and what about scott birtwhistle, now he is out ofjail.iew commission reviewed this case last year and called it a compelling prosecution case. the ipcc and police watchdogs have looked into specific allegations made by clients against police officers and they came back saying there was no wrongdoing. what is the new stuff you say you are picking up that you believe will prove the men's innocence? neither the ipcc nor the criminal cases review commission examined the case in the depth that we have. we now have evidence that shows that the jury we re evidence that shows that the jury were misled at trial as to the positioning of the two vessels. this is about disclosure, an issue that has been in the news quite a lot recently. disclosure is the amount of information the police provide to the other side in a case, to the defence. in this case, even the experts testifying at trial were not given access to all the information they needed to get it right and present a complete the picture, so the experts, jury and judge for all misled. in the e