with the necessary skills and expertise to continue to engage in that particular program and douglas chapman joins me know welcome to the alex salmond sure that's very much there but the prime minister about his joy there but she seemed to concede that the minister of defense will no putting out to white tend across the world a range of ship building contractors. you know when we look back to the ship building stance she was only last year you know people who work in the ship building this and she really thought the future was looking a bit greater however this latest announcement we have contracts and they're going to international tender means that british jobs squashed jobs are being sucked shipyards and you know the future for these workers is us but doesn't the prime minister have a point i mean the range of ships being put out to tender are not ships are likely carriers which have been built to your can states if serviceable ships are required for the navy and should write the public money and value for public money is the prime consideration well i think the been a whole range of diff