the first one is -- i heard -- for 3 aseats 3 and 4, the amendments i had introduced was changing the appointing authority for those two seats, taking it away from the mayor and board of supervisors and giving it to the college and associated students. upon further consideration, i wanted to propose that we keep those two seats -- one -- seat 3 appointed by the mayor and seat 4 appointed by the board of supervisors but add an additional seat, a student seat that is appointed by the associated students. i mean, i think in terms of amending the ordinance, it probably would be best that what i'm proposing as a third seat to be held by a student at city college and be appointed by the associated student -- city college associated student so that would go best as seat five, and then all the other seats from seat 5 on would get bumped a number higher. city attorney givner, does that sound -- yes? and then there -- there was a question raised about seat 141234 it's a nonvoting seat held by the student trustee who's a member of the college board? is there a reason why that's a nonvoting seat