we took that -- it was turned down by the appellant and we took it to the planning department and flatley rejected by the preservation staff and said that there's no way they'll approve anything with less than a 15-foot setback from valencia street. so it's basically meet their demands or meet the neighbors and lose the square footage. >> clerk: thank you. sorry, you'll have time on rebuttal. thank you. >> thank you, good evening, president fung and commissioners. the project at 645 valencia is within the commercial transit zoning district and i think that the project sponsor gave a very thorough history, the background of the history of the project. first came into the department for review in 2013, that environmental review and p.p.a. are preliminary project assessment were submitted at that time. it was to be a demolition and new construction with nine new units. as the department was reviewing it and as the noted evolution of the historic importance of the building, the project was changed from a demolition, new construction to an alteration to maintain the existing building which is