e-commerce sales up 33 and in the release doug mcmillin called the result solid adding, quote, we arensforming to better serve customers. we're changing from within to be faster and more digital while shaping our portfolio of businesses for the future and we provide flexibility to do so the e-commerce number reind moos us of the 23 number we got last quarter which was quickly followed by the worst day for shares in three decades. >> we have to get away from judging these companies only on e-commerce because the only standard we use now is how they're doing against amazon everything is zero sum jesus, they declined from 33 to 23 then amazon must have picked that up and we have to reevaluate walmart we ought to stop that. there are going to be quarterly fluctuations online. i think that they have a good online business. 33% is great we did the same thing with target, by the way target, the brick and mortar didn't matter. they had acceleration online, boom >> i think what we ought to be judging is a little bit more holistically of which walmart had good traffic and that's the kind of thi