but if you read catherine newton's report, it isa read catherine newton's report, it is a holistic viewh interest on one aspect between dan ashworth and i would like to ask rachel to add comments to that. we will come on to other members of the panel, but i think, you know, i think you've spoken about this and you're the one that wrote to the committee about the process. catherine newton was clear in her statement, as far as she is concerned there is no grievance for players in that this position and that's what eniola aluko said. when someone that's what eniola aluko said. when someone who is co leading an internal review is supplying evidence to that review as well. that's a very poor example of due process and that's why i asked you again whether you feel it is not just lessons to be learnt, but an apology should be given for the process which was not fit for purpose. one of the reasons we asked an independent barrister in was to give us the benefit of a fresh pair of eyes on the process and i think that was right. we took the concerns and the complaints seriously. we followed them i

chief executive and rachel brace hr director at wembley that perhaps they had tried to steer catherine newtonhe fa officials saying that they had tried to conduct an open and clear investigation. in the last few moments we've heard from the fa chairman himself who has said he is not happy with the way things have gone but nevertheless he wanted to have a better system for whistle—blowers to come forward. so that there is a more acceptable environment for people to make grievances if they have them. many thanks for the update. this is bbc news at five — the headlines: ministers have been forced to abandon charges for calling a helpline about the new universal credit system — after strong criticism from campaigners and mp5. the nhs is failing to meet performance targets for cancer, a&e and planned operations at hospitals across the uk according to bbc research. the football association has apologised to two female england players who were found to have been discriminated against by coach mark sampson. manchester united manager jose mourinho has played down speculation linking him with a move to