rolewas, what relative does the government play in the lives of individuals and what seed towe individuals our government or from judge rightsperspective, what did our government confer on us. that is the issue. it is as old as the constitution. senator hatch is very eloquent, and i mean this sincerely, his very eloquent statement on , this is andge bork individual we are speaking of. a man of honor and integrity. but notwithstanding the fact that i must tell you honestly i feel sorry for him -- those sitting home at this moment watching this nomination go down and feeling, because we have all been there at one point in our lives, the personal loss he must feel at this moment. with all due respect this is not about judge bork, it is about the constitution. the resolution of a debate in its most fundamental form that can be put in my view as follows "do i have certain inalienable ,ights merely because i exist or do i have those rights because my government has ."nferred them upon me is the latter, mine is the former. thatnever had any doubt once those issues were framed, the e.u., my collea