just am so proud to be able to represent the district that i grew up in and where my parents still live. i had gone through the public education system and went to neighborhood schools throughout the sunset district. so, had gone to francis scott key elementary school, hoover middle school, lowell high school and am just so proud to be able to come back full circle to support a lot of those schools that i went to and be part of that community in a very integral way. >> so, you spent

i'm here on behalf of councilmember carmen chu. he want to be an issue as they do share some words. carmen has great support for james. he's been outstanding dedicated commissioner serving as a top leader. he listens to the public various constituencies and takes action to prove the lies surrounding. i think it's proven by the number people in the room to get sure there's a bigger room and be a bigger audience. these are the qualities that cannot and should not be overlooked as the puc commissioner and we urge you to vote in support of reappointment having this service commissioner. thank you so much >> thank you so much. next speaker, please. >> i'm robert watkins. i'm a longtime employee of the city. the work for parking that over 35 years. that's been involved in labor and my moms involved in late. i'm here to sport this courtney for reappointment. he is, like the supervisors he's right or that. he's for working class people. and creating jobs. i'm also on the friendship board and i watch what he does. he's a great guy. thank you

i'm here on behalf of councilmember carmen chu. he want to be an issue as they do share some words. carmen has great support for james. he's been outstanding dedicated commissioner serving as a top leader. he listens to the public various constituencies and takes action to prove the lies surrounding. i think it's proven by the number people in the room to get sure there's a bigger room and be a bigger audience. these are the qualities that cannot and should not be overlooked as the puc commissioner and we urge you to vote in support of reappointment having this service commissioner. thank you so much >> thank you so much. next speaker, please. >> i'm robert watkins. i'm a longtime employee of the city. the work for parking that over 35 years. that's been involved in labor and my moms involved in late. i'm here to sport this courtney for reappointment. he is, like the supervisors he's right or that. he's for working class people. and creating jobs. i'm also on the friendship board and i watch what he does. he's a great guy. thank you

i'm here on behalf of councilmember carmen chu. he want to be an issue as they do share some words. carmen has great support for james. he's been outstanding dedicated commissioner serving as a top leader. he listens to the public various constituencies and takes action to prove the lies surrounding. i think it's proven by the number people in the room to get sure there's a bigger room and be a bigger audience. these are the qualities that cannot and should not be overlooked as the puc commissioner and we urge you to vote in support of reappointment having this service commissioner. thank you so much >> thank you so much. next speaker, please. >> i'm robert watkins. i'm a longtime employee of the city. the work for parking that over 35 years. that's been involved in labor and my moms involved in late. i'm here to sport this courtney for reappointment. he is, like the supervisors he's right or that. he's for working class people. and creating jobs. i'm also on the friendship board and i watch what he does. he's a great guy. thank you

witnessed the actions of the board and don durrant and the assessor's office under phil tang and no carmen chu and chief appraiser matt thomas as well as the board and the additional board three to accommodate the dominantly homeowners in the evening with their appeals and all of us about to make dramatic changes in how we became more efficient, more knowledgeable andcapable particularly at the assessor's office coming before the board. i'm an opportunity to do that as well as interpret the revenue and taxation codes board of equalization, assessor's handbook and it's been a great experience. i'm looking forward, i'm energized and want to be reappointed to another three-year term. so if you have any questions on the happy to answer them but thank you for your consideration as he was shortened i think that just for all the applicants were here today, just to speak to kind of the set of criteria or values you use as you are evaluating these appeals i come before you from more difficult than others. how you make your decisions going forward so he could speak a little bit to that may be also offer

i'm here on behalf of councilmember carmen chu. e want to be an issue as they do share some words. carmen has great support for james. he's been outstanding dedicated commissioner serving as a top leader. he listens to the public various constituencies and takes action to prove the lies surrounding. i think it's proven by the number people in the room to get sure there's a bigger room and be a bigger audience. these are the qualities that cannot and should not be overlooked as the puc commissioner and we urge you to vote in support of reappointment having this service commissioner. thank you so much >> thank you so much. next speaker, please. >> i'm robert watkins. i'm a longtime employee of the city. the work for parking that over 35 years. that's been involved in labor and my moms involved in late. i'm here to sport this courtney for reappointment. he is, like the supervisors he's right or that. he's for working class people. and creating jobs. i'm also on the friendship board and i watch what he does. he's a great guy. thank you.

witnessed the actions of the board and don durrant and the assessor's office under phil tang and no carmen chu and chief appraiser matt thomas as well as the board and the additional board three to accommodate the dominantly homeowners in the evening with their appeals and all of us about to make dramatic changes in how we became more efficient, more knowledgeable andcapable particularly at the assessor's office coming before the board. i'm an opportunity to do that as well as interpret the revenue and taxation codes board of equalization, assessor's handbook and it's been a great experience. i'm looking forward, i'm energized and want to be reappointed to another three-year term. so if you have any questions on the happy to answer them but thank you for your consideration as he was shortened i think that just for all the applicants were here today, just to speak to kind of the set of criteria or values you use as you are evaluating these appeals i come before you from more difficult than others. how you make your decisions going forward so he could speak a little bit to that may be also offer