patrick houlihan and martin and fiona delany have so far made no comment. angus crawford, bbc news. the paradise papers also include revelations that the queen‘s private estate invested offshore, and that president trump‘s commerce secretary, wilbururchase the controversial retailer brighthouse and 75% of first quench, which used to own threshers, which went bust owing £70 million in tax. brighthouse has been accused of exploiting low income families and the financial conduct authorities ordered to pay almost £15 million in compensation to a quarter of a million customers. the duchy says it‘s only a small stake worth only £3208. the duchy told us that all of our investments fully audited and legitimate. if a very wealthy person wants to avoid taxation in britain, and therefore put money into a tax haven somewhere, who loses? schools? hospitals? housing? all those public services lose. and the rest of the population have to pay to cover up the deficit created by that. the documents also reveal that wilbur ross, us commerce secretary, has business links with russian allies of president putin. mr ross has a secret stake in a shipping company called navigator holdings. one of their major clients is an energy company, sibur. putin‘s a