dr burka if i could start with you let's let's just look at some of the the confrontations you speak slowly i don't understand a word of your question ok i do knows the world unfortunately ok well but about to come to his first yes israel israeli police confront protesters with riot gear and armored vehicles do you think it's a proportionate use of force. well first of all happy new year for everybody who watches and answered the question we are all the time asked for proportionality even when gaza strip launch missiles on israel and kill israeli civilians when we are back and people are killed somebody rushed to say please proportionality you know in war there is no proportionality and would you please ask those who bombed to dresden at the second world war so this is one point to take into account the other thing is the habit of palestinians to use tel means including bumping kidnapping airplanes and then complain about the really knowledgeable person i sponsor this is. yes of course fox all what we see now in the territories is permanent incitement for people to come and convert i