ms. swan has shown a pattern of knowingly violating rules and regulations of the planning department. by having short-term rentals in her residence and has been fined and illegally occupying this retail space. if the commission approves this c.u, like was said before, you'd be setting a precedent for anyone else. if you have rules, let's follow them. i kind of agree, why have a c.u. it says you don't do this, you don't do it. it says you can do this, then it's okay. she's not where she is supposed to be. she can go around the corner or that would be fine. that's all. >> commissioner: thank you, very much. next speaker, please. >> good afternoon. my name is colleen acosta. me husband and i lived in noe valley a little over a year and before that we lived elsewhere in san francisco but we'd often venture to noe valley and because it was a family area and we'd walk down and looking at the merchants. over the last four and a half years we've been in san francisco we have noticed a significant incr