well that was yahoo henri from the palestinian policy think tank al shabab speaking with us earlier artless get some more analysis on this peace plan to do that i'm joined by professor natasha lindstedt with the government department at the university of essex in the u.k. professor instead is a commentator on middle east politics and development policies professor it's good to have you on the program i want to ask you what came to your mind 1st today when you heard about jared plan. i think what came to my mind is similar to what a lot of people the way a lot of people have reacted to this it just doesn't seem very credible he himself here is not a very credible or trustworthy person in the region he hasn't really earned the respect of both sides he seems to have a good relationship or at least good working relationship with the israelis in for a quick amount of time but he has absolutely no credibility from the palestinians they see him as someone that they can't trust in any way shape or form and i think what everybody also is thinking is that as the reported already mention this doesn't