so first speaker henrich alberts. >> interview: hi, i'm henrich albert speaking for the sierra club for the san francisco bay chapter of the sierra club. i'd like to speak about the volunta voluntary settlement agreement we've been talk about. and thank you very much. the commissioners raised good questions about that. i was in the water board's meeting on december 12th when the voluntary agreement was announced publicly. we event -- haven't seen details before and we weren't categorically opposed to voluntary settlement agreement, if there's a good one, we're for it. i was encouraged to see there was something concrete. as i say, we hadn't really seen anything. now that we've had a chance to analyze this, i'm disappointed to say this is basically a sham. i have here an analysis that possibly some of you folks have already seen. this was done by barry nelson on behalf of the golden gate salmon association. i have copies for all of you folks here. i'd like to go over it just briefly. the whole analysis is brief. but basically it points out four key defects. the first is science. this agr